Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Greater transgender visibility hasn't helped nonbinary people – like me

Started by stephaniec, October 13, 2015, 06:20:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

stephaniec

Greater transgender visibility hasn't helped nonbinary people – like me

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/oct/13/greater-transgender-visibility-hasnt-helped-nonbinary-people-like-me?CMP=share_btn_fb

The Guardian/Alok Vaid-Menon via Creative Time Reports Tuesday 13 October 2015 07.15 EDT

"I often walk around the city wearing a beard and a skirt. This is when I'm most myself, but it's also when I'm most afraid of people's reactions. As a South Asian nonbinary person – someone who does not identify as a man or a woman – I have grown accustomed to people being disgusted by me, to strangers calling out on the street, "What the hell is that?""
  •  

Alison-Rose

As someone who identifies as non-binary, I've found that it would probably have been a lot easier for others (but not myself) if I'd come out as wanting to transition fully. I try explaining my sex never changes and that it's my gender that fluctuates, though from personal experience it seems as if there's still very much a fear of those living outside the binary system - not all of us are willing or able to present as cisgender members of society, plus we have to consider that many people don't live up to this unfair expectation despite never doing anything to consciously alter their appearance in order to feel more comfortable.

One particular roadblock I've experienced is that apart from possessing several features that mean I'm unlikely to ever "pass" without the need for highly invasive surgery that may not even be physically possible due to various problems I suffer from, my frame is just so uncharacteristic of either sex that I'm seemingly forever destined to be stuck in the middle, so to speak. My intention has never been to gender->-bleeped-<-, yet as time passes it's clear that I'll always be seen as either an effeminate man with a few typically masculine characteristics, or a male desperately trying to be a woman yet falling way short of the socially constructed mark.

My partner has been incredibly supportive ever since I came out to her, and I've always asked for her honesty, whether this is in how she's coping with my genderfluidity or what she thinks of me when I'm going all-out to present as the opposite sex. Despite previously looking to transition, I'm now more comfortable as someone who is free to switch my outward gender to fit more how I feel inside, but it seems as if the rest of the world still isn't as understanding of the difference between these two terms. I don't want to focus on specific cases, but does anyone honestly look at someone like Ruby Rose* and see a biological male?

While I have to agree that it's fantastic the media is suddenly increasing visibility of transgender people, I don't believe there is much that can be done right now to change the wider perception of anyone who either chooses to exist outside of the gender binary or lacks the ability to present as exclusively one sex/gender, even if this is their intention. That article starts off with a caption pointing out the horrible expectations I now face in my life of having to sometimes be a thin, attractive woman, as if these values alone define a woman's femininity. For these reasons, I'm resigned to accepting that for now I'll be forever perceived as simply trying.

My greatest dream is to walk among other citizens and not have people stare at me for refusing to confirm to their gender structure, being able to show up at work and be accepted for who I want to be at any given point. I've already encountered pressure to transition from so-called experts, though I certainly don't blame anyone for pushing me in that direction. The fact remains that when I first sought the advice of a therapist, there wasn't such a thing as a genderfluid flag and the transgender tipping point had yet to happen - never mind society beginning to accept at a glacial pace that there may be life beyond the rapidly outdated binary.

*I really don't mean to be unfair here, but what she feels is more honest self expression remains to be seen by most as an effort to challenge longstanding conventions. I genuinely would love nothing more than to see the day a person decides to be seen as the opposite gender and can do so in safety from ridicule or even physical hostility without being judged as either consciously trying to do so or failing miserably in their efforts. Regardless of how we present to better match the way we identify inside, it's rarely a choice for us, and the one thing we all share is that we're still humans who deserve the same rights as those comfortable in their skins.
  •  

suzifrommd

Quote from: Alison-Rose on October 13, 2015, 08:26:05 PM
I try explaining my sex never changes and that it's my gender that fluctuates, though from personal experience it seems as if there's still very much a fear of those living outside the binary system

I'm not sure it's a fear, as much as a discomfort. As a species we are programmed to gender people as one of the two binary genders. Our system of reproduction has depended on it. So when we come across someone they can't gender cleanly it overloads our circuits.

I am very impressed, Alison. I spent all of about three weeks imagining I could handle living outside the gender binary. In the end I picked one of the two binary genders, which meant transitioning and living as a woman. My interest in not standing out muscled aside my interest in being genuine. I tell very few people (outside of this forum) that I'm non-binary.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Asche

Quote from: suzifrommd on October 14, 2015, 11:13:03 AM
As a species we are programmed to gender people as one of the two binary genders.
I disagree.   It is cultural.  We are raised from birth to classify people as "male" or "female" and treat them differently based on that classification, in the same way that in the USA we are raised to classify people as "white" or "black" and treat them differently and interpret their behavior differently based on that classification.

And I think that whether the habit of gendering people is "programmed" or cultural makes a difference.  If you believe that our brains come wired to gender people, then there's not much we can do -- non-binary people are just victims of biology or evolution or something.  It amounts to throwing up your hands.

But if it is cultural, then we* can change it.  It may be hard, but it's in principle possible to get people to make room in their minds for "neither" and "undetermined", in addition to "male" and "female."  Or to come up with ways of interacting with people and interpreting their behavior that don't depend upon classifying them as "male" or "female."

* -- for suitable values of "we", of course.
"...  I think I'm great just the way I am, and so are you." -- Jazz Jennings



CPTSD
  •  

suzifrommd

Quote from: Asche on October 14, 2015, 08:01:41 PM
And I think that whether the habit of gendering people is "programmed" or cultural makes a difference.

I totally agree. It's colored a lot of the decisions I've made about how to present myself and the importance of "passing".

Alas, I wish I could go along with the cultural explanation. It would make our outlook far less bleak.

But I'd ask why things like reparative therapy for gay people have proven to be so impossible. If gendering people were a cultural habit that could be relearned, couldn't we get gay people to change or open up their sexual orientation by teaching them how to not gender people? In practice, that has proven to be impossible, so I'm not holding much hope that it would work for the rest of the population either.
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

Asche

Quote from: suzifrommd on October 15, 2015, 06:05:13 AM
If gendering people were a cultural habit that could be relearned, couldn't we get gay people to change or open up their sexual orientation by teaching them how to not gender people?
I don't think that people's sexual orientations are really all that much a function of how they gender people.

One reason is that sexual preferences actually aren't as simple as "turned on by women" or "turned on by men."  "Gay" and "straight" are oversimplifications of what actually goes on.  (Just as "male" and "female" are simplifications of the actual biology.)  If you look at what turns individual people on, you'll find that people aren't really turned on by particular gender categories of people; they are turned on by particular types of people, which can often be oversimplified to "turned on by women" or "turned on by men" if you don't look too closely, and even then, they often have exceptions.  For example, if you pick some particular gay man, you'll find that he isn't turned on by all men, but only particular types of men (e.g., burly hairy men), and there will be the occasional man (or maybe even woman!) who isn't his "type" but still turns him on.

Add to that a tendency to assume that you'll be turned on by who you think you're supposed to be turned on by, so that people's sexual preferences often seem more binary that they really are.  (Note that "supposed to" depends upon how you identify yourself -- if you think of yourself as gay male, you'll believe you're supposed to be turned on by people you gender as male.)


Also: I don't think you can eliminate gendering by convincing individual people to stop it.  For one thing, you are socialized to do it starting practically from birth.  For another, it's reinforced by your interactions with other people.  How two people interact depends upon their genders, so if I behave towards a woman the way I've been socialized to behave towards a man, or vice versa, I'm going to get into trouble.  With most people, I basically have to gender them (and figure out how they've gendered me) if I want my interactions with them to be at all comfortable.
"...  I think I'm great just the way I am, and so are you." -- Jazz Jennings



CPTSD
  •