Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

What’s more important to you ? Acceptance or blending in/passing

Started by Anatta, August 14, 2011, 06:28:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

What's more important to you ?

Acceptance I don't care if my appearance doesn't quite match my psycho-sexual identity
2 (3.6%)
Blending in/passing It's more important for me to look the part without question
22 (40%)
Self Acceptance-when I can fully accept myself I won't care what others think...
12 (21.8%)
All of the above
11 (20%)
Not sure
1 (1.8%)
Don't care
1 (1.8%)
Other= personal option-please explain
6 (10.9%)

Total Members Voted: 54

RhinoP

I personally believe that every Trans, wether they want to admit it or not, has a certain level of characteristics from the desired sex that they want to obtain before they can walk out into public with sanity and confidence still attached - that is, unless they actually take pride in appearing strange or contradictory, something that some Trans do take pride in for sexual, personal, or religious reasons. In this day and age though, harassment, discrimination, and fear cause most Trans to still want to be passable at least to the "confusing" level, a point where strangers at least have to do a double-take, or at least where people do not point and laugh. I believe most of the Trans out there do want to eventually be confused for the sex they want to be, even eventually being always taken for the chosen gender. Many also want to be seen as handsome or pretty, two descriptions that make up some of the most important romantic emotions in sexual identities themselves.

Wether this level of characteristics is simply a wig, dress, and heels, or reaches farther into both facial and body surgery or hormonal changes, every Transperson obviously partakes in some sort of physical change, and every Trans obviously has a different level of innate passability concerning physical features. As in the psychiatry of 'normal people', the importance of appearance to a human being directly involves a person's history of trauma, current sociological age and society, and family-career surroundings, all of which are things that are no less important than the identity of being Transsexual. The simple facts are that most people want to wake up in the morning and see the person they are on the inside represented on the outside. Where as "normal people" live a constant merging of soul and appearance (and thus, with ease, feel that their body and face well-represents their soul), Trans-people live a lifestyle where, because of the way native hormones work, the soul divides with the body's growth and appearance every day the person is living; that is, until they get hormone therapy or various surgeries, many of which many Trans can't afford.

A Transperson usually wants to pass for many reasons; my personal reasons are that, in my age group, trans who do not pass are constantly bullied and threatened, that in my age group, trans who do not pass are not considered physically attractive even by Trans-friendly people and potential partners, and that I simply feel suicidal and depressed if I cannot start my day passing, or at least encompassing in a personal way, the gender I prefer. As my face and body continue to age (balding, hair grown, facial structure, ect ect), the strength to do this has all but vanished and I, for some time now, have been literally forced by my emotions and physical defects to live as the man my body wanted me to be. I still try to socialize with people my own age (early 20's) and simply no one my age, not even the most trans-friendly person, can "see" a balding, hairy male as female, no matter how hard they try.

  •  

Pippa

I want to be the person in my head, not what others see and I am working towards that goal.  I accept myself as I am but I want to improve what I am.  Friends and Family accepting me for who I am is important and I couldn't think of being without them.  What I am really concerned about is that they will not accept the real me.  However, I an aware that sacrifices have to be made during transition and life will not be like it was before (thank god).  I just hope that one of the sacrifices I don't have to make is my family.
  •  

Virginia

(Bigender unicorn here)
The sad reality is, although the people in our lives may accept our transgender nature, once we come out to them, we will never be treated as cisgender again. That is vital for keeping my dysphoria at bay, regardless of whether I am presenting as a guy or a girl and it is the reason the only people who know about my gender are my close family, therapist and the doctors who take care of my routine health care/prescribe my HRT. But the price of stealth is a big one; living a lie to everyone we know and never being accepted for who we truly are. Your choice; Scylla or Charybdis.
~VA (pronounced Vee- Aye, the abbreviation for the State of Virginia where I live)
  •  

Steph

The only thing that matters is your happiness, for if you can't be happy what's the point.  Many people here where I live know about me and my past it couldn't be hidden, my friends know about me, my fellow workers and those I supervised know of/about me, I accepted.  However on the other hand (Four fingers and a thumb) the vast majority of folks in this city of 120,000 know nothing of me, I blend in.  I was married June 25th this year to a most wonderful man, at Pub we frequent with our family and friends and anyone else who happened to be at the pub during the ceremony consequently there were those who knew and the rest didn't have a clue.

Simply put, find a balance, live your life and most important of all be happy otherwise you'll drive yourself crazy.
Enjoy life and be happy.  You won't be back.

WARNING: This body contains nudity, sexuality, and coarse language. Viewer discretion is advised. And I tend to rub folks the wrong way cause I say it as I see it...

http://www.facebook.com/switzerstephanie
  •  

varelse

Acceptance Is definitely something I want from the people I know, but blending in with unfamiliar people who would simply see me and id me as 'girl' is also something I long for. I really dont like conflict of any kind, and if they simply see me as a taller than average female, then it would make everything much more bearable.
  •  

Josh

Quote from: TheAwesomePrussia on August 19, 2011, 01:59:37 PM
Acceptance from close friends. Passing/blending from acquaintances and strangers. And acceptance for myself. Acceptance and validation from others helps my confidence, but nothing beats just reminding myself that I'm proud of who I am.

Pretty much same. And if acquaintances and strangers find out, I really dont care as long as they respect it. I dont care if people know Imma transguy, as long as they respect it.

I am proud of who I am. I identify as a straight male but I know that Im trans. The majority of people I know know me as full male and dont know Im trans anyway. :)
  •  

Jillieann Rose

I voted for Blending in/passing It's more important for me to look the part without question
That's because I all ready have Self Acceptance - I fully accept myself.
But I do care what others think and want them to see me as a women.
  •  

RAY

try to do all because its hard enough to live in times like this
  •  

gantz

If i have to choose I would go for passing. why, i just think its more logical. if you can blend in, what really is the need for acceptance. first off, must you even tell them what you originally were? if they cant tell anyway. yeah maybe thats a fiendish way to look at things but tahts how i feel honestly about this.

without blending in theres just too much room for unwanted things. is that worth the trade for a little bit of acceptance? sure acceptance is good and needed but not from everybody. to our loved ones and people that we care about, yeah acceptance is important. but from these strangers who dont care whom we may never see again ever... i dont care what they think i just dont want their bull->-bleeped-<- being thrown at me thats all.
  •  

TheAwesomePrussia

Quote from: Kal(eb) on August 23, 2011, 08:03:18 PM
Pretty much same. And if acquaintances and strangers find out, I really dont care as long as they respect it. I dont care if people know Imma transguy, as long as they respect it.

I am proud of who I am. I identify as a straight male but I know that Im trans. The majority of people I know know me as full male and dont know Im trans anyway. :)

Most of the people I've met after I came out and started living full-time just know me as male (I'm pretty glad for my dad's genes, even pre-t I pass most of the time). And most of my friends from before say that they really never actually saw me as female, just "me".
I've had a few acquaintances and strangers who found out, usually because family slipped up with pronouns or because I'm with a few of my other friends who are trans, some of whom don't really pass yet and sometimes need a little help explaining to someone who's unfamiliar with trans issues why they should be referred to as "he" when they read as the other gender.

But other than that, later down the road I'd like for close friends that I make, as in, real friends, to know and accept me. Like it or not, my past, my trauma, and my experiences are all part of what helped shape my personality today. And I feel when I have a friendship like that, the other person deserves to know that.
  •  

straycat

I put all of the above because I think those things are interrelated and all important to me.  Acceptance and self acceptance though has the most impact on my day to day happiness. 
  •  

shelley

Quote from: TheAwesomePrussia on August 19, 2011, 01:59:37 PM
Acceptance from close friends. Passing/blending from acquaintances and strangers. And acceptance for myself. Acceptance and validation from others helps my confidence, but nothing beats just reminding myself that I'm proud of who I am.

I couldn't have worded it any better myself.

Would be fantastic and greedy to have both though, although confidence is a huge part in passing, aswell as looks. If you don't let people get the vibe that your worried about how people think of you, i think thats half the battle to passing.
  •