1. Well, I agree that being physically active is a turn-on, considering that most of my leisure activities involve exercise.
2. For me, if someone looks like they are trying too hard, then I am turned off.
3. Hygiene is a case-by-case thing. For example, if a person doesn't use deodorant, but doesn't have an odor (good or bad) I'm fine.
Bottom line, I like to give someone a chance and find physical attributes irrelevant. Even the cutest guys can be huge jerks...