News and Events > Arts & Entertainment News

Rachel McKinnon?

<< < (2/2)

Devlyn:

--- Quote from: emma-f on October 22, 2019, 09:50:36 am ---I think with Dr McKinnon its 2 things:

1. The first is that there remains much debate as what ought to be the requirements for a transwomen to compete in female sports. The fact that the UCI / IAAF / IOC etc have various guidelines does not mean that people have to agree with them. They are very controversial and I know a great number of cis-people who are not transphobic (and indeed transwomen) who consider that the present regulations are too lenient (or indeed too strict).

I don't see the article as transphobic at all. In fact its interesting that they even pointed out "After concerns about transgender athletes having an advantage in the Rio 2016 Olympics, Loughborough University in England conducted a study by reviewing 31 national and international sporting policies, including those of the International Olympic Committee, the Football Association and the Lawn Tennis Association. The study concluded that a majority of policies unfairly discriminated against transgender people, especially trans women". For foxnews it actually appears to be surprisingly neutral.

2. I'm afraid she doesn't do herself any favours on twitter.  Last week she suggested that the only morally acceptable sexuality was being pansexual. Now whilst I can kind of see what she is on about (ie. that you should fall in love with a person, not their gender or their genitals) funnily enough heterosexual / gay / lesbian people don't like it being suggested that they are immoral merely because they are attracted to a certain gender.

--- End quote ---

I agree, I read the article twice, and didn't see anything transphobic about the reporting at all. BlueJaye, are we missing something? Your posts seem to indicate that Fox did something wrong in this story.

BlueJaye:
I would have to go back to the original Facebook post, I think the link that was posted was titled differently from the actual article.

Sent from my SM-A205U using Tapatalk

Matinaz:
It is difficult to explain.

Outlaw Jenny:
I too fail to see the transphobia of the Fox News article. If anything, it defended trans people lol.

DebbySoufflage:
I think Rachel McKinnon sometimes is too quick to yell transphobia.
Rachel in my humble opinion obviously has an advantage over the majority of cis women athletes. I wonder if Rachel complies with the prohibition of performance enhancers. DHEA is available over the counter and hard to prove.
McKinnon is also very aggressive quite quickly on social media from what I have seen from her.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page

Go to full version