Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Nature vs. Nurture, what happened to individual choice?

Started by Xren, January 04, 2014, 11:35:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

helen2010

This is a really rich discussion which mirrors much of the internal dialog and self analysis and criticism I have had.  Not sure if this adds to the very insightful comments already made but nature feels more comfortable so I am more accepting of this theory.  Nurture makes me feel uneasy as it makes me feel that but for others I wouldn't be this way.   Separately my response to hrt was not in any way a placebo effect - intense dysphoria instantly disappeared, nothing, nada, gone which for me pointed to nature as the most likely explanation of my state.
Choice for me relates to how I choose to understand an experience.  In general I select the paradigm which fits me best ie that with which I am most comfortable and that is normally the one which is kindest to myself and to others.  Until the adopted paradigm is rejected either conclusively by society or I accept/adopt/evolve or embrace an alternate paradigm then this is my understanding.   So in my case I am most comfortable with (intellectually and emotionally) with a nature explanation of my reality, I choose this explanation and within self defined or imposed boundaries I choose how I will deal with it, I think.
Of course if choice is an illusion and this has all been predestined then I am kidding myself.  Not knowing how to prove which is true I again to choose choice as this possible illusion works best for me at this stage of my life/development/path/experience/ramble et al
  •