Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Ian is a captain in the Paras. This week he'll tell the Army he is having...

Started by LostInTime, March 31, 2007, 07:48:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

LostInTime

Ian is a captain in the Paras. This week he'll tell the Army he is having a sex change


rolled up to reveal muscular, tanned forearms. A rugged smile plays across his face.

But then you notice his stance. One foot is placed carefully in front of the other, the military boots elegantly angled away from each other. It is almost the pose of a catwalk model, designed to show her legs to the best advantage.

I know!' Ian says now. You can tell that I wasn't your average Para, standing there like a ballerina.'

To say he was not an average Para is something of an understatement. Three months ago, Captain Hamilton, 42, a decorated officer who also served in Bosnia and Afghanistan, took the extraordinary decision to become a woman.

  •  

rhonda13000

  •  

ChildOfTheLight

"For a man to be with a woman, it is about domination. For a woman – for me – love is an emotional journey."

I read this, and I thought, "Says who?"

See, this is one thing I can't get over.  Many people who transition seem to me to have these forced, narrow, stereotypical views of what men and women are, and how they can love, and other things.

It makes me wonder if for some people, they're naturally different from what their sex is supposed to be in some of these ways, and they try to dissociate from that to be a manly man or a womanly woman, but they can't do it, and the discrepancy just builds up until they've become very different inside from what they present, and that's how they come to identify with the opposite sex, whereas if people didn't insist that men have to be such and such, and women have to be such and such, that might never have happened, and they might have been happy living as somewhat atypical members of their birth sex.

Of course, it doesn't matter much by the time they've gotten to the point of "transition or die."  At that point, transitioning is clearly the right thing to do.  And it could just be that a lot of people in general have these views, so of course some people who transition will have them.

But it does make me wonder.

None of this is intended to question any particular person's experience.
  •