Not to be too picky, but SRV was not exactly much of a rock player - he was good when he got around to it, but it wasn't his bag. But I have no trouble listing him as one of the top white blues guitar players of all time. And that's good, because blues was never about originality, but about playing with feeling, which he did very well. He also used the thickest guitar strings I've ever seen on an axe outside of Dick Dale.
Yeah Jeff likes the '57 strat body with a '62 neck. He has an awesome guitar tech, for sure on that.
And yeah, Blind Faith was what? About 69, with Layla and Other Love Songs in 70. Then what. Even if I give you Slowhand, that's '77 - and then what? 35 years with not much? That's a lot of not much.
But look at Beck. From the Yardbirds, to his own band with releases in 68, 69, 71, and 72. Truth* and Beck-Ola still sound great. Then he gets together with what was left of the Vanilla Fudge and did Beck, Bogert & Appice in 73. Then in '75 (this is right where Eric is starting to just go through the motions), he did another solo record, Blow by Blow with the awesome 'Cause We Ended As Lovers. Now this was different. It was not blues like the earlier stuff, it was much more jazz orientated - so, right there as 'jazz fusion' is being invented by Miles and other jazz cats, Beck is just about the only rock musician to go the other way. Then he did the Upp deal, a little funky (as is befitting the person that Stevie Wonder wrote Superstition for.) Then in '76 does Wired with Jan Hammer, one of the better fusion records, to be sure.
Then he does 10 more records between 1980 and today. At least 5 of them (that's half) won Grammy Awards. One was a tribute to Gene Vincent, and one that was more electronic, and then last year the tribute to Les Paul which is just a damn good, super listenable concert.
And it's that dual threat of constant performances over 45 years, and a really diverse recorded output** that helps Jeff rise above the rest - at least for me. That, and he - not Eric or even Jimi - seems to be the pick for all the really good guitar players I know.
* - Truth is considered by many as one of the first and most influential records in the creation of Heavy Metal.
** - Hell, I didn't even list the people he did guest work for, including Roger Waters, Stevie Wonder, Morrissey, Kelly Clarkson, Kate Bush, Paul Rodgers, Stanley Clark, David Bowie, Rod Stewart, Tina Turner, John McLaughlin, Mick Jagger, Jon Bon Jovi, Herbie Handcock, and Buddy Guy - among others. They rehearsed him for both the Rolling Stones and Guns 'N Roses.
'Cause We Ended As Lovers, by Stevie Wonder.