Quote from: tekla on February 19, 2012, 01:09:34 PM
How about all the photos that were taken of Pearl Harbor both during and immediately after the attack? There are tons of them. Lots and lots show all the boats in the harbor. Second, isn't the Navy in the business of moving ships hither, dither and yon? Sure they are. To move them from San Diego to Pearl might make sense considering that Pearl would be the forward base if a war came with Japan. What kind of refurbishing docks do they have at Pearl vs. San Deigo?
Ships would have been moved in the weeks or months previous to the attack, not the "day of" nor "immediately after."
QuoteWe know the carriers were out at sea on maneuvers (but again, Navy ships are frequently out on maneuvers) but several of the ships sunk at Pearl were pretty main line. One I would think they would not have wanted to lose. However much of the power of the conspiracy argument revolves around those aircraft carriers not being there. Then again, if they had known, if they could have laid in wait, all the planes up in the air and not parked next to each other on runways, if all the guns would have been manned and loaded - then why not just blow the Japanese navel air force into oblivion and totally destroy it, while bombing their (now) defenseless fleet into the deep of the Pacific? If they would have known with enough time, that's what they would have done.
1. iirc, most of the ships sunk were returned to active duty within a few months of the attack; the exception being the
Arizona, which was a WW1 battleship--and totally obsolete by 1941 standards.
2. Carrier planes are not the same as land-based planes.
3. The purpose of allowing Japan to attack was to provide an event that the American public could rally behind, and get us into WW2. There was a strong sense of "isolationism" in the US because of WW1, where the public felt we'd been lied to in order to help England defeat Germany (true story, btw; but off topic). The US knew that with the Axis' Tripartete agreement, if we declared war on Japan, Germany would declare war on us; and soon after we declared war on Germany,
and set our #1 priority with the defeat of Germany--not Japan.
There is more to this, of course, but let's not get too far off topic.