Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

What causes a person to be transgender?

Started by HughE, November 25, 2015, 11:23:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Gertrude

Quote from: traci_k on November 30, 2015, 12:56:53 PM
Good answer Hugh. You got me thinking so I ran a couple of other internet searches. The in utero hormone wash makes a lot of sense. What if it were anti-androgenic compounds exposure or alternatively, anti-estrogenic exposure? That could perhaps explain some the ftm cases. While we were considering purely pharmaceutical exposure, what if there was maternal environmental exposure? Doing the various searches on anti-androgen and anti-estrogenic chemicals, I came across this from a Danish study.

Danish Scientific Study Concludes Chemical Estrogens Causing Decreased Fertility and Maculinity
http://www.hormoneimbalanced.com/danishstudy.html

This wasn't the only time I came across reference to this study, but this put it pretty succinctly. Doing the reverse anti-estrogen  searches brought to light many chemicals with the reverse effect.

Given various genetic make-ups and exposures could give us the non-homogeneous effects we see. I mean, let's face it if the chemicals are in the water and on the foods consumed, we should see "clusters" of mtf and ftm cases. Nut, given different genetic make-ups and sensitivities, perhaps some people are more prone to being transgender.

Just a thought.

Part of the problem is measuring who is transgender. Right now, it's based on those that self identify in studies. There's a lot more that don't than do identify. If someone could design a study that captured a majority, that would be useful.
  •  

diane 2606

I was conceived in early spring 1946, out of wedlock. I can only imagine the emotional stress my mom must have endured during that point in history. She and my father, a big band musician, married that June. He had to quit playing music and go find a "real" job, which caused him to become an unhappy person who took it out on the rest of the family. Oh, yeah, my mom smoked and drank through my gestation, too. I share those facts from my history because I think they have some relevance.

I've done a fair amount of reading on the subject transsexualism and brain chemistry. Frankly, there are some hypotheses on the causes that sound pretty convincing to me, but nothing has been conclusively proven. I'm most comfortable with the concept that quantity and timing of appropriate hormones during fetal development have much to do with the gender identity of the child after birth. While chemical intervention from docs, as Hugh argues, is likely the cause in some cases, the timing and quantity of hormones is probably the culprit in most.

The nice thing about timing and quantity is that it accounts for both MtF and FtM throughout history. It isn't dependent on medical advances to account for the existence of transsexuals.

Could the stresses of being a single, pregnant woman in the mid-1940s have altered hormone delivery? I don't know if my mom was given synthetic estrogen, or other drugs, during her pregnancy. I also don't know if her smoking/drinking affected testosterone delivery. In 1950, when I first expressed my non-conforming thoughts, I learned very quickly to suppress, suppress, suppress. After me, my parents produced three daughters, none had gender identity issues.

As you can see, I'm new here, and didn't want to miss making a timely post on this thread. I'll see if I can find any of the research I read. I had everything on a laptop that was stolen a few years ago. I haven't bothered to recreate my files.
"Old age ain't no place for sissies." — Bette Davis
Social expectations are not the boss of me.
  •