Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

I took a gender test online

Started by KristyWalker, March 06, 2016, 09:53:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

KristyWalker

I took a test online (and everything you see online must be true! Lol.) The test came back with a result that does not match how I feel and know I am a woman in a man's body. I am not questioning who I am but answered all the questions honestly. I am thinking since it did not figure in my being ADHD and LD or that it was written in 2006 the test gave me the answer I am a transgenderist I have not heard that term before. I do know 100% I want to go on hrt after that I will have to think about going further as of now I want to keep "it". I am thankful I have had amazing coping skills I have always been okay with myself when I start to feel bad I remind myself "I am who I am no matter how people perceive me". Now that I am out to everyone  it is harder I want to start hrt sooner than 12 months living as a woman like my therapist wants me to.

Sent from my SM-G920T1 using Tapatalk


[/url]
  •  

kittenpower

Which test was it? I took a test online called a C.O.G.I.A.T.I. a long time ago. When I started seeing a therapist, she had me take some Kind of personality inventory test from the DSM.
  •  

Reptillian

They're never 100 percent accurate though.
Terminologies
...
Igsexual : The identity in which one takes the position of the worldview that sexual attraction is not coherently defined and cannot identity within a sexual identity unless a reference point of what's sexual attraction has been coherently defined
Cis-genderless : The perspective in which one has no gender mentality although identify with sex organ
  •  

KristyWalker

That sounds like the test

Sent from my SM-G920T1 using Tapatalk


[/url]
  •  

Michelle Fay

Yes fun doing the on line test lol, but loved Kitten power answer about 9 lives , being transgender sometimes would be good to be a cat think 9 lives would come in handy lol 
  •  

jimmie

I've taken some of the tests too.  As I was taking them, honestly, I couldn't help being slightly biased in the ways I answered.  But I think we all want a way to confirm what we feel inside, and for me I don't think the tests are definitive but they are kind of fun.
  •  

Devlyn

I think we have a 99% accurate test: If you find this site and make an account, you're probably transgender.  :)

Hugs, Devlyn
  •  

stephaniec

it's pretty funny to have test to see if your trans when 90% of the medical community haven't the slightest idea what to do with us if they've even treated a transgender before or even have seen one.
  •  

Tristyn

Quote from: stephaniec on March 07, 2016, 09:56:03 AM
it's pretty funny to have test to see if your trans when 90% of the medical community haven't the slightest idea what to do with us if they've even treated a transgender before or even have seen one.

I'm sorry but the way you said that made me laugh. This is funny because, like you said the majority of the medical field have little to offer us. Hence why we continue to strike so much controversy to this day just from being ourselves. Ridiculous. I mean, when I first came out I thought there could be a test but it makes more sense that there in no accurate gender test because we aren't even fully understood yet in the fields of medicine and science like you said, Stephanie. Great point.
  •  

Kylo

Ah the online gender tests.

My fave of these is the one that claims to identify your sex based on how you write.

I've written professionally before and tend to be fastidious about how I write. Only in the last few years have I let colloquialisms slip in when hanging about in forums and such... anyway, the test identifies me as female 100% of the time. So I ran some classic literature excerpts written by men through the thing and they too are identified as female. In short, anyone using proper English is female. Even when they're not. :D
"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

Asche

I tried the COGIATI test recently.  I was not impressed with the questions, so I couldn't take the "diagnosis" seriously.

Whoever created the test seemed to have a rather limited and outmoded idea of what being transgender or transsexual is about.  The test seemed to rely a lot on gender stereotypes and very narrow ideas of "masculine" and "feminine."  All the questions assume you're binary M to binary F.  (No F2Ms need apply.)  And there's no provision for "non of the above" for any of the questions, nor for leaving any of them out.  This was a problem for me, since I'd say for at least 1/3 of the questions, there were no answers that remotely applied to me.

This test really belongs in a Cosmo or Reader's Digest -- from the 1950's.
"...  I think I'm great just the way I am, and so are you." -- Jazz Jennings



CPTSD
  •  

Devlyn

Well, it should be noted that the person who came up with the test has stated it's not effective and was done to show medical researchers that a test was possible. Do your homework, people.  :)

Hugs, Devlyn
  •  

Reptillian

Quote from: King Phoenix on March 07, 2016, 10:29:32 AM
I'm sorry but the way you said that made me laugh. This is funny because, like you said the majority of the medical field have little to offer us. Hence why we continue to strike so much controversy to this day just from being ourselves. Ridiculous. I mean, when I first came out I thought there could be a test but it makes more sense that there in no accurate gender test because we aren't even fully understood yet in the fields of medicine and science like you said, Stephanie. Great point.

You could get close to accurate, but you're still going to be running into problems. For examples...

If someone identifies as a male, and with little negligible differences observed in light of recent evidence regarding psychology of men and women behaves as a woman, and the test only place emphasis on behaviors, the test will come to show that this person who identifies as a male is gender-neutral or a woman despite that is not how he sees himself.

And then, there are people who perceives their bodies as opposite of what their body says or they feel differently than what their identity is, but still insists on identifying the way that their body is saying, there are test that do not account for individual logics and how one comes to a certain identity, and that means according to some test, they are trans.

And even if you can account for everything, you are still going to get some discrepancies between individuals' actual identity and results. In the end, there's just no truly known effective way to determine a individual's gender although you could assume a individual is cis just because the majority is cis, but that's not going to work in a place full of people who aren't cis.
Terminologies
...
Igsexual : The identity in which one takes the position of the worldview that sexual attraction is not coherently defined and cannot identity within a sexual identity unless a reference point of what's sexual attraction has been coherently defined
Cis-genderless : The perspective in which one has no gender mentality although identify with sex organ
  •  

suzifrommd

IMO, online tests are not worth the paper they would have been printed on. Their value is about the same as those quizzes in women's magazines (Are you a Flirt? Take our test and find out!)
Have you read my short story The Eve of Triumph?
  •  

KristyWalker

Last night I was tired and had a few beers in me. I realized that  know no test could possibly take in all factors.

Sent from my SM-G920T1 using Tapatalk


[/url]
  •  

Tamika Olivia

The tests are mirrors, some of them rather warped. They are your own ideas reflected back through, mostly, shoddy science and stereotyped reasoning. That you took them, that you are here, that you are seeking these answers is far more indicative than the tests or their results.

You have a fairly good idea of who you are, so trust you. Also, it's weird that your therapist is requiring RLE prior to hormones. That is kinda out of vogue these days.
  •  

Annis

I've taken a few tests online too and most of them said that I was a man questioning his gender identity. DUH! Thanks for the help. I know what it's like to want to be able to have a poll to fill out and it gives you definitive answers but where it counts is in your heart; how you feel inside. No specialized online tool can truly determine whether what you feel is right.
  •  

KristyWalker

Thank you all! I am going to make an appointment with the psychologist my doctor recommends. I don't want HRT tommorow but still want it sooner than a year. I am thankful I have had the coping skills so until coming out the the dysphoria had been very manageable and now it is my fear and my years of denial to myself because of my misunderstanding that if I was sexualy attracted to woman I could not be transgender I just recently found out that is a misconception.

Sent from my SM-G920T1 using Tapatalk


[/url]
  •