Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

When Did You Know You Were...

Started by Tanya W, November 15, 2013, 12:46:57 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ashey

I can maybe trace it back to when I was 5. I had 'damsel in distress' fantasies, which is pretty amazing because that's a big part of my sexuality now. I'm very submissive and into BDSM. I like being captured and restrained. So I say maybe 5 because you have to buy into gender stereotypes. It's certainly something that is more attributed to women but not exclusively.

6-8: I was learning things. Anatomy especially, but slowly absorbed the awareness of the behavioral differences between boys and girls as they became more obvious. Still, I'd sometimes be the 'pink power ranger' when playing with a male friend of mine, and I'd sometimes be in a situation where he had to rescue me.

9-11/12: Developed a certain lucidity about my situation. I was somewhat submissive around my guy friends. 'Experimented' with some of them. More roleplay stuff where I'd assume the female role. But then a lot of frustration came about. I remember putting stickers on my earlobes, pretending they were earrings, and my dad told me to take them off. Little things like that would happen and contribute to my depression/tantrums. I also recall being in school one day, and this one guy was fooling around and twisting my nipples. I freaked out at him and started crying, saying that he wouldn't dare do that to any of the girls there and pointed to one rather well-endowed girl standing near us. Teacher came in at the wrong time and misunderstood what was going on and scolded me for something like sexual harassment. I was crying so much I don't think I could even try to explain what had happened. And finally when I was 10 I was hanging out with one or two of my guy friends and some girls. Something triggered me, probably some teasing or some gender/sex-related comment. I ran home crying and went into the kitchen, grabbed a knife, and went out to the garage. I wanted to just gut myself and be done with it but my sister ran out there, yelled at me, and took the knife away. Can't say I had a desire to kill myself after that, but for the next few years I cried myself to sleep a lot. I wished, prayed, and hoped that I would wake up as a girl. I felt like being a boy was so hard for me. Like I just didn't 'get it' and being a girl would be so right for me. I'd go clothes shopping for school and stare longingly at the girls clothes. I'd spend a lot of time imagining what it would be like if I really did just wake up as a girl. What would I wear? How would people treat me? How would I decorate my room?

Then all that waned as I realized it was never going to happen. I knew my parents wouldn't understand so I never said anything to them. My friends and anyone else probably wouldn't get it either, and I didn't want to seem like even more of a freak than I already was. I even thought I was an alien at one point. There had to be SOME reason I felt so different from everyone. Why wasn't I playing sports with the boys? Why did I get along with and relate with the girls more? But I eventually pushed all this out of my head. I was smart enough to know that this kind of thinking was dangerous and counterproductive. So I started bottling it up and assumed a more masculine persona. I practically studied the boys around me and on TV. Tried to find things I could relate to. And my longing to be a girl was pushed off onto a longing to have a sister near my age. Then at 13 I started smoking pot, hung out with more people, and socializing became easier. I got into music more, found new interests, and developed a more agreeable persona. I used to plan out what kind of a look I should have to seem more 'cool' and less weird. I ended up becoming this stoner/slacker/rocker type and it worked great for me. But by this point I had repressed my issues. Between 13 and 19 I doubt I ever thought about my childhood. All my struggles had been put in a box and buried and I never even realized it.

So I would say 5 is when I started feeling 'girly' and certainly by 9 or 10 I knew I desperately wanted to be a girl.
  •  

Lo

Quote from: Tanya W on November 15, 2013, 06:41:03 PM
This is definitely something I have struggled with also; I wonder if it is common? I feel like, at some point in my life, some part of me just stopped growing. As a result, adulthood and aging - and all that comes with these territories - seem strangely remote to me. I cannot imagine them in some ways. I often feel like I am doing more painting by numbers than actual living. 

For a while I have thought this was because I had addiction issues arise around twelve. A common recovery maxim is that aspects of our development stop when the addiction starts. True enough, methinks, but this is not quite everything for me. Twelve was also the age at which many of the girls around me began to develop. That I did not was so confusing. I felt left behind and, to some extent, feel like I'm still back there waiting for the next phase of my life to kick in.

I feel similar for other reasons-- I don't have a "normal" sexuality, but rather a paraphilic one, and it emotionally stunted me in a way. People that have intense fetishes and who are completely unable to relate to normal sex are stuck in a child-like mindset in a way, perpetually and shamelessly fascinated by whatever the fetish is.

I read a book, though, called Denial: My 25 Years Without a Soul about a gay man who went his entire childhood and young adult years not even being able to understand that he was gay. And one of his memories that really struck me (so much so that it brought tears to my eyes) was one from the beginning of the book, where he relates being a kid and just having this very concrete sense of KNOWING that he would never get married and have a family. He didn't know why, he just knew that having a wife and kids wasn't in his future, and it was devastating to him. That's what clued me into remembering that I had the exact same feeling... I imagined growing up to be an animal or a monster because deep down I knew I wasn't going to grow up to be a man or a woman.
  •  

Miyuki

In my case, things were rather... confused when I was growing up. Here are a few examples that illustrate the problem.

When I was little I had long, curly, blond hair. Whenever my parents used to take me out, I remember people always commented on what a beautiful little girl I was. I would of course always correct them, that as a matter of fact, I was actually a boy. But I was never offended by being called beautiful all the time. I cried for hours when my parents decided to cut my hair short before I started school.

Sometimes one of my mom's friends would bring over his daughter to play with me, since we were about the same age. We'd always play house, only I would be the one to play the female role (cooking, cleaning, etc.), and she would be the one to pretend to go to work and then come home. However, because I had a stay at home dad, to me that was normal for a boy. She always thought it was funny though, that I wanted to play that way though.

Growing up I had a lot of cousins, mostly girls, who I would play with. The one I spent the most time with was a girl who was a year older than me. We usually got along pretty well, unless she decided to use her advanced age to play tricks on me (trying to convince me I was adopted, for example...). However, she never liked to do girly things, and as it turns out she ended up being a lesbian. :-X

Growing up, I never really felt compelled to wear girl's clothes. But because I went to a Catholic school with a progressive stance on girl's uniforms, the clothes I had to wear were technically the exact same clothes the girls wore. And I didn't like them anyway (they were really uncomfortable).

So yea, when did I figure out for sure I was transgender? About a year after I started taking testosterone blockers... ::)
  •  

Jace

I didn't realize I was transgender until a few months back, sometime last year. In fact I'm still jumping between certainty and uncertainty. But the more I look back at things, it's like how did I not know?

I was a tomboy as a kid, lots of girls are. I played with the boys, got angry when they kicked me out for being a girl, I even got accepted as an honorary boy in the boys only club in second grade. I threw a fit whenever I had to wear dresses, had a tantrum when I had to make a cut out of myself with a yellow dress, they finally let me have yellow pants, but no blue.  I played with all sorts of toys, boys and girls. Though imaginary games were always my favorite.

When fifth and sixth grade hit and girls started growing up, I didn't. I still just wanted to play games and be a kid, I didn't understand the rush. Seventh and eighth grade were also like that. I was mature for my age mentally, but physically I looked like a 4th grader, I always have. Girls were wearing makeup and I tried but never liked it. I just didn't want to stand around and gossip I wanted to run around, be active. Freshman year though I wore a real bra for the first time and started acing more feminine. I didn't feel like I was forcing it, but it didn't feel natural either. It felt like I was playing a role, the cute tiny pixie girl.

It wasn't until half way through junior year that I had my ah ha moment. I had always heard about transgender people, but it was never positive. Words like ->-bleeped-<- and it were what I heard, so for me the thought of being transgender just never occurred to me, after all while I always wished I was a boy I didn't think I was one. I think I even read some stuff about it when I was looking up genderqueer things because I was having a tough time with my sexuality and thought maybe I just have dysphoria but I'm not actually transgender. It wasn't until I saw a dude's video though about how he figured it out that I went oh my god. I had a total freak out, messaged my very accepting best friend and basically had a sob fest. I just couldn't believe it was true, even now I can't.

A lot of it has been hard because I never had a clear sense of my gender as a child. I liked to play with girls and guys, I was always very androgynous looking, and really I just didn't lean one way or another. I did get very upset when I was treated as a girl though, never when I was treated as a boy. I remember having dysphoria now though. Whenever I took a bath, went swimming, etc this feeling of wrongness would wash over me, there's no other way to put. It just feels icky and wrong and I never knew what it was until recently.

Wow that was kind of a jumbled mess, sorry.
  •  

Ashey

Sorry for double-posting, I just read through everything.

@Jillian: I'm amazed how much our stories are alike! I mean, they're still different but some things really stood out, like that feeling of not belonging anywhere and wishing upon stars. I must have dimmed the sky a bit with all the wishes I made! Even the masturbation bit made me smirk. My first orgasm was from a vibrator (technically one of those 'squiggle pens'). xD It's nice to know I'm not alone in a lot of these things. :) *hugs*

Also, I realized I hadn't finished my story. Sorry for the length...

In high school, being the rebellious stoner/slacker/rockstar-wannabe that I was, I was mostly comfortable with myself but some things did start creeping in. I grew my hair out. Big deal, a lot of rockstars had long hair. But having long hair, sometimes my dad said I looked like a girl. I'm not sure what effect that had on me. I didn't mind it so much but generally I just shrugged it off. I liked having long hair. Then a friend of mine put it in pigtails at school one day. Shrugged it off. It was silly. But, I think I felt a bit of a tingling deep down... Then I pierced my ears. Big deal. Some eyeliner now and then? Rockstars do it. Then I'd also slip in some black hair clips or bobby-pins to 'keep the hair out of my eyes'. I'd tuck them behind my ears so they wouldn't stand out. Still... I kinda wished I didn't have to... In retrospect, it's kinda funny realizing all this and what it meant. I repressed everything so well, I had no comprehension of why I was doing all this. All I knew was I liked pushing boundaries but didn't want to be teased for being girly or looking like a girl. So it was a weird balancing act without knowing why I was doing it.

Sexually, I was also oblivious. At 10 I developed an anal fixation. 'Normal' masturbation had gotten boring quickly so I tried different ways of getting off. I was a bit ashamed but I didn't stop, I just made sure it stayed my dirty lil secret. Never once thought it made me 'gay' or anything. I loved being penetrated, but I never thought about being penetrated by a guy. I dated women throughout high school, and had plenty of sexual experiences, but I never once used my penis. I loved women but just couldn't stay physically aroused, which was very embarrassing and I think it contributed to a lot of my relationships failing. And yes, I used the headache excuse once or twice. xD But I didn't know what was wrong with me! I loved women, but I just never had a typical straight male sex drive. When I was 20 though, I think I started admitting a lot of things to myself. I got into a conversation with my friends about how as a straight guy I could appreciate attractive men. I guess that conversation stuck with me and I realized I wasn't being totally honest with myself. So I came out to my friends as bisexual. This made a whole lot more sense to me, and I felt like the pieces of the puzzle were finally coming together. I relaxed more and felt excited. As if being bi could explain everything lol. But my best friend at the time kept the enthusiasm going as she showed me all these pictures of different guys trying to find my 'type'.

Then, a few months later, my best friend gets out this dress from the back of her closet and laughs. She's very punky/gothy so she never wears anything like that. I tried making a deal with her that if she wore it, I'd wear one too. Well... she didn't, and I did. It was like a switch had been flipped and everything that I had repressed came flooding out. In a sense THAT was the missing piece of the puzzle. I can't even remember exactly how I felt or what happened because it all came at me so quickly. I could remember my childhood, and that feeling of wanting to be a girl. It was so clear and tangible that I couldn't understand how I had forgotten! Soon after dressing up a bit more I knew I couldn't just put it back in the bottle, and this time I knew there were things I could do about it. So I sat with my friends and made a pro's and con's list of transitioning. Glad to say the pro's won out. :)
  •  

Dalex

Quote from: Tanya W on November 15, 2013, 06:41:03 PM

Finally, I want to thank you specifically, Dalex, for your post. Here's an embarrassing admission: I have long scratched my head when considering the male-identified among us. I mean, you would give up that for this? Reading your words I again and again felt this head scratching stop. You have showed me something I have never seen before: our experience is way more similar than different. You have helped me grow a bit with your offering, helped me see beyond my limited sense of how things are. I am moved and humbled - still more than a little embarrassed - and so appreciative.

There's no need to thank me, but I am glad. It actually too me a while to think of what to reply, and honestly I still don't really know how. Though, I do understand where you are coming from when you talking about that head scratching. I think everyone has that moment at least once, just a moment where we wonder why someone would want something that you yourself has, yet always felt dysphoric and out of place having it our selfs. Heck, I  even thought for a very long time if the medical teams could come together and see which two people were compatible with one another so they could switch, like in a sense; a heart transplant and so forth. I think I scratched my head around that more, if anything.

When I think about it, I suppose I have always been rather good at putting myself in others shoes and try my best to see things from their point of view. It's one of the reasons why I can't give others pity or sympathy, but what I can offer is empathy, but I feel I'm getting a bit off topic here.

What my point about all of this rambling was, we are all human and it is very human to not always able to understand why someone would want something you don't. And that's what we are at the end of the day, we are all just very much human :)

I hope what I wrote made any sense, English is my second language so I do understand why sometimes my view's and points don't always come out as I intended them to. And last but not least, I love you all here. Everyone here has shown me what true strength and bravery is. I want to steal a bit from Robins poem, and write it a bit in my own words, so the last bit all belongs to her but I feel like it's a good message to everyone.

Everyone has wings and many will want to shoot you down for having the ability to fly. But remember, we all fly together, even though some of us are pretty far from one another. I have seen when one of our wings seem to get a bullet wound, many are willing to come sweeping in to help mend the wing back together and help us to fly once again. Hey, it's what family and friends are for, right? :)
  •  

KabitTarah

Quote from: ♡ Emily ♡ on November 16, 2013, 07:58:53 AM
Oh key... It was really comforting for me to read this ;). I do wonder where does that come from, cause kids at that age are not supposed to know... well, I guess we will never know.

And, btw, when we still had the Sexuality subsection open for everyone, not just for subscribers, we had a wonderful thread on masturbation, which actually showed that really a lot of transwomen had the same experience - not being really sure what we are supposed to do downthere and instead going for the female pattern "behaviour" instinctively.

Yeah, and some of Your memories in that second post made me blush too...

Before I subscribed... I made a similar thread outside. It walked the line, but didn't get moved.  ;D https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,148434.msg1225040.html#msg1225040

~ Tarah ~

  •  

~Kaiden

Well, I suppose I'll throw my two cents in here as well!

I didn't really start accepting or acknowledging the fact until these past couple months... but in a way, I think I always knew.  There's always been that feeling in the back of my mind that something was just off.  And I never liked being called a girl or a woman.  Every time someone has referred to me as a girl or a woman in my life, I get this sharp twinge of severe discomfort.  I'm not sure how to describe it, but I'm sure you all know what I'm talking about.  I could describe it as a punch in the gut, or like someone plunging a syringe full of a hefty dose of self-loathing into the back of my chest.  It always left me with a bitter taste in my mouth.  But, anyway....

I think the earliest memory of realizing how much I despised being a girl was when I was about 5.  I remember it quite clearly actually, which is strange because I really don't have a lot of clear memories before the age of 12.  My brother, cousin (male cousin), and I were in our bedroom racing 2 player on Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (which I am a boss at, btw X3) and my brother and I were racing.  My cousin said something to the effect of, "She's gonna beat you!"  I remember wanting to snap back at him and shout, "Who are you calling a she!"  But then I stopped, realizing, oh yeah... I AM a "she".  And after coming to that sudden realization, I felt a crushing sense of despair come over me.  After just a moment ago, having fun without a care in the world, just feeling like one of the guys, that was the first time I realized that something was really wrong. 

I started refusing dresses and girls clothing at about 5 or 6, probably right after that incident stated above, and demanded not to be given girls toys anymore on my birthday or for Christmas.  Of course I always was, and every time I got a girl toy I would either give it to my little sister or trash it.  In school, I didn't have a lot of friends, because I never really fit anywhere.  I wasn't girly enough for the girls and the simple fact that I was female made me an outcast among the boys, so I was pretty much alone.  On top of that, I've always had bad social anxiety.  And even though I know it's probably mainly caused by other experiences in my life, I have started to wonder if the dysphoria had a lot to do with it.  The only other kids I really had to play with were my brother and sisters friends, and given the choice, I would always play with my brother and his friends.  In fact, given the choice between playing with my sister and their friends and just staying in my room alone, I would usually just stay in my room. 

As I got older, the angry dysphoric feelings subsided, as everyone pretty much came to accept that I was a tomboy.  But then, puberty hit, and things started to get bad again.  My mom had explained to me about the what to expect.  I think I wanted to throw myself against a wall, but I just did the only thing I could do, cringe and hope by some miracle it didnt happen.  But of course, it did.  And I, for some reason, hit puberty faster than most of the other girls in my class.  To my horror, I developed exceptionally large breasts.  I was one of the first girls who had to start wearing a bra.  Other kids would comment and it made me so uncomfortable I started to wear nothing but t-shirts and sweatshirts to try to make them less noticeable.  I still do, because I can't stand them.  I often feel more like they are a couple of tumors on my chest that need to be removed, rather than a part of my body. 

In middle and high school, I had a few friends.  They were kind of girly girls, but they were pretty awesome because they were funny nerds like me, and they accepted me for who I was.  High school was rough for me though.  I still didn't fit in anywhere, and always got crap from the other kids.  I never went to proms or dances.  The idea of putting on a dress and dancing a ball having to try to act like a woman made me sick to my stomach.  After a while, I couldn't take it anymore.  I dropped out and pretty much became a shut-in for a while.

When I was 19, I decided I needed to stop hiding from the world and go do something with my life.  So, I went and got my GED and started college.  I decided that I had to accept the fact that I was a girl, because if I was going to go back into the world I had to learn to "fit in".  So, I started doing something every morning I never had before.... hair and make up.  Luckily, my sister was going with me, so she helped me get ready, because I had no idea what I was doing.  I'd put on some girly clothes and go to class feeling like a clown.  I never really knew how to act like a girl, and never felt comfortable being myself, but I made the best of what I could work with.  My social anxiety wasn't as bad as it was in grade school, so I managed to make some friends, had a pretty good time, typical college life, did well in class.  Still, dating, parties, things like that, were still difficult.  I was 20 at this point and had yet to have experienced a relationship.  I didn't even like dating.  It wasn't that I didn't want one, it was just that, I didn't want to be the "girlfriend".  I've always had the deep desire to be the boyfriend in the relationship, whether that relationship be with a man or woman.  I would often find myself avoiding any kind of flirty or romantic situation, because I realized, girls flirted one way, guys flirted another way.  I just couldn't see myself flirting like I saw other girls flirting.  I couldn't understand how I could be expected to behave that way. 

Then eventually, I did find myself in my first relationship.  I remember, even though I wasn't all that excited about the idea of penetrative sex, I was extremely excited to finally see what a penis was like in person. XP  I remember both of my ex boyfriends had commented at some point in our relationship that they thought it was strange how fascinated I was with their penis. XP  And to make it even more strange, penetrative sex was a huge issue for me.  Through two relationships, one lasting 4 years and the other 1 year, I was only able to bring myself to do it a hand full of times, because every time it felt so wrong.  Painful, and at times intensely nauseating, and always left me feeling kind of violated.  This caused problems in my relationships, needless to say.  My first ex would often get angry and tell me I wasn't a real woman, adding to my already strong feelings of inadequacy.  I would often wonder if there was something medically wrong with me, but upon a check up, everything was perfectly fine... (physically anyway)  But of course, that didn't make it any easier.  On top of that, my body dysphoria made it impossible for me to feel comfortable in the nude.  I always felt rather disgusted by my body, especially my breasts.  Even though I've always been a little overweight, I've never really been heavy, but I always kinda felt like Jabba the Hut without clothes on. XP 

And of course, the desire to have a penis has always been very strong.  Even when I was very young, I always felt like it was missing.  Even though I knew I was a "girl" and wasn't supposed to have one.  I have had many, many dreams throughout my life about having a penis, and being a boy, and then feeling the crushing, dysphoria and disappointment upon waking up.  Another things is, when I imagine myself in my head, I have always imagined myself as a man.  Say if I were thinking about my future or dreaming about being a celebrity or something like that (we all do that at some point, don't we? XP) I would always be a man.  And in my head, my inner voice when I'm thinking to myself is often male.  Sometimes its female, but a lot of the times its male. 

But, its pretty remarkable the changes that I have felt over these past few months, finally realizing who I am.  So much has changed in my mind.  The dysphoria can be worse at times, now that I am more aware of it, but at the same time I feel like I can handle it better now that I know what it is.  My view of myself has changed drastically.  One problem that has haunted me throughout my life is that I never could figure out who I was.  I always had problems, trying to figure out how to act, what to say, what was "appropriate", what I should like or dislike.  Even though, it's not like I couldn't have done and been everything I wanted to be as a woman, there was one fundamental thing that was wrong with the whole picture, the fact that I WASN'T a woman.  That, in and of it self, for some reason, felt so limiting to me.  And now, I know why.  Accepting myself as a man has been the most life-changing experience of my life, and I have the people on this forum to thank for that. :)  For the first time, I feel like I know who I am, and feel comfortable just being me without worrying so much about what I do or say.  And I'm finding out, that I actually like myself, a lot.  And I'm not all that hideous after all. XP  After so many years of self-loathing and hate, I am for the first time learning to love myself for me, and realize its okay not to fit into a box.  And its an amazing feeling.  I truly feel like I have been reborn.

Sorry..... I typed way more than I intended to. XD  Darn my rambliness. XP  *double headdesk*
Make your own kind of music, sing your own special song.
Make your own kind of music, even if nobody else sings along.
  •  

Joan

For me it was Nadia Komanec (sp?) at the Montreal Olympics when I was seven. 

She moved so gracefully, so beautifully.  And then looking at her...from what gymnasts wear you get a pretty good anatomy lesson, and I could see pretty clearly that she didn't have what I did.  I wanted it gone, and I wanted to be like her.

After that came puberty, college, work, all kinds of other stuff...and the intensity of that feeling rose and fall, but I wasn't sure how far across I was on the transgender scale until the start of this year.  A final determination to sit down and work through exactly what it was that was making me so unhappy brought me to a final acceptance of what I'd always been trying to evade: transsexualism.
Only a dark cocoon before I get my gorgeous wings and fly away
Only a phase, these dark cafe days
  •  

Tessa James

In my experience with transgender and LGB folks many have reported the same sense or phenomena as Kai.   That they/we had troubled self images and unclear, fuzzy or even no memories of our early childhood.  Some of us had those ah ha moments that punctuated the fog but I submit much of it was too painful to dwell on?

Thank you all for sharing!
Open, out and evolving queer trans person forever with HRT support since March 13, 2013
  •  

Tanya W

Quote from: Tessa James on November 20, 2013, 10:36:42 AM
In my experience with transgender and LGB folks many have reported the same sense or phenomena as Kai.   That they/we had troubled self images and unclear, fuzzy or even no memories of our early childhood.  Some of us had those ah ha moments that punctuated the fog but I submit much of it was too painful to dwell on?

Thanks to everybody for sharing your experiences here. It has been amazing, walking side by side with you all through the troubling, insightful, saddenning, liberating times your stories reflect.

At the beginning of this thread, I wrote of my 'when did you know' moment. Though this is something I had never spoken of with others before I hit the 'Post' button here, I have always known it was somehow an important juncture in my life - I just didn't quite get how it was important.

Reading all the stories here, one thing - of many things! - that has come up for me is the realization that I have actually had a great many 'ah ha' moments over the years. Longing for the change in presentation that came with puberty for the girls I knew; feeling somehow that that washroom, the girls' washroom, was where I should go; looking down with growing confusion at this body - all of these were "ah ha moments that punctuated the fog" of a very fuzzy self-image.

Why, I have been wondering, have I not noticed this before now? Tessa, of course, is right on in suggesting such moments were simply too painful to dwell on. Without a doubt. There is, however, something else in here for me...

It is, for most of us, difficult to accurately see anything we do not have a conceptual framework for. It is hard, in other words, for us to clearly see something for which we do not have a corresponding mental image. We can see a 'chair', for instance, because in our minds, we have some sort of idea labelled 'chair'.

Years ago, I was working in a rec centre swimming pool. A non-swimming friend walked by unexpectedly and wandered out to say 'hi'. The pool was absolutely empty for the first minutes of our exchange, then someone walked in, grabbed a styrofoam kick board off the deck, jumped in the water and began moving up and down the lane with this. 'I wondered what those things were,' my friend exclaimed. 'What did you think?' I asked. 'I don't know. I guessed they were just little coloured things you kept around for decoration.'

This pretty much describes my situation with regard to the 'ah ha' moments we've been sharing here. I have, I am understanding, had many of them over the years - but because I have not had any sort of conceptual framework that explained these to me, they have passed only barely noticed.

I grew up in the very white bread, middle class, suburban world of 1970s/80s North America. In this time and place, ideas of 'transgender' - the kind of ideas that would have helped me really see and understand the moments I am describing here - were very near non-existent. I vaguely remember a news story about Renee Richards wanting to play professional tennis. I listened to lots of music, so was familiar with 'Walk on the Wild Side' and 'Lola'. Beyond this, however...

So I passed many of my years with a very troubled, fuzzy, and unclear self image. Sure there were 'ah ha' moments punctuating this fog with some kind of regularity, but I really was unable to see these, understand these, welcome these for what they were. Instead they became strange little secrets that I tucked away - never looking at them, never asking of them, never feeling anything more that a hint of their significance until very recently.

In this light, reading all of your stories has been more than amazing. It has been informative in a most helpful and necessary way. Many, many thanks.   
   
'Though it is the nature of mind to create and delineate forms, and though forms are never perfectly consonant with reality, still there is a crucial difference between a form which closes off experience and a form which evokes and opens it.'
- Susan Griffin
  •  

Sammy

And thank You, Tanya, for creating this thread :) You were not the only one to be amazed and having walked side by side with others who shares their stories - listening to them amazed, saddened and liberated :) It is one of the best threads here and I hope there is more to come ;).
  •  

GorJess

Since my 2nd memory, which was at age 3. And yeah, this is likely going to be long, so if you don't want to be stuck reading War and Peace, Volume II, Jessica vs. Her Body, given my photographic memory, I'd suggest stopping here (and no offense taken on my end). Trigger Warning: Genital mutilation, suicide attempts.

But yeah, as I said this started at age 3. I always took baths with my mother, and it was just us two in the house at that part of my life. I knew what she had vs. what I had. Something just clicked that that was wrong. And so my 3 year old brain reasoned that I, too, could simply get my body like hers, from simple getting rid of that part of my body. And so, every time I had a bit of free time, I'd go straight to the bathroom, drop down my pants, underwear, and slam down the seat, as many times as I could, so it would fall off. After all, if my mother didn't have one, how secure could it have been? In retrospect, my mind must have thought it would fall off like if you did the same with a stick, in that it surely would fall off from impact alone. It didn't quite do that, but it did prompt my mother to walk in, and remark once to me, astonishingly aghast, "A purple p****!" She never did anything about that incident.

Around that time,  my favorite toy was a Madeline doll, who I slept with every night, and my favorite stories were her stories, of living in Paris; "In an old house in Paris that was covered in vines, lived twelve little girls in two straight lines..." As the traditional opening ended, I always thought of myself as Madeline, always the shortest of them all, just like I was for many a class until like 10th grade. That wound up impacting my life even today, as I speak French as my second language now, and am a bit of a Francophile.

I also attended a day care at this time, and always just wanted to play with the other girls who were doing house. And it was a small day care, too, a little area inside a church, so around the size of an average living room, for like 15 some kids. But they always, always rejected me, because I was a "boy", meaning I was physically pushed me out, every time I tried to play with them, at one point leaving me like 25 some bruises on each leg. I was an insistent bugger, you could say. Eventually, they caved one day, and they let me in, to call me over, to let me play. I was absolutely ecstatic, even though I had to play the brother, who promptly died in about 2 minutes. My thoughts at the time, they still ring in my head today, or at least the general idea of them: "Oh, wow, yay! I want be the mom or sister, like I heard them say they are a lot, but I get to be in the girl's group today!" Other than that, I mostly just sat alone, looking on, about 5 feet away, wishing and wanting. One day, we learned how to end a performance at this same day care; boys bow, girls curtsey. I can't recall any stares or anything with negative connotations, when I did only my curtsey, except the smile on my face.

Around this age, I really got confirmed the differences down there, between a boy and a girl-it was in this book shop, and I chose to read this book called The Human Body for Kids, or something of that nature. I was hopeful they would have something on the difference between boys and girls, and indeed they did ("little boys don't have a vagina"/"little girls don't have a penis"), that's the first time I learned the word vagina, and what I needed then, and still need to this day. I wished every night there on out I could wake up right, for some time...

Then when I was 4 (don't worry, these aren't all this long!), I had really envied a pair of pink Hello Kitty boots this one girl had. I remember loving the pink, and the possibly faux-fur design of their heels. I also loved to play dress up, and play as my personal favorite evil character I knew, Cruella DeVille, so I mixed up black and white wigs, clothes, etc. to make my hair match hers. We also had open house that year, and had an arts and crafts area we were displaying, and I made a pink, stapled headband that I kept on the rest of that night. While the staples were itchy, it still made me so happy, and I had to tell my mother all about it!

Then, like now, I did acting, in some courtroom theatre, which was my first taste of acting. Awesome! This one day, they actually complied with my request to play someone's daughter, and that I got to read her lines. It absolutely made my day to have done that. Like before, my mother was the only friend I had to talk with at that point, so I told her, again beaming.

In kindergarden, we had this field trip to the local airport, and I had the curse of being born with a low voice (love ya, HRT!). So all my class got to go into the cockpit of the plane, sit in the pilot's seat, to announce the city we had "landed" in. My mother, a chaperone, and my teacher made a fun game out of this, amongst themselves and the other students: Try to guess who the student was that had just spoken. It was surprising how many they actually got wrong, so I had hope when it was my turn, that they'd hear a girl when I spoke. I tried my best girly high voice, because even I knew it was a bit on the low side for a boy that age, let alone a girl, and said: "Welcome to [city]." I thought it sounded great, they totally thought it would be a girl...ah, nope. My mother said she and the teacher were laughing over how low my voice was, and how the speaker was obviously me. She meant no harm, but oh, that one just hurt.

In grade school, like grade 1, it was simple. I talked to other girls. Period. Usually I would talk about liked stuffed animals, or other soft things. I would with the boys from time to time, but they were like (as they were), the other people. Not degrading them, but just, well, like how most kids would-mostly talking to those of the same sex.

Second grade is where things got interesting, funny, and rather nasty...I thought up my first true name for myself, in a letter addressed to male classmate I had a crush on, as Juliet. Chosen because I wanted to keep the J (hey, look, I still did!), and it was romantic in a way, with Romeo and Juliet. I just knew it as a famous love story at the time, so why not use her name? Hopefully I don't meet her tragic end in the future, though! We also had self drawings, god help me if I can do better than a stick figure most days...mine was a stick kid who was seemingly normal, except for the fact that I put a taped X where my crotch was. Yeah, I meant that by it. And I got close to doing it, too. I got a tool kit that year for my birthday, which I found utterly useless except for the saw. I got up early one morning, took out the saw, pulled down my underwear, and starting to slowly to move the saw, left and right, left and right, carefully so, as to be precise. Didn't want my family knowing, so when I heard them wake up, I hid my experiment as soon as I could. They were none the wiser about this until another 8 years after this incident.

3rd grade to 6th grade, I loved going to the 'girl' gifts part of a certain site, with the label attached to its hit counter saying, "[A]nd we know if you're a girl." I always thought that true, silly me, but I hoped they saw me as a girl, but had my worries, doubts, since nobody else did but me. Around that time, my friends and I (boys, which, egad, shock, right?) would pick 'characters' from anime (which, meh, no appeal other than Pokemon now, sorry) or video games to pick to be. I wound up picking this girl from this one show, and as such my friends called me her name. I basically was their boss, in a friendly way, so they had to do it, although they took no issue with that. I remember writing in my Crayola 64 Pack, on the underside of the flap, that year that her name was MY name, and it was NOT that wrongname. I dreamed, wished, prayed I could become her one night. And so, when I woke up, I felt like her, I truly believed I had become her, and adjusted my attitudes and such to 'become' her. I didn't dare look down, since I didn't want to be disappointed about the down there part. Tried to trick myself that since if I didn't look, I still had a 'chance' of being right. I late became her later in life...always secluded, down, depressed. Rather fascinating.

But my friends were more involved with a group I was in, so there were more like group buddies. I didn't have any other friends, so I went to video games, because they would let you see yourself for whatever you wanted to. In 2001, my favorite game ever came out...and not just because you could play as a female for the first time on it, though that really helped (and, according to my father, I played all the time as female characters in video games--he remembered more than me on that front). I loved playing as her, it was so refreshing, and right! I always changed her 'back', if I was afraid my parents would see. Why that was, I don't know-but possibly because I was a kid who had her share of trouble in the classroom until 4th grade, since I likely was bored of too easy academic work. I really didn't want to start that cycle again, since I was now basically a model student behavior wise, and academically.

I read the cocoon item some people have shared here, I did the same like every day in around 5th/6th grade. Saw that one on a TV show-this boy wanted to be less scared, and so he wrapped himself up in a blanket, and eventually his blanket became his new wings, as a butterfly; a happier, braver child. Right after the episode, I thought the same could work for me, that I'd become a girl, like that. Wrap the blanket around me, go to sleep, wake up a girl! It was RIGHT THERE, had to be! Augh, no. Of course not. At least my mother bought me a pair of girl's blue shoes then, which I proudly showed off to all the bus drivers in the district: "Look! I'm wearing girl's shoes! :) " I was just happy, and proud. Can't help but wonder what they thought of it all though!

My mother got pregnant with my first sister in summer 2002, and I wound up getting a sympathy pregnancy (morning sickness, all that fun stuff!) with my mother...at least I had that, as much as I didn't know what it was. It was fascinating, almost like our symptoms lined up, like how with two natal females living together sometimes share period dates, or close to them. I'm sure it was a sympathy prenancy though, given it stopped basically immediately when my sister was born. I might not be able to birth my own, which is always devastating, but I had that. Minus the delivery, that's as close as I can ask for. :(

Towards the latter half, 5th and 6th grade, of middle school, I just talked to this one friend Claudia a lot-again about fun furry pet toys, cats, or just girly things in general. It was wonderful, and she thought as much of it as I did, which is to say, nothing.

Somewhere around 6th and 7th grade, I had this book of 100 Questions for Kids. 2 of them stuck out to me: Do you ever wish you were of the opposite sex? OH MY GOSH, YES! YES! How they knew how I felt, though, that's what I wanted to know. Felt like I was stalked! The other one asked if I would trade lives with anyone in my class, for I believe a week. And yes-this girl in my class who I was good friends with, since we shared a lot of laughs, fun, and academic interests. I mean, she had an awesome family, basically the same personality, interesting, etc. as me, AND she gets to be a girl. I was worried how she would feel though, if I did that, but I totally wanted to switch lives with her...so much.

For 8th grade, I read one of my favorite book series ever, all 8 of the Anne of Green Gables series. It was easy to imagine myself as Anne, with her fun imagination, school success, childhood mischief, her coming of age (like I was, simultaneously), and so on. As my father joked about my love of the series, "Maybe she read those books because she wanted to become a Canadian!"

Towards the end of 8th grade, it was getting to be the end of the year...and god help me I had a stalker girlfriend who always rang my number. I was NOT interested, never reciprocated those countless offers. She just was that obsessed and obnoxious. Around that time, I played The Sims all the time, just a fun game. I made a fictionalized version of my family, with me being named Jasmine, or another girl's name that can also serve as the name of a spice. It was really cool...and I boasted about it to my friend how awesome it was that I got to be a girl (that I saw myself as, reflected back in the screen). He was, understandably so, tepid and a bit confused as to why I did so, in his reaction. That family made me so happy to play with, it made things okay that summer, since I was on the computer basically all the time, and I got to be a girl during it.

Then, sigh, the joys of high school. I had a late puberty, and so I basically started in 9th grade. Only then did I notice secondary sexual characteristics between men and women...god help me, I wanted to look like THEM! And I knew it was going to get bad, fast. I knew too much about puberty to know this one would not end well at all. Day after day of secluded depression, wondering WHY!? Ready to smash a mirror if I so much as saw my reflection of the NIGHTMARE of changes that took place. I wanted to end it daily, never was successful. The closest I got in high school was I think sometime in early 2008, when I hung a belt around my neck, and tightened it more than it should have been, in an attempt to cut off the throat's ability to breathe. I did get a few remarks about why I had such marks, and I fed them the BS that I was simple exercising my neck, with a demonstration. Somehow, they bought that (hey, I am an actress, you know) and gave me neck exercises (which I would remember now, I'd like to exercise the area) to do instead. I had NO friends in 9th grade, so academics, save for geometry, were my one salvation. I adored algebra and French, so rather than talk to people during lunch most days (seriously, HS was 90%+ days of sitting alone at a table), I'd just read my books to learn more. Books were my friends.

I couldn't take much more in 10th grade, at which point I couldn't take it anymore. Around October 2008, I started to write something called Jenny's (the name I liked for myself at the time) Journal, which was a slightly humorous attempt (though more self-necessity than anything else) at writing my day from a girl's perspective, including the crush I had on the [American] football team's quarterback. Well, naturally, it got back to him, since a lot of my fans were jocks, and it got to the principal about this, under potential sexual harassment. If I had been born right, it sure as heck wouldn't have been-and it wasn't here, but... yeah. My parents got called in to the school about it, which made me feel embarrassed, and asked me if I felt like this. I did not say yes, since I didn't think the time was right.

Same reasoning with the two times we were asked flat out on an evaluation sheet (0-2 scale, 2 is highest): "I wish I was a member of the opposite sex." Once on my 16th birthday, once in 4th or 5th grade. Still wondered how they knew my life, but was worried I'd be harmed if I put yes, so I put 0 both times, stupid me (though truthfully, it was a 2, of course--and one person was actually shocked I was a 0, after she was told).

Anyway, after that journal snafu, I tried to hide my thoughts, that they were shameful, and more importantly hurtful to others. I couldn't hold them back. It just HURT to do so, on top of the puberty hell, and made me cry internally. I would have done so externally, but pre-HRT, I couldn't cry as well, even if I had wanted to. And so, the year flipped to 2009. I went to see then-president elect Barack Obama get inaugurated, with this group who I had done a law camp with before, the summer prior, in 2008. Rooming with like 6 boys, who were super girl crazy, and peering out the windows for them all the time, and their crushes, well, I think I was the bigger one crushed. It felt so TERRIBLE, because while they were nice enough, I did not belong, and I longed so much to be in a room with the other girls for girl chat...sigh...

Anyway, January 2009, prior to the swearing in, our first night there, we were divided not only for room purposes between male and female, but for a guideline talk. After they separated, god I wanted to RUSH to the girl's one, but I knew that one would go over oddly. First question they ask once they women are gone: "WE'RE ALL MEN HERE, RIGHT?" Unlike the others who roared like their local team had scored a winning touchdown, goal, or what have you, I stayed silent, cowered my head in fear, and depression, as I thought to myself, "This is wrong...." And I knew it was absolutely enough. I had to tell my family directly at this point, as if it hadn't been obvious enough to that point. Add that to some guy, who actually was quite nice, but felt the need to mention getting his pants fitted a certain way, to show off his "junk in the trunk". I had no idea how to react, I honestly just grimaced, because it was just awkward to hear that. I couldn't hack it as a guy, ever. Talking about those parts I detested like they are some glorious gift, it's not for me. I never had a doubt I was female, but, really, this showed me for the first and only time, just how bizarre the male world is, and why it doesn't work for me.

Obama was sworn in (not about politics, I swear, I'm only adding context to the dates!), I came home, did an interview about going there, getting a special ticket that got my close to the event, from a state senator, about the experience. About a week after, I was sitting in the car, in the parking lot of a little local diner or cafe, when I told my mother, at 16. I read Just Evelyn's Mom, I Need to be a Girl countless times the prior few nights, as well as seeing 20/20's My Secret Self, with Jazz and her mother, Jeanette, praying my mother (and father) would be similar to those two in her response. She totally did in time-and these days, I keep in contact via FB with Jazz's mother. My originally thought increasing my T levels would help cure this-not to be mean, but to offer a viable solution. I went to therapy, for many years. Nobody knew ANYTHING, or wouldn't see me as an under 18.

I was SO bummed I couldn't go my senior year as the female I knew myself to be, but given my lack of HRT to that point, and my voice, probably would have been a huge messy national article bit about it, like a bathroom spat. Still didn't make my senior year any less depressing, academics aside...I didn't want to even go to my HS graduation since it would be under the wrong name. I had to be threatened with no graduation dinner if I didn't, and I reluctantly went. Of course, oh nononono! It didn't stop at names, it went to dang robe colors, black for men, red for women. I really, REALLY wanted a red one. So much. That still bugs me. At least my family called me JD cheering for me when I graduated, which are still my initials (Jessica Danielle, to be exact). I graduated friendless, the one friend I did have found others, and basically drifted from me. Can't say I'd blame him with how I was then. That didn't mean I didn't want female friends though...I did more than almost anything else! I just worried they'd see me trying to hit on them, and not just as friends, girl-to-girl, so I abandoned the idea, at least in my high school.

So I went to driving school that summer, since I was unconfident about my abilities, as well as that I wanted to NEVER have that M marker on my driver's license. I found it super easy to talk with the other girls there, as we talked about fashion, and advice for life, and such. It was awesome! All the girls loved talking to me about, well, whatever. One told me I just had to be her fashion guide once she got her license, and we'd go together to shop! I think they thought I was a homosexual male, which nothing wrong with that, except the male part...that made the experience a touch less special, sigh.

I actually met my first 'other' (I use 'other' since this person since detransitioned) TS person, a few years younger than myself working at a local Burger King, after my first driving lesson, which was neat, but honestly rather scary to me, since the look was a bit garish, over the top. I met my 2nd one (FTM this time) while acting, and we were assigned 'partners' for one of the dance numbers, who made it a point to tell me to use male pronouns, which of course, no issue there. I asked why he was talking about names, hormones one day, turns out he said he was FTM, as thought (given a pound on his chest was hollow, sounded like a binder), and told me how I'd feel if I woke up one day in a girl's body. I didn't laugh, somehow, as not to be rude, but HA!

College was more of the same, great academics, love the professors for their intellect, and so on. Hey, I learned a lot about the awesome stuff like business, more about French, more theatre, amazing astronomy, and so on! No friends, sadly, and body hurt like hell, every day, still, and I was a Dean's List student a few times. Even this spring, my junior year, the pain, loomed over my like the black shoe over the helpless ant. I am glad I was not successful (don't do this!!), but I basically smothered myself with a pillow one night, and think I saw the afterlife, where I was free of all pain, dancing, like a music box ballerina, that it was all over. I recovered. Thankfully, I started HRT November 2012, which rebounded a 2ish GPA at that point in the semester, into a Dean's List GPA. That's the power of estrogen, baby!

And so, months went by...I waited until my birthday this year, June 2nd, my 21st, to start living partly (read: everywhere but class) as me. I went to the Philly Health Conference, this past June, which I'm hoping to present at next year with some close people in my life, to live as me all day, everyday there, haven't looked back since! I'm much more open, easier to talk with now, since other girls just see me as just another one of them, talking about whatever is on mind, and that soars my confidence. Everybody sees me as Jessica, anywhere; thank you great genes! It's AMAZING! It's like a perfect puzzle piece fit. Still need SRS to feel complete, personally, someday...in the meantime, to tell my story, like here, I've done an interview that should be out by year's end, as well as appearing in a documentary that begins work in December. Why do this? In addition to helping youth who truly need a role model or example, these actions are also in memorial of my father, who passed unexpectedly in his late 50s this July-he stood for social justice, equality, for all, which his parents instilled in him with the UN. I want to carry on his traits as a person in me, and I can't think of any better way to do so.

In conclusion, I've never lived life as a guy. He didn't exist-people did not see his shadow, literally so, as I prevented people from seeing me, outside of classes, or if they did they had to be in my really close circle, or I would be studying, or eating alone. I've always been female, and always will be. This life is SO much better now. I can't imagine how AMAZING, at LONG last SRS will be in hopefully a year! Hope you enjoyed my story. :)
You are here in order to enable the world to live more amply, with greater vision, with a finer spirit of hope and achievement. You are here to enrich the world. -Woodrow Wilson





With Dr. Marci Bowers in San Mateo
  •  

Jill F

I first suspected something was up when I was 4 years old.  My mom took me to the beach and I told her I wanted a swimsuit like the ones the girls were wearing.  In turn, I got the first of many lectures about what is "appropriate" for boys. 

At this time the majority of my friends were girls.  In preschool, boys and girls were separated during one play time period each day and I always hated it.  Boys played too rough for my taste and I hated that whole male pecking order thing from the get-go.  I didn't fit in, and it was obvious to everyone.  I just wanted to play nice inside with my girl friends.

Eventually I was forced to socialize with boys, but I never really quite fit in.  I learned how not to get my ass kicked every day by forced assimilation.  I always felt sort of fake and spent a lot of time alone in my room.  I often wished I could just trade places with every girl on my street.  When I was 6 years old, I was able to get naked with one of my girlfriends and even tried to have sex with her.  Actually I just wanted to be her, and I spent a lot of my childhood trying to shove my genitals "back up in there where they belonged".

In 7th grade the cojones kicked in and I became miserable.  I had almost no friends and I spent most of my days at school dodging bullies.  I remember crying one day at lunch, feeling the testosterone turning me into a man and hating these new feelings.  One one hand, getting bigger could help deter the violence I encountered almost every day and I knew it would help me socially, but on the other hand it was causing what I now know to be dysphoria.  I became very attracted to girls, and desperately wanted a girlfriend at the time.  I kept telling myself that my transgender feelings were probably normal but nobody ever spoke of them, I wasn't gay after all and maybe some female essence is actually the root of being heterosexual, like in a yin-yang symbol or something.  At this time I began experiencing recurring dreams that I was growing breasts that I hated waking up from, sometimes in tears. 

Then one day my right testicle swelled up to the size of a tangerine and I was rushed to surgery.  I don't recall the details exactly, but I ended up having "vestigial girl parts" removed from it.  My brother had to have an undescended testicle removed when he was 3.  I believe now that my mother took DES when pregnant with us.

My mother gave birth to my one and only sister when I was 14, and I recall wishing every day that I could just trade places with her.   My mom was often too busy to deal with a baby, so my sister became primarily my responsibility.  I recall feeling strangely maternal on one hand, but raging from testosterone on the other. 

At 17 I started having sex with girls, but often imagined myself being the one the receiving end and often found myself jealous of how pretty they were, wishing I could look like them.   I dismissed it as "normal" to feel that way, and I learned to cope with the dysphoria by denial, suppression, overcompensation, booze, drugs, and playing guitar for hours at a time.   

I tried growing my hair long many times, but my dad always managed to force me to cut it.  My parents moved away when I was 20 and in college, so I finally was able to grow it out and pierced my ears.   Why they always pestered me to cut my hair was beyond me, but I've kept it long for most of my adult life. Now I know why...

I met my wife at 23, married her at 25 and tried to forget about my gender issues.  Every time they surfaced, I'd shove them back down.   Why would you have a sex change just to be a lesbian?  I like girls, I like having sex with them, and hell, I'd make a pretty ugly woman.  This worked until last year when I had a breakdown over it.  The transgender feelings were at the surface, and I couldn't make them go away anymore.  I told my wife, not knowing how she'd take it, but I had to do it as she knew something was really bothering me and deserved to know what it was.  Originally I thought I was an androgyne or bigender, as the dysphoria wasn't constant and I'd have moments where I was still basically OK with being a guy.  If this was the case, I thought that transitioning fully might cause dysphoria from the other direction, so I avoided that notion like the plague at first.  I didn't want to tell the whole world about my issues if I could still manage being a guy sometimes.  Hell, it would have been easier not to have to go there.

I finally got therapy after I tried to drink myself to death on a couple of occasions while trying to come to grips with being transgender.  My therapist, an expert in gender issues, shocked me at first by telling me I needed to get on a low dose of estrogen ASAP.  If I was truly transgender, then this would bring me some much needed relief.  If not, then it would just make me irritable and moody and I could put this whole thing to bed once and for all.  Of course 2 hours after my first dose my brain felt like it had finally unclenched itself- like it felt before puberty.  I still had reservations about transitioning at that time and only dressed privately.  My therapist later asked me why it was that I wouldn't just want to be Jill 24/7, so I pondered that for a time.   As my tight fitting shirts were about to out me,  I decided to give full time a shot.  I figured that if I ever wanted to stop because I preferred to present myself as male sometimes, then a full transition would not be in the cards and I wouldn't have to tell the whole world.   I turned out that I actually never wanted to present as male at all, and I only did it out of a perceived need to fulfill others' expectations of me.  That's when I knew 100% for sure that I needed to make it permanent. 

How thick am I?
  •  

big kim

I previously wrote that I knew when I was 14 when I wanted to be the girl on the back of the bike but the clues were there many years before.It's only with hindsight I could see them.I was born in 1957,"sex changes" were only ever in seedy Sunday newspapers which my parents never read.I remember imagining starting school as a girl and thinking I was in the wrong school when I went to an all boys junior school. I can recall other boys being terrified of having to play a girl in the school play,our teacher was a fearsome battleaxe and if Miss Bennett told you you were playing a girl you were,no argument.I wondered what all the fuss was about and wished I could play the girl. We also got an exchange student called Jean from France and I wished I was French because I thought French boys had girls names.Although I was tall I was a quiet timid kid who hated fighting,I had few friends and preferred to be alone,fishing and model making.I often daydreamed about living as a girl and knew one day I would.I didn't know how but I knew it would happen.I hated having boy's haircuts but it was the late 60s/early 70s so I got away with a grown out DA while at school.I liked girls and had a girlfriend at 12,nothing happened we never even kissed,I liked boys also,not as much as girls but this made me feel even more weird.I knew there were gay people and straight but not bisexual.For many years I wrongly assosciated gender identity and sexual preference.
I skipped meals,drank and cut myself as puberty started,I saw my chance of living as a girl getting further away each day.My schoolwork went to hell,I dropped 20 places and was rarely out of trouble,I got in a ton of fights I didn't care if I lost as the pain took the edge of dysphoria.I first dressed up at 13 in some old clothes of my Mum and sister I was supposed to take to a jumble sale at Church.I took the ones that fitted and I liked best for myself.About a year later came the incident with the older boy and his girlfriend on the BSA where I wished I was the girl.
I continued drinking,dressing,skipping meals and cutting until one day in 1973 I was flicking through the TV channels(all 3 of them back then!) and an old Pathe news film came on with a beautiful blonde lady in a racing car.She was Roberta Cowell the former Spitfire pilot and at last I knew it was possible to live as a woman.I realised long ago no one could ever know my secret so I rarely made friends or had long term relationships and covered up by being a biker(now I could have long hair and not get crap about it)driving muscle cars drinking even more and smoking weed and taking speed to take the edge off dysphoria.
Shortly after my 21st birthday I saw an article in a sleazy paper about a transexual and it was like I got an electric shock and a bucket of cold water over me at the same time.I realised the feelings were not going away and i would have to deal with them.I covered up even more,I bought a 327 Chevy Chevelle and a Triumph Bonneville and chased even more girls.I'd had the occasional fling with  guys but usually preferred girls.I was going to transition in 1979 but I lost my nerve,I knew nothing of HRT,electrolysis and convinced I would be some sort of monster I lost myself in dope and booze for 10 years.
By 1989 I was desperate,I was a mess  smoking to much weed,drinking to much not eatingenough with thinning hair and I knew i had to do it soon.I started electrolysis and self medicating early in 1990 and living in role at nights and going out to a gay club at weekends These were the happiest times I had ever known,I watched spellbound over the next 18 months as my facial hair diminished,my face changed to a more female shape,my hair grew back even in the bald patch and my breasts grew.In the last week of September 1991 I went full time,what I had wanted so long was happening at last.
Sorry if I've gone on to long and bored you
  •  

Tessa James

OMG how very personal and profound you all can be.  Tears are not enough!


WRITE on!
Open, out and evolving queer trans person forever with HRT support since March 13, 2013
  •  

FTMDiaries

My mother realised that there was something different about me by the time I was 18 months old. As far as she knew, she'd given birth to a pretty little girl with enormous blue eyes and masses of blonde curls; her own little Shirley Temple. And so she expected me to act like I looked: sweet, demure, girly. Instead, I was a little tearaway: single-minded, determined, adventurous, and far more boisterous than my elder brother. She was perplexed: I was supposed to be girly, right? So why wouldn't I act like a girl?

Before the age of 3 I didn't have any major problems with my gender, because I didn't know anything about gender. I used to play with a mixed group of children, and we played the sort of games that young children tend to play so there wasn't any gender-based segregation. But when I was 3 I started attending Nursery School, and it was there that it slowly dawned on me that I wasn't like the other girls. I grew up in a very sexist era (the 1970s) when gender roles were strictly enforced, and it was in Nursery School that the teachers first split us into groups of boys and groups of girls so that we could play with our own kind. I didn't see anything wrong with being grouped with the girls at first - I was a girl, after all - but for the first time in my life I forced to play the sort of games that girls are supposed to like, and oh my god! it was incredibly weird, frightening and lonely for me.

We were given tea sets and dolls and prams and things. We were expected to play make-believe games with these toys, and I didn't have the first clue where to start. It was the social aspect of these games that knocked me for six. Girls would each assume a social role in these games, and there'd be lots of talking about who was going to take what role and what they'd be expected to do, and then the game would be all about social interaction between our respective assumed roles. I was completely and utterly lost: not only about how to do this, but also about why anyone could possibly be interested in playing this way. I would sit there in a group of yammering girls, looking longingly over at the boys who were running around, shooting each other with toy guns, playing with marbles, having fun on the playground equipment: playing the sort of games I loved and knew how to play. But I knew I wasn't allowed to go and join them: the teachers made it perfectly clear that those games were not for girls, and I knew instinctively that I'd be 'outed' as a weirdo if I even tried to join in. I realised that the other girls would identify me as an outsider, and the boys didn't want a stinky girl with cooties to join their games. So my only recourse was to be the socially awkward kid on the outskirts of a group of girls, feeling more & more distressed as time wore on.

By the time I was 5 I knew for sure that I wasn't like other girls and that I felt more like a boy. I went to my parents and told them that I was really a boy, that I wanted to wear boys' clothes and be known by a boy's name, and they dismissed me as 'going through a tomboy phase'. My mother told me that once puberty hit, I would grow out of my tomboy phase and get on with the business of being a girl again. So she let me cut my hair a bit shorter, and although she wasn't particularly happy about it, she let me wear shorts & t-shirts for the most part. But there were times when I was forced to wear dresses: I remember having screaming, crying arguments with my mother because she insisted that I had to wear a dress if I wanted to attend any parties because girls were expected to dress formally for the occasion - but my brother wasn't subject to the same restrictions. I have a photo of my brother and myself dressed up & ready to attend my mother's work Christmas party: he's wearing a Superman t-shirt, slacks and brown sandals; I'm there in a %$*£ing dress. He's smiling happily; I look miserable as sin. Because I was miserable at being forced to present myself to other people whilst wearing something that identified me as a girl.

Puberty hit, and I was elated at first because I thought that I would at last start getting over feeling so terrible about myself, just like my mother predicted. However, it soon turned into a nightmare when my body started sprouting obvious female attributes. To my horror, I had B-cups and wide hips by the time I was 9 years old, and I felt absolutely mortified and betrayed that my body was undoing all the hard work I'd been doing for years. I'd been trying to convince the kids in the neighbourhood that I was a boy but as soon I developed an hourglass figure there was no way I could convince anyone of my masculinity. So I took to wearing baggy clothes to try to hide my curves, and I started mentally disassociating myself from any part of my body below my neck. Oh, and having breasts and hips as a 9-year-old attracts all sorts of unwelcome attention from heterosexual men, let me tell you. It was awful.

So my teens were like a slow-motion car crash in which I felt more & more miserable in a body that was careening out of my control, heading in completely the wrong direction. I had no idea why I felt this way... until at age 19 I read the same article Emily mentioned in a previous post: the one about the transsexual Bond girl, Caroline Cossey. Caroline told a heart-felt story of what it was like for her growing up with everyone expecting her to be a Good Little Boy. She explained how puberty made her body feel alien, and how she decided to transition to ease her discomfort. By the time I got to the end of that article, I was crying and physically shaking. Here, at last, was somebody else who had experienced the exact same horrors as I had, albeit from the opposite direction. She described perfectly how I'd felt whilst growing up. Finally, I had a name for what had been 'wrong' with me all these years: 'transsexual'. But I'd only ever heard of transsexuals as being of the MtF variety. I had no idea whether it was even possible to be the other way round; there was (and is) so much less information about FtMs out there that I'd never even heard of such a thing. So I went to the municipal library and did as much research as I could.

There was precious little information about female-to-male transition, particularly in the days before the Internet, but I did eventually find some decent medical journals that had some good info. However, I was disheartened to read that the surgical procedures at the time were so poor that I would effectively wind up mutilating myself whilst permanently sacrificing my ability to orgasm. The detriments seemed to outweigh the benefits, so I broken-heartedly decided that I had no choice but to abandon all plans of transition and instead try to figure out how to live as a woman. I did that for almost 22 years, going so far as to get married and give birth to two children, whilst constantly struggling with an underlying discomfort at being expected to be a woman. Last year, the dam broke and I realised I had no choice but to transition because I couldn't bear wasting my life like this any longer. I did more research and was delighted to discover that surgical techniques have moved on considerably in the last two decades, so here I am medically transitioning at long last.

I will say one thing though: being born female-bodied made it possible for me to hide my sexuality. I've always been sexually attracted to men, but that's not considered unusual for a teenage girl, is it? So I managed to fly under everyone's gaydar, until I was ready to come out on my terms. But on the flipside, being attracted to men made me stay in denial for much longer.





  •  

Natalia

Great topic! It is really nice to know how everyone discovered their real selfs, and eveyone writes so well! :)

I did not realize I was a transgener until around one year ago, when I was prescribed with testosterone blockers for my male pattern baldness and I decided to research about other ways to stop baldening...then I found a lot of transgender sites telling how testosterone blockers and hormones are used for MtFs and found about gender disphoria!

It was like something dinged on my head! I have gender disphoria! Now everything makes sense! I started remembering a lot of my past, I linked the dots and saw so clearly! I was supposed to be a girl! I am a girl!

My oldest memory is from when I was around 6-7yo. I remembered how I loved to wear my mother shoes, especially the high heels! I loved to walk on high heels and look at me on the mirror. I was so beautiful! I really wished that I could wear those kind of shoes when I grew up! But when my mother discovered she got angry and told me to never use them again.

Actually I was a lonely child. I didn't have brothers or sisters and never had friends on my neighborhood...so I learned to play alone.

I loved to play with my stuffed animals and I spent a good part of my childhood playing with my beloved furry friends (I still sleep with some of them :D). My favorite stuffed animal was my teddy bear and when I impersonated me into it I have always changed my voice with a falsetto and turned it into a very feminine voice...yes, that was me!

But the most girly thing I loved to play was with my mini-market, with beautiful small cans of beans, vegetables, fruits and all kind of things you buy on a real supermarket! I also loved to build a small house for me and make is very tidy and pretty!

Then years passed and I never really fitted into any group nor had friends at school. I was always the lonely weird shy boy who loved to study and that talked to nobody.

I was overweight when I was around 10-11 yo and the boys mocked me because of my moobs. They were always pursuing me and squeezing my nipples, calling me a girl...I hated that! I felt so defenseless! I felt abused...I didn't know what to do and I did not have the courage to tell it to anybody because I was so embarassed! It should be normal to a girl to be mocked that way, but not for a boy...one day I ended telling the school director and that was one of the most shameful moments of my life. I really felt like a girl telling the director "help me, the boys are squeezing my boobs!" 

When all the boys were talking about girls, I was never interested and I avoided those subjects. One day a boy bought to school a lot of playboy magazines and they passed it to me. I got very embarassed and could not see the magazines...because of that some people started to call me gay...but I was not gay...I was just, I don't know, assexual, perhaps.

My beautiful handwriting with lots of different colors and markers did not help at all. Everyone always told me that my notebook was really girly! The other girls were envious of my beautiful letter!

And years passed until I started to realize how I I hated the fact that I was a man, I knew I would never be a real man, I just didn't fit! I was too shy, too polite, too educated, too defenseless and I never wanted to be different than that.

I knew I couldn't do nothing about it and I closed myself on a shell. I never allowed anyone to know my real feelings and I decided to bury it deep into my brain and forget about it.

When my hormones kicked in (some years later than for most boys) I started to watch porn. First I started watching girls, but I was never really excited watching their beautiful bodies...I realized I wanted to have their bodies...when I moved from softcore to hardcore I realized that on a relation I would like to be the girl. My mind was always on the girl and on the though of being the girl. Oh god, how badly I desired to be a girl!

And then I started to play Second Life back in 2006. My first avatar was a girl named Natalia (coincidence?). I got a boyfriend there, married with him and spent almost two years getting online 5 hours daily every night. I loved to be with him, to be a girl, to talk my feelings, to buy beautiful clothes, to be who I am really suposed to be! He didn't know I was not a girl and it became harder to hide it...when we ended our relation it was one of the worst days of my life.

It may seem ridiculous to cry over a virtual relationship, but I never had a real one...I cried for hours! :( My first and only relationship was with a boy and I was the girl and it wasn't even real! (my life sucks!)

But when I linked the dots and discovered about gender disphoria, wow, suddenly all got bright and clear! My life now have a different meaning and I need to go after it. I need to seek my real self and to allow it to flourish out of this male shell!
  •  

Sophia Hawke

*Explicit*  Seriously, read no further if anything that has to do with sex offends you.


Ill never forget the moment I realized i was transgendered.  EVER.  I was 16 and in high school, my life up to that point had been a mess, between abuse, neglect, and a pharm shill psychiatrist and i was finally out the other side.  I had finally lost as much weight as i could from having been on zyprexa.   At the time i was attending alternative school, class sizes were very small. maybe only 60-80 kids in the whole school.   A trans girl transferred in from public school.   At the time id never ever thought of anyone else penis as attractive.  She was VERY hyper femme and over exaggerated, alot of my classmates were super critical of her and made fun of her.   And its not that i felt bad for her, but i was just strangely attracted to her and i did not know why.  My motto is pretty much to try everything at least once(as far as legal things were concerned or sometimes drugs back then), anyways, half way through the school year we got to talking and I got my dad and his now ex-wife, to drive me over to her house one weekend. 

     We both climbed into bed and watched MTV(TrL?) and then little mermaid and some other classic girl cartoons.    She was the first girl i had ever kissed, even with her beard she was beautiful to me :-)
Almost automatically i went down on her without even thinking(and let me tell, at 28, still the biggest joystick ive ever seen, not even many bigger in porn lol).  Anyways, I sucked her and swallowed(something that created a life long fetish even, my female friend tell me now that they would never :-(). After that i tried without thinking again to put her inside me(she was seriously huge) and it hurt pretty bad and never fit.   She tried to console me and at least reciprocate, but could never get it up.
               
        It was during that moment(seriously) that i realized everything at once.  I didnt come there to get with a (in my mind GG, and is still how i think of all transwomen), it was because i loved who she was, and what she was doing.  I loved watching girly cartoons(and still do) with her and I wanted to do exactly what she was doing.  I knew that i wanted her then male body as a women wants a mans and that one day id finally become a woman.  Like a rush of memories, i remembered playing with my female cousin as a kid with barbies and other girl toys instead of my brother and our friends. I grew up best of friends with her.  And the previous summer i had gone to an indian pow wow(yeah a real one, somehow my uncle is part of a native american tribe)  During that camp out and before she had shown me how to do foundation eye liner and lipstick.   You can bet i wore it all week too that we were there, i was happy as could be even with all the strange looks.  That same year id also been a school girl for Halloween.
               I knew, and i still regret to this day not coming out right then and there.   I feel like ive missed 28 years of my life, and for the most part ive been silently miserable with a smile mask.    I'm sorry to be so graphic, but i feel that it really outlines one of the biggest GD inducing things for me.    I like girls and guys, yet i can't achieve fulfilling intimacy with either, with the body of a man.     It's haunted my relationships all my life.  Either i can't do it, or im so bored doing it for her after a time.    This has destroyed virtually all of my relationships, and left me feeling worthless and unwanted.      Every day im desperate to become a complete girl just so i can stop feeling lonely.  For that matter even enter into relationships, since im both highly submissive and shy.   I just hope for the day when i get to be approached.

Sorry for that whole tirade.  GD is bad today.
  •  

~Kaiden

Wow... I just want to hug everyone on this thread.  All your stories are so moving!  :P  Thank you all for sharing.

I thought I might tack on a couple other things I forgot to mention.  First, just an observation about my sexual orientation.  I've always been a bit confused by what I found physically attractive in people.  I consider myself bi, but in truth I'm not really attracted to men or women.  There are traits in both that I admire, and I've often felt more attracted to people who embody a bit of both.  I've never in my life found myself attracted to very feminine women or very masculine men.  So I guess you could say I'm attracted to androgyny? (is there a word for that? :/)  The weird thing is though, I have never really thought much about it until recently having realized I was trans.  I just thought I had odd taste in men.  My mom likes guys with long hair too, after all, so maybe I get it from her.  I told my mom when I was 14 that I thought I was bi, but she kinda laughed at me and told me I was just doing it for attention.  So I kinda let it slip back into the closet and told myself, as part of fitting into the role, to just be straight.  At the time, I thought I was more attracted to men anyway because of the genitals, but I think that was mainly because if I couldn't have a penis of my own, a boyfriend would be the next best thing.  But what I've come to realize is, when it comes to finding a partner, what someones got between their legs actually means very little to me.

Another strange thing is, I can't remember exactly when I first heard about transsexuals.  I think I was kind of always aware of their existence from a young age, as my parents weren't very discerning about what my siblings and I watched, so I was exposed to a lot of things that probably weren't considered appropriate for my age.  But, in my early 20s, I think that was when I really got engrossed in the subject.  I really like watching things like the Science Channel and Discovery... (yes, I am a science nerd...  :icon_no1swatching-nerd:) and for a period of time they had a lot of documentaries about transsexuals.  I started to develop a secret fascination with the subject.  There was this particular show called Taboo, which I became a bit obsessed with.  They had a few episodes that focused on the subject of transsexualism.  That was the first time I heard of Balian Buschbaum, and I remember sitting there wishing I could be him.  I recorded all the episodes to my DVR, and every once in a while I would sit in my room alone and watch them all over and over again, wishing I could do what they were doing.  But every time this happened, I would sit there wondering why.  I wasn't ready at that point in my life to actually consider that I might be trans.  I didn't really think I wanted to be a boy, I told myself I could never cut it as a guy because I would just be a nerdy, effeminate wimp. :P  But I was still pretty deep in denial about everything back then, so I would just brush it off and try to go about my miserable life continuing to try to be this woman I knew deep down I wasn't.

Actually, as I was writing that, I remembered something else I forgot to mention, and I can't believe I didn't think about it earlier because this was the biggest "ah-hah" moment of them all!  It was a few months back.   Between April and August, a bunch of not-so-good things happened all at once, and I was feeling really depressed, kind of at the end of my rope, almost to the point of giving up.  I was starting to wonder what the point of life was anymore, as mine seemed to be one big joke.  For the first time, I actually started to have suicidal thoughts.  I just had this overwhelming feeling I couldn't go on the way I was, but still, couldn't bring myself to consider it had anything to do with my gender.  It scared me, so I decided I needed to figure out a way to be happy.  I started trying things, exorcising more, eating better, trying to get out more and improve my life.  Even tried to get a job, although my social anxiety started getting to me too much after going to 4 interviews and not getting hired, so I gave up. :P So, I decided to start spending more time writing, and really working on finishing my book.  Things improved a little, but I still felt trapped.  Then, in the middle of June, I think it was, or maybe July, I found an article on facebook about Chelsea Manning.  A US soldier who had been sentenced to 35 years in prison for releasing classified government documents.  After her sentencing, the soldier who had previously gone by the name Bradley had come out publicly as Chelsea.  For some reason, that got me right in the heart.  I felt a strong sense of admiration for her bravery to come out to the world whilst already at the center of so much controversy.  And at the same time, an unexplainably heavy feeling of empathy.  I couldn't understand why it made me feel so emotional, so I tried to tuck it away in the back of my mind, as I did every time I had that explainable feeling.  Then, a short while later, as I was working on my book one day, I inexplicably started playing with the idea of changing the main character of the story from a cis-woman to a trans-woman.  (I've always had a funny way of expressing myself through my writing without really realizing I'm doing it until later.)  The idea stuck, and as I started tweaking her character and her background story, and writing in scenes dealing with her sexual identity, I realized I was expressing my gender frustrations through her, and my own feelings about my gender started to surface harder and more clearly than ever.  I'd found that, without realizing it, I had backed myself into a corner.  Suddenly, I couldn't bring myself to continue writing the story I had been working on nearly every day for the past several years, without having to deal with the feelings I had worked so hard to repress my entire life.  I wasn't about to stop writing, so, that's when I decided I had to figure this out once and for all.  I had to find a way to determine whether I really was trans, or if I was just going crazy... 

That's when I got online and found this forum, and it's opened my eyes so much.  Ever since then, everything has just kind of been falling into place, like the pieces to a puzzle I've never quite been able to put together.  Maybe a few pieces are still missing, but I can see the picture clearly now, and it's an amazing view.  I still can't believe it sometimes.  All that's left now is to place the final pieces, glue it all together, and hang it up on the wall for everyone to see.  For the first time in my life, I actually feel happy.  I never thought I could be this happy.  :)  I only wish I could have come to accept it much earlier in life, instead of wasting so much time avoiding it.
Make your own kind of music, sing your own special song.
Make your own kind of music, even if nobody else sings along.
  •