I have both the classic and now the soft. I prefer the soft, but it is more delicate, and lint sticks to it quite a bit. It also sticks to me, which I guess I really don't mind so much, since it helps with holding it in place. My classic started to peel a little under the shaft about 2 weeks after I bought it, but never really got worse. It is not as comfortable as my new soft 3inch, which, by the way, has a flat back...this is different than my classic 4 inch with the 3D scrotum.