YES, yes to Elijah. He's much more twinky than my usual taste but he's just fricken beautiful! I think it's cuz I watched LOTR when I was 7 and lovedd him, and have seen it more times than I can count, since (50% just to see himm). I'm not sure if it's so much attraction as much as I just reaally love his look, so otherwordly.
Alsoo, my vintage crush is obvs Marlon Brando:

Stanley Kowalski is just like...raw, animal sex appeal. Another vintage one is john Garfield. But he died young, sadly.