This whole "refusal to name surgeons thing" is really bizarre - we /need/ to have transparency here! It is not our responsibility to protect the image or ego of any surgeon - and as long as we are honest with our approach, I think it is necessary to share this knowledge.
I don't want to assume you went to Dr.Reed either, but it certainly sounds like you did. Please clarify this so our forum here is a resource and not a rumor mill. We never have to turn this into a smear campaign, certainly we can acknowledge that there are always unknowns in surgery and that these surgeons have all had satisfactory results.
OP - I am so sorry you've had this experience. Honestly, it seems like moving on to Meltzer would be the safest thing to do at this point. I can't offer experience here but I do support you and will keep you in my prayers.
I was planning SRS last year, I did a fundraiser online to pay for it. I didn't raise enough for SRS so I got FFS instead - but before I did, Dr.Reed went looking for my contact info on my fundraiser comment page. He wanted to offer me a discounted $12k vaginoplasty through a grant program his office offers for cases that have financial hardship. That is my understanding.
I thought that was both beautifully generous and disconcerting. I decided not to pursue his offer because I found such a wealth of feedback online stating that this surgeon has so many complications in his work. I think it was the high instance of fistula that freaked me out. Something like 1 in 10?? Where as Mcginn said fistula instance should be like 1 in 1,000 or something.
I dunno if I got those numbers right, but this is my limited experience with choosing an SRS surgeon. I hope you find the care you need. So much love being sent out to you.
Di