Had both and GREATLY prefer the Sailor. As stated previously, Mr. Right is way too firm and overall un-real looking - the coloration is weird and everything, and it's so stiff I've thought about using mine for pack and play more than once. It's fairly uncomfortable close to the skin and personally, mine tore after maybe a month of use. My Sailor, on the other hand, is nice and squishy, hilarious to swing around at high speeds, comfortable, natural, and a lot more durable. Sheds a little bit, but that I can live with. I use the Haka harness from Early to Bed, sans back plate, and usually wrap some bondage tape around the ring for a little extra padding. Works fine for me.