We've all heard the old question.....

[Devlyn]

Ginger or Mary Ann? I won't limit your choices. Which castaway(s) would you want to stay shipwrecked with? I would have been showing Mr Howell some leg! Hugs, Devlyn

[cindianna_jones]

When I was younger, I would have picked Ginger. She was so glamarous. Now.... I'd go with Marry Ann. She was bubbly, fun, and down right cute. I suppose it boils down to who would make the better friend.

[Jeneva]

Cindi you said basically what I would.  Mary Ann was so much closer to living in the real world almost like a girl next door type.

[Jamie D]

Being the non-conformist I am, I'm going to throw you a curve.

I vote for "Bunny."

[Beth Andrea]

Mary Ann.

I've never really cared for the "Marilyn Monroe" dolls. Real girls are HOT.

[Stephe]

Ginger or Mary Ann? I won't limit your choices. Which castaway(s) would you want to stay shipwrecked with? I would have been showing Mr Howell some leg! Hugs, Devlyn

Gilligan?

[justmeinoz]

Can I share a hut with Mary-Ann and Ginger? 

Gilligan Stephe?  Do you have an ear fetish?? 

[Stephe]

Gilligan Stephe?  Do you have an ear fetish?? 

Well lets see, I got to choose between the fat skipper, the old man and the obnoxious professor... Compared to them Gilligan looks pretty good True tho the professor could make a blender out of a coconut..

Sorry, just not into women much these days...

[Michelle G]

Even though I am an avid fan of hot redheads I still would pick Maryanne! Until recently when I realized that Dawn Wells is the exact same age as my mother 

[Cindy]

The professor, I always thought he was a hottie.

[Rubberneck]

Mary Ann of course.

[Tammy Hope]

my answer never reflected who I wanted, but who i wanted to BE - and that was, slam dunk, Mary Ann

there's was none of the guys i would have been interested in but i'd have definitely cuddled up to the Professor given the options.

[V M]

Another vote for the professor 

[Jamie D]

The professor, I always thought he was a hottie.

Well, if the issue is survival, yeah, the Professor is a great choice.  I mean, who else could make a radio out of coconuts?

[kelly_aus]

Well, if the issue is survival, yeah, the Professor is a great choice.  I mean, who else could make a radio out of coconuts?

Was there anything he couldn't make out of coconuts?

[justmeinoz]

Thinking about it I'd have gone straight for the Professor too!  Intelligence is Hot!  Besides he could make a bra out of a coconut as well.

[Amazon D]

Even though i never dated men i don't think of gilligan as a man  or male.. gilligan always seemed to break the gender boundarys and so gilligan would be my pick because he seems non sexual / asexual which is what i am..

[Jamie D]

Who was "Bunny," you ask?

"Bunny" was the "pre-Mary Ann" in the seldom seen pilot for the show.

See THIS website for more historical information about the original pilot.


Bunny was one of two secretaries (along with Ginger).  The Professor was just a high school teacher.
It was a six-hour tour.
And the theme song was a Latin tune.