Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Am I, or am I not?

Started by April202, July 24, 2014, 04:11:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

April202

Hey. I'm (very) new on this site, only just registering moments ago. So I apologize if I break any 'norms' of not posting before replying, or if I'm posting this in the wrong forum. Nonetheless, here I am, because I have a 'problem' (it doesn't feel like the right word, but it's the only one I can come up with that descripes the situation as close as possible) that I am not able to resolve by myself. I need help from someone who already have, or are, going through the same thing.

I am eighteen, soon nineteen, years old male possibly identying myself as female, and thoroughly confused if I truly am transsexual. It's not any new thoughts that has suddenly appeared in my mind in the last weeks or months, but something that now has been more or less present since I was about fifteen. I will admit, that it is only after I turned seventeen, and more and more strongly in the last year, that these thoughts have been on my mind. I have tried researching, but that only goes so far, and if anything, it has made me more confused.

My 'research', which I don't think I can truly call it now, talks about transsexual who goes into depression, who hates their body as it doesn't display the gender they identify themselves as, who cut in their genetalia to somehow feel better. The thing is, I haven't had any of those things happen to me (and I don't wish to, let's make that clear right now). But while I don't feel 'wrong' in my body, neither do I feel completely 'right'.

I have always been rather feminine, I guess you could call it. When I was small, my best friends were two girls, I played with dolls, I dressed up as Pippi Longstockings (a figure from a fairy tale writting by Astrid Lindgren, a swedish author), and when given the choice to sleep in night clothes or night gown, I chose the gown. After those girls weren't my friend anymore, I tried befriending boys as I didn't want to be alone, but I never really were into the boyish stuff (and I was in a year with sixteen boys, none of whom I related to). As I tried befriending boys, I, of course, tried to put away the habits that made me 'girlish'. They were effectively put away, and I haven't played with 'girl stuff' or dressed up as a girl in a very very long time. That said, I didn't embrace what 'a boy should' according to society.

I tell myself that the first time after that, that I begin to wonder about who I am, is when I'm about fifteen. But I am told by my mother, that I apparently once around the age of ten, told my boy friend (a friend who is boy, and turned out to not really be my friend) that I wished that I was a girl.

At fifteen it was discovered that I was chronically ill (I will not go into it here, as it truly isn't important for what I have to say). After many treatments that didn't lessen the effects of the illness, I went into a depression because of it. I was in a very dark place, angry at everyone, especially because I didn't have any friends. I came to a turning point, where I decided that I had enough to try and change myself to befriend others, and instead just try to be happy with myself. That is the best decision I have ever made, that, in some ways, makes it so I have peace within myself.

I know who 'I' am, what I like, what I dislike, and so forth. But I do still not know if I am a he or a she. I know I like boys more than I like girls - but if anything, that only adds to my confusion, because is this 'transsexual thing' just something I try to tell myself I am, so it will be 'easier' (which I truly know it isn't).

Something that I also noticed is this: I am an author on a fiction website, and all the stories that I've written, is all from a female main characters point of view. All of them. I have an easier time living myself into their head, and I imagine myself to be them when I write.

And in the last year, I have begun imagineing what my life would be like if I was born a girl, or if I became one in that very moment. Things like that.

I don't expect you to have all the answers, but any help would be accepted with open arms.
  •  

Jess42

Sounds to me like you are. The spectrum is pretty large from feeling wrong, to just the desire to be your preferred gender to soul crushing dysphoria. Since you write and you always write from a female perpective, I believe its fairly safe to say that you are transgender. Its just where you are in the spectrum is on you and how far you go with it. Or what you needto do to feel more comfortable with yourself.
  •  

Jessica Merriman

Most here started out with a Therapist with experience in gender issue's. I would suggest talking with one to find out and explore what you are feeling. Some of your thoughts are very close to what I personally experienced growing up. I can only speak from my personal prospective, but beginning transition and going on hormones has worked wonders with me. I actually look forward to getting up and never seem now to have enough day for all I want to do. It was scary to begin transition and will provide a new set of problems, but I handle them so much better now. Even if therapy does not show you to be dysphoric they may be able to help in other ways with depression, etc. Good luck!  :)
  •  

CoderMarissa

The fact that you're questioning means it's highly possible you are. It took a while for me to realize that for myself, and it wasn't until I saw some transition slideshow videos on YouTube that I realized transition was possible for me.

I recommend seeing a gender therapist ASAP. They'll be able to walk you through the important questions you have of yourself.
Out to self: December, 2012
HRT: May 19, 2013
Full-time: May 19, 2013
VFS: July 11, 2014 (Yeson Voice Center)
SRS: est. December, 2014
  •  

goldphantom

I felt the same way just a few days ago. I've been struggling with this for over 5 years. I am a very feminine, and I just assumed I was a feminine man. Then it turned into wanting to have a vagina but not breast but still living my life as a man.

I have since accepted my self as a girl, and I am hoping to see a therapist soon. Good luck.
  •  

androgynouspainter26

April,

You sound exactly like I did two years ago!  For me, dysphoria wasn't some all-mighty crushing feeling, at least not initially.  My body simply didn't feel right.  I think you're falling into the same trap I did-so many people think that they need to fit into a specific narrative to be transgender-that their earliest memory must be of cross-dressing, or that they must struggle with self-injury, or can't be interested in anything considered traditionally "male".  This really set me back a few years when I was coming to terms with myself.

There is no standard narrative.  If you feel wrong in your body, think you would be more comfortable as a girl, and think your life would be better and happier if you could live as female, you are trans.  Right now, it seems like you're obsessing over labels.  I think the first step is to try exploring who you want to be, free of restrictive categories like male and female.  Also, finding a therapist is really helpful.  And if you ever want to chat with someone who still has this part of the process fresh in their mind, totally send me an email/message.  It's really scary facing yourself sometimes, but feel so much better for it, of that I am almost certain!
My gender problem isn't half as bad as society's.  Although mine is still pretty bad.
  •  

Hannah Samira

I find your situation really relatable, mostly because we were friends with girls growing up and because we're the same age! To be honest you sound like you are more trans than me but don't take my word for it! As most people have said, seeking therapy is probably the best option :) x
Twitter: @HannahSamira14
Instagram: @hannah_samira14

:angel:
  •  

MajorTom

I'd say you are, but it's up to you to eventually figure out. It takes time- and when you do finally find out for sure, you'll be happy. It'll be hard, but you'll get there. And everyone is different with gender dysphoria- I don't have dysphoria about my primary sex characteristics and didn't really know from a young age, though was more masculine and most of my friends were boys. Sure enough, I turned out to be ftm. I would also suggest seeing a therapist- talking to someone unbiased about your life can be really helpful.
  •  

Jaz650

Quote from: April202 on July 24, 2014, 04:11:58 PM
Hey. I'm (very) new on this site, only just registering moments ago. So I apologize if I break any 'norms' of not posting before replying, or if I'm posting this in the wrong forum. Nonetheless, here I am, because I have a 'problem' (it doesn't feel like the right word, but it's the only one I can come up with that descripes the situation as close as possible) that I am not able to resolve by myself. I need help from someone who already have, or are, going through the same thing.

I am eighteen, soon nineteen, years old male possibly identying myself as female, and thoroughly confused if I truly am transsexual. It's not any new thoughts that has suddenly appeared in my mind in the last weeks or months, but something that now has been more or less present since I was about fifteen. I will admit, that it is only after I turned seventeen, and more and more strongly in the last year, that these thoughts have been on my mind. I have tried researching, but that only goes so far, and if anything, it has made me more confused.

My 'research', which I don't think I can truly call it now, talks about transsexual who goes into depression, who hates their body as it doesn't display the gender they identify themselves as, who cut in their genetalia to somehow feel better. The thing is, I haven't had any of those things happen to me (and I don't wish to, let's make that clear right now). But while I don't feel 'wrong' in my body, neither do I feel completely 'right'.

I have always been rather feminine, I guess you could call it. When I was small, my best friends were two girls, I played with dolls, I dressed up as Pippi Longstockings (a figure from a fairy tale writting by Astrid Lindgren, a swedish author), and when given the choice to sleep in night clothes or night gown, I chose the gown. After those girls weren't my friend anymore, I tried befriending boys as I didn't want to be alone, but I never really were into the boyish stuff (and I was in a year with sixteen boys, none of whom I related to). As I tried befriending boys, I, of course, tried to put away the habits that made me 'girlish'. They were effectively put away, and I haven't played with 'girl stuff' or dressed up as a girl in a very very long time. That said, I didn't embrace what 'a boy should' according to society.

I tell myself that the first time after that, that I begin to wonder about who I am, is when I'm about fifteen. But I am told by my mother, that I apparently once around the age of ten, told my boy friend (a friend who is boy, and turned out to not really be my friend) that I wished that I was a girl.

At fifteen it was discovered that I was chronically ill (I will not go into it here, as it truly isn't important for what I have to say). After many treatments that didn't lessen the effects of the illness, I went into a depression because of it. I was in a very dark place, angry at everyone, especially because I didn't have any friends. I came to a turning point, where I decided that I had enough to try and change myself to befriend others, and instead just try to be happy with myself. That is the best decision I have ever made, that, in some ways, makes it so I have peace within myself.

I know who 'I' am, what I like, what I dislike, and so forth. But I do still not know if I am a he or a she. I know I like boys more than I like girls - but if anything, that only adds to my confusion, because is this 'transsexual thing' just something I try to tell myself I am, so it will be 'easier' (which I truly know it isn't).

Something that I also noticed is this: I am an author on a fiction website, and all the stories that I've written, is all from a female main characters point of view. All of them. I have an easier time living myself into their head, and I imagine myself to be them when I write.

And in the last year, I have begun imagineing what my life would be like if I was born a girl, or if I became one in that very moment. Things like that.

I don't expect you to have all the answers, but any help would be accepted with open arms.

The best advice I can give you is meet with a therapist that specializes in transgender issues. I make my head hurt if I try to figure out if I was born this way. So far I can trace my ->-bleeped-<- to the third grade. I'm probably never going to know if I was, but I do know that being a woman is who I am, and it makes happy. Find a good therapist that can help you. For now be whatever feels right to you.


You must be true to yourself, in order to be true to God! - Jaz
  •  

Ianianian

I'm gonna agree with the therapy thing but I also wanted to say that one of my biggest tip offs for being ftm was that I couldn't quite capture the female perspective in my own fiction writing. I could never quite peg it down and I was much much more comfortable writing a male main character. So while that's not necessarily an end all be all definite indicator, it's definitely a strong sign.
  •