Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Doc freaks out

Started by Doc, May 02, 2007, 06:10:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Doc

So. I'm thirty-two. I'm a man. My body is a female body.

My parents are both biologists. I remember being three years old or so, very small, and hanging out in the garden with my brother and my mom. We noticed a couple of grasshoppers mating on one of the plants, and my mom took the opportunity to give a little science lesson:
"Most animals that are big enough to see are either male or female."
"I'm female!" I crowed. I thought that females were the boys, because boys grow up bigger than girls, and female is the longer word. I remember casting a defiant look at my brother, as if by 'calling it' first that way I'd get it, I'd be the boy and he'd be the girl.
"Yes," said my mother, "Girls are female and boys are male."
Heart-sinking, that. I felt like I'd cursed myself. A couple days later I got my brother to give me a boy's haircut. Or rather, cut my hair short. He was five. And we did it in the closet, in the dark, the way you do taboo stuff like try to change your gender. The results were comical. My mom's cool. She just laughed and took me to the barber to get a real boy's haircut, since that's what I wanted.

I always felt like a boy, whenever I daydreamed about growing up, the imaginary future me was a man. Still is. Heck, the me I see in my own mind as I'm going about the business of life is a man. A short, relatively sexless, intellectual and un-macho man, but a man. Not really very different from my physical incarnation at all when it comes down to it.

I went to school with my boy's haircut, but after a few years I decided I wanted to grow it out. I was tired of the "are you a boy or a girl?" teasing, every day, from schoolmates. I became the icky, ugly girl that nobody wants to play with. I don't know that this was any better than having my gender-expression mocked and hammered on every day or if it was worse. I hated being a child.

When I went to junior high and high school my brother tried to coach me in being a girl. He's a kind man and was a kind boy, and it was a kind act even if he was fourteen and said he was doing it so I wouldn't embarrass him so much. It didn't work. I always was awkward as a girl. I came into myself a little better as a teen and got somewhat less awkward, but I also became violent -- fistfights with teenage boys. I became a goth and won a lot of friends that way. Tough grrrrl baby-dyke with black eyeliner and a Bela Lugosi costume, acts psycho and aggressive, rants about anarchist politics, what could be more cool to teens in the punk/goth scene?

Went to college. Had a mental health crisis. Dropped out. Went home and threw myself into remodelling a bedroom in my mom's house. Went back to college, still unstable, had another mental crisis, recognized my gender problems as a source. Read about transgender issues seriously, for the first time, at eighteen. Read Gender Outlaw. Wrote a big whiney miserable angst-laden email letter to Kate Bornstein. She answered me. I don't think she said much, really, but I think she saved my life. Just by being who she is, and being so kind and understanding about who I am.

Over the next few years, I learned to stop. Stop trying to fit in as a girl or a woman. I struggled with wanting SRS and HRT (totally out of reach at the time, I went to school on the 'eat nothing but beans and rice, get a part time job, beg dad for book money, and sell LSD on the side' financial-aid plan) and trying to crush everything feminine in me, and I learned to stop that rubbish too. I came to a decision -- that I want to be me, and that I don't want to medicalize my condition. That there's nothing wrong with me being a man with a female body, or at least nothing wrong with it that's in me. I'm not the one who needs to be broken and reset to function in society, it's society that needs to be broken and reset to function with me in it. Of course, this is not going to happen in my lifetime, but what the hell. I guess I am a man of principle, even when principle is a big pain in the neck.

Things were going well for me. Fell in love. Got married, to a gay-acting straight man, very much a Chopin to my George Sand. He knows that I feel like we're in a gay marriage, and I know that he feels like he's in a sort-of straight one, married to this cool avant-guarde crossdressing female that he does not think of as a woman or as a man.

Doesn't seem so bad. Pretty damn good, really. Or at least I thought so until, well. Last week. Sort of. There was a detectable build-up and now this emotional explosion. I'm having some massive trans-angst fit now. I feel utterly miserable about it. My boss had a dream where I was the mother of three daughters, my hormonal-cycle hit that day when my mood bottoms out, my best binder's about worn out and I read Max Valerio's The Testosterone Files and all the sudden I feel like crap and don't know how I can face the rest of my life. Thinking about SRS and HRT and still hating the idea for so many reasons. Feeling angry, feeling sad, feeling crazy and hopeless and alone. Feeling unmanned, really, my confidence and zest and strength sapped away.

Anyway. It seems like there are several people in positions similar to my own on this forum, and that here (unlike other transgender forums I've visited) they're not getting pushed aside as 'not real trans' so I'm thinking there might be something for me here.
  •  

Emerald


Welcome Doc, pleased to meet you!

-Emerald  :icon_mrgreen:
Androgyne.
I am not Trans-masculine, I am not Trans-feminine.
I am not Bigender, Neutrois or Genderqueer.
I am neither Cisgender nor Transgender.
I am of the 'gender' which existed before the creation of the binary genders.
  •  

Maebh

Quote from: Doc on May 02, 2007, 06:10:51 PM
Anyway. It seems like there are several people in positions similar to my own on this forum, and that here (unlike other transgender forums I've visited) they're not getting pushed aside as 'not real trans' so I'm thinking there might be something for me here.

Fáilte Welcome to Susan's Doc.
Thanks for sharing so candidely. Yes you are not alone. Of course read the rules first and then feel free to browse and participate. As you must have discovered already from TS (MTF or FTM), Androgyne, CD, TV, ->-bleeped-<- and any other labels you can think of the Trangender Continuum is vast. Hope you find who you are here and  find your own way to express it.  Et vive la difference
Go n-éirí do bhóthar leat Good luck. Enjoy the journey.

Hope, Light, Laughter, Love & Respect

Maebh
  •  

Hazumu

Hi. Doc!

Something you said early in your narrative, about confusing the words and meanings (female means boy), made me flash on something from my tender youth.

Mom told me some babies got pink, and some got blue.  I thought so sure I should get pink -- I preferred pink, it went with how I felt about me much better than cold blue.  "But, pink is for girls!  you're a boy, so you get blue..." my mom said. I tried to go with that, I tried to like blue.

But, y'know, it still ain't right...

Welcome to Susan's!  Please have a look at the Terms of Service.  Staff members are here to answer your questions about the site, and there's a whole bunch of people that hang out here who can relate to what you wrote!

Welcome to Susan's;

Karen
  •  

HelenW

Welcome, Doc!

This is a great place to visit for help your head on a little straighter.  It certainly helped me that way.  I'm happy to make your acquaintance!

again, WELCOME ! ! :)
helen
FKA: Emelye

Pronouns: she/her

My rarely updated blog: http://emelyes-kitchen.blogspot.com

Southwestern New York trans support: http://www.southerntiertrans.org/
  •  

J.T.

Hey Doc

This is the place to be.  I just joined last week and everyone has been really awesome, very welcoming.  I can't help YOU much, right now... but I hope you find what you are looking for.

see you around

ht

edit:

QuoteThat there's nothing wrong with me being a man with a female body, or at least nothing wrong with it that's in me. I'm not the one who needs to be broken and reset to function in society, it's society that needs to be broken and reset to function with me in it.

yep, totally agree.
  •  

jaded

  •  

Ms.Behavin

Welcome Doc to a place where we have all felt the same,  that the worlds not right or why does everything feel wrong.  I was a slow learner, or rather afraid to show others who I really am.  I have finally lost that fear of just being me.  It took 51 years for me to finally tell myself, it's ok just being me.

Take care

Beni
  •  

Dennis

Welcome Doc. And you're right, this isn't a place where people judge others or play the "I'm more trans than you" game. We have members from all along the spectrum and members who change places on the spectrum. Whereever you fit and whereever you stay, we're glad you invited us along on your journey.

Dennis
  •  

rhondabythebay

Welcome to Susan's Doc!

Quote from: Doc on May 02, 2007, 06:10:51 PM
It seems like there are several people in positions similar to my own on this forum, and that here (unlike other transgender forums I've visited) they're not getting pushed aside as 'not real trans' so I'm thinking there might be something for me here.

You are right in your thinking, there is a lot here for gender variant people and their SO's. I, like you and others here, have never felt comfortable in this world. I feel this place is right for me, it has helped me in my darkest moments. So stick around and tread the path with us.

Hugs,

Rhonda
  •  

Doc

Quote from: Karen on May 02, 2007, 07:21:18 PM
Mom told me some babies got pink, and some got blue.  I thought so sure I should get pink -- I preferred pink, it went with how I felt about me much better than cold blue.  "But, pink is for girls!  you're a boy, so you get blue..." my mom said. I tried to go with that, I tried to like blue.

Hehe. Yeah. I never tried until I was school-age and having to deal with all these other kids. Really, it's funny 'cause my mom is this very unfeminine woman, kinda the classic country-style tough woman, smoking a corncob pipe and stringing fences. She never tried to force me into a female gender-role at all. My grandmothers did, but really, my mom tried to protect me from that. Yet I'm trans. No real trouble escaping female roles or claiming male ones, but I still feel confined and unhappy locked into the female gender status.

I wonder if this status/role thing isn't the next hurdle (next? We're over the first one? When did that happen?) trans people will have to tackle. Seems like breaking gender roles is quite in vogue these days, but gender status is as firmly enforced as ever. It seems to be very hard for people to understand that doing something as a man is different from doing the same thing as a woman.

I was reading this anthropology book about cross-gender behavior in Native American cultures. It made a firm distinction between role and status and talked about all kinds of culturally acceptable gender-bending stuff -- men who are still considered men but do only women's work, females who change their gender-status to become men by simply wearing a certain ornament on a belt, and are considered men even if they continue to wear women's clothing. Just about every varient you can imagine in some American culture or another. Very civilised if you ask me.
  •  

tinkerbell

Hello Doc and welcome to Susan's!

Thank you for your introduction.  Please take a few moments to get familiar with the site, review the site rules, and take advantage of our many resources such as the wiki, chat, and the links listed at the main page.  We look forward to your future posts and participation.  Enjoy your stay.

tink :icon_chick:

P.S.  Please do not freak out, you are among friends, so just relax and join the conversation.
  •  

Kendall

Welcome Doc,

Yes there are some here that sound similar in experience to you. As well as those from all over the gender spectrum.

QuoteI'm not the one who needs to be broken and reset to function in society, it's society that needs to be broken and reset to function with me in it. Of course, this is not going to happen in my lifetime, but what the hell. I guess I am a man of principle, even when principle is a big pain in the neck.

Things were going well for me. Fell in love. Got married, to a gay-acting straight man, very much a Chopin to my George Sand. He knows that I feel like we're in a gay marriage, and I know that he feels like he's in a sort-of straight one, married to this cool avant-guarde crossdressing female that he does not think of as a woman or as a man.

Yes you can express freely your relationship, gender, and orientation views in accordance to the rules Karen mentioned above of course.

QuoteI was reading this anthropology book about cross-gender behavior in Native American cultures. It made a firm distinction between role and status and talked about all kinds of culturally acceptable gender-bending stuff -- men who are still considered men but do only women's work, females who change their gender-status to become men by simply wearing a certain ornament on a belt, and are considered men even if they continue to wear women's clothing. Just about every varient you can imagine in some American culture or another. Very civilised if you ask me.

Yes that would be nice.

Nice First post. Very informative and much better than my first post.

Thanks again.

KK
  •