I'm starting to really like Maura or Laura. Maura Lundy, Laura Lundy, hmmm... I don't want a middle name. Margaret is sort of old ladyish, mostly because of Ms. Thatcher and the fact that it had a surge in popularity in the early 20th century; thus a lot of elderly Margarets. I think my mom has mentioned hating the name too.
Michelle is nice but it reminds me of "shell", which isn't one of my favorite words. Natalie rhymes with my last name so it doesn't "flow" properly.
Update: I think I'm going to go with Laura!!!!!!!! I've been juggling Laura, Maura, and Margaret for a long while. Just reading "Laura Lundy" is really satisfying to me. I'm going to think hard about this for a week or so before I really commit to it, though.