Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

SAFETY CONCERN: Asked to speak at GSA

Started by aucoraborealis, March 11, 2014, 11:47:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

aucoraborealis

I live in a very small logging town. Most of the people here have never heard of the term "trans" and are very close-minded and conservative. That said, I've been asked to speak at a GSA (gay straight alliance) seminar at the public school on behalf of the trans community. I don't hide the fact that I'm trans, but I'm not publicly out and I'm not living as a women. I'm in a gender fluid "boy mode" for the time being. Here are my thoughts...

For speaking:

1. I was lost once too, and it would have been awesome to know there was someone I could talk to in this town.
2. I've always told myself I'd be out one day and help those struggling to find their way.

Against speaking:

1. A have a wife and son (two more on the way) that I need to take into consideration. She's fine with me being out, but prefers that I keep it out of her circle of friends, church members, co-workers, etc. She views this seminar as basically coming out to the whole town and isn't crazy about the idea.
2. I'm concerned about violence. This is a crazy place. If the wrong people find out, I wouldn't be surprised if I ran into some form of altercation because of it.

Has anyone struggled with this dilemma before? I want to put the trans community ahead of myself, but it's hard to gauge if this is a good decision. I suggested setting up a private email that they can give out to those questioning their gender or considering transition. That way I'd remain anonymous, but I guess to some degree that's a cowardly move.
  •  

suzifrommd

For #2, I don't like to cave in to bullies. Violence is always a possibility, even if you keep your head down.

For #1, wife and kids are stickier. On one hand, kids can handle adversity better than we give them credit for if we help them through. On the other hand you don't want to go out of your way to make your kid's life harder.

Personally, I would do it. I'm an educator, and I believe strongly that if transgender people don't educate others about who we are and how we live, then the media will do it for us and totally botch the job. For that reason, I've offered to speak about transgender in public forums even though it would make it harder to pass among people who've heard of me.

But in the end, the choice is yours. You understand the trade-offs. Not much I can add.

Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

ThePhoenix

There are ways.  I'm in a profession where being open as trans* is career ending.  And violence is an ever present concern.  And I just don't enjoy the spotlight anyway.  Here's how I deal with it:

I publish and give talks under my first name only.  I do not allow my last name to be listed in publicity material, programs, websites or other material.  That way I could be any of a zillion people with the same first  name.  If someone unfriendly hears about me, good luck finding me.

I also do not do press interviews and the like.  Occasionally the press is present at events where I'm a participant.  If that is the case, then they must be informed in very strong terms that they cannot name me.  I have had a reporter ask to write about my work with the community and I've refused.

If people cannot agree to these terms, then I will decline their invitation to be a speaker/panelist/discussion participant/whatever else.  If that leaves them in a lurch or awkward position, then they are free to reconsider their refusal.

These steps mitigate the risk, but they don't entirely eliminate it.  There's always the possibility that someone screws up.  And I'm well enough known that if I'm publishing under my first name alone, people know who it is.  That fact gives me some credibility, but it also has gotten me cited by full name on a couple of Cathy Brennan's anti-trans* hate websites.  But by and large this approach as worked pretty well for me.

As far as violence goes, I do believe in caving into that threat.  If you're dead or in a hospital, then usually that means you are not doing any good for anyone.  So I encourage people to be realistic about the risk (aren't people at a GSA likely to be a friendly crowd?) but not to do anything stupid that would put them at a realistic risk. 
  •  

aucoraborealis

Thank you for your replies. I know it's a situation specific to me, but what you've said has been a tremendous help :)
  •  

JoanneB

Others have said some great things to get one thinking of the problem. Phoenix made some good points. One important point to mention is that in many to most cases where "The public is invited to......" you likely will not have control (aka legal standing) who can photograph you. 
.          (Pile Driver)  
                    |
                    |
                    ^
(ROCK) ---> ME <--- (HARD PLACE)
  •  

Bimmer Guy

I like everything ThePhoenix said. 

Is this a seminar for all the GSA's in the area?  If it is just for one GSA, you can say that you can't make the seminar (I am assuming this is like a conference with more than one speaker), and instead can come see them at the school during one of their meetings.  This way you can support the students, but it will be more private.
Top Surgery: 10/10/13 (Garramone)
Testosterone: 9/9/14
Hysto: 10/1/15
Stage 1 Meta: 3/2/16 (including UL, Vaginectomy, Scrotoplasty), (Crane, CA)
Stage 2 Meta: 11/11/16 Testicular implants, phallus and scrotum repositioning, v-nectomy revision.  Additional: Lipo on sides of chest. (Crane, TX)
Fistula Repair 12/21/17 (UPenn Hospital,unsuccessful)
Fistula Repair 6/7/18 (Nikolavsky, successful)
Revision: 1/11/19 Replacement of eroded testicle,  mons resection, cosmetic work on scrotum (Crane, TX)



  •