A big chunk of the "Trans Trender" label is fueled by the desistance mythos, which is built around a set of incorrect assumptions about gender nonconforming youth. The desistance mythos claims that most 'transgender youth' will desist from being transgender.
- Bad Assumption: Gender-nonconforming is transgender
- Bad Assumption: A person who stops appearing as gender-nonconforming does so forever
Young people may decide to explore this crazy cultural phenomenon we call
gender. It may be from curiosity, a sense of rebellion, an internal need, or a desire to match others in a peer group. These gender explorers form a large group that sociologists call
gender nonconforming.
A few of these
gender nonconforming individuals may display a
persistent, insistent, and consistent gender identity over a period of 6 months or more. These are individuals who may actually be
transgender persons. Note that others may be transgender persons as well, as not all transgender persons demonstrate gender nonconforming traits visible to others, but instead learn to hide, courtesy of the social pressures around them. 👋
In the
desistance myth, all persons displaying
gender nonconforming behaviors are assumed to be transgender, and when they stop displaying this behavior they are assumed to
desist from being transgender forever. These are the two bad assumptions at work.
Most
gender nonconforming youth won't meet that test of displaying a
persistent, insistent, and consistent gender identity over a period of 6 months or more. When they stop presenting
gender nonconforming behavior they have not 'stopped being transgender', as they were probably not transgender to start with.
Some
gender nonconforming youth might be transgender persons, but rather than push on against social pressure from others, including parents, religious leaders, and peers, are forced into hiding. When hiding, with the inevitable eventual onset of anxiety and depression, does not mean that they have 'stopped being transgender'.
A small portion of these
gender nonconforming youth
will be diagnosed as being transgender and may proceed to transition and live a happy and healthy life as their authentic selves. The
desistance mythos is constructed specifically to discredit these individuals and drag them down.
I would emphasize that it is not our task in life to pass judgement on others. Rather, we need to pay attention to ourselves, and seek the care or treatment that we may need on our path through life. We are ultimately responsible for ourselves. People must be free to explore themselves, and whether they decide a certain path is appropriate for themselves, or decide to change paths is entirely their responsibility. The imposition of external judgement and condemnation, whether for being gender nonconforming or a transgender person, is not appropriate, and should be avoided.