Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Name Changing

Started by kings joker, January 22, 2017, 03:04:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

kings joker

So I have a name that is a nickname for several feminine names but idk if a guy walked in and said my name is ____ people would really question it. It's not quite neutral but still to uncommon to really be pegged. I think it would be easier to change my name for things like jobs, documents etc but I'm not necessarily dysphoric about my name. So my question is how did you know you wanted to change your name? I know those who have very female names didn't really have a choice or feel connected to it but with mine being so kinda in between I feel like it really falls onto do I want to.
  •  

Kylo

Because of what it represents. My father named me and I don't like the guy, so changing it feels a bit like a new start. Don't get along with either of my parents, so it feels a bit like breaking out of their mold and taking charge.

I actually kind of like my old name, I hated it when I was young but I grew to like it. And it's one of those unisex names so there's no actual pressure to change it, just the urge to get rid of bad memories and start over. Might be motivational. And something new.

Most family are going to insist on ignoring my new name I expect, so it's more for me than anyone or anything else.
"If the freedom of speech is taken away, then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter."
  •  

TransAm

Both my previous middle and first names could be easily masculinized (and frequently were growing up) in nickname terms. On paper, though, both were feminine.
I simply had them legally changed to the masculine versions, though people in my day to day life are still calling me what they always have (the male 'nickname' derivative). If your name on paper is somewhat neutral and you like your name, maybe it's not really something you have to concern yourself with.
On the other hand, Kylo has a good point about starting fresh.

You really just have to decide if it's worth the hassle. I will recommend that you settle on a decision before you have your gender marker changed (if you intend to do so, of course) so that both can be altered simultaneously.
"I demolish my bridges behind me - then there is no choice but forward." - Fridtjof Nansen
  •  

kings joker

I actually didn't consider the fact that both my first and middle legal names are very feminine so changing it might be necessary. I wrote this with my nickname in mind but I have used since toddlerhood.
I actually have the opposite issue of kylo. I love my family and really like the sound of all my names strung together but are very feminine. I think my family will be kinda hurt if I change my name and will think my dad will take it as another blow. I'm afraid I'm moving a lot faster then my family can handle and I just don't want to hurt them more. I don't want my name change to wipe the past away and that's kinda what I'm hesitant about I guess.
I've been looking up names online and like the idea of changing to a more masc name but its a really big step...
  •  

Alexthecat

Quote from: kings joker on January 22, 2017, 04:34:11 PM
I actually didn't consider the fact that both my first and middle legal names are very feminine so changing it might be necessary. I wrote this with my nickname in mind but I have used since toddlerhood.
I actually have the opposite issue of kylo. I love my family and really like the sound of all my names strung together but are very feminine. I think my family will be kinda hurt if I change my name and will think my dad will take it as another blow. I'm afraid I'm moving a lot faster then my family can handle and I just don't want to hurt them more. I don't want my name change to wipe the past away and that's kinda what I'm hesitant about I guess.
I've been looking up names online and like the idea of changing to a more masc name but its a really big step...
You transition for you. You can take what your family thinks and says into consideration but do not let it sway you from doing what you need to do for yourself. Family can suck it up; you are not being selfish when it comes to your own mental health.

  •  

kings joker

Quote from: Alexthecat on January 22, 2017, 04:42:27 PM
You transition for you. You can take what your family thinks and says into consideration but do not let it sway you from doing what you need to do for yourself. Family can suck it up; you are not being selfish when it comes to your own mental health.
I know. However, this was a whole fight my dad and I had a month ago when I was home. I'm trying to not have the same thing happen. He is of the opinion that I should wait a few years to start hormone. Though we both agree that it is just his opinion and I can do what I want, I still don't want to hurt him again with changing my name. So I'm just trying to really know before I mention anything to my family.
  •  

Alexthecat

Quote from: kings joker on January 22, 2017, 04:47:59 PM
I know. However, this was a whole fight my dad and I had a month ago when I was home. I'm trying to not have the same thing happen. He is of the opinion that I should wait a few years to start hormone. Though we both agree that it is just his opinion and I can do what I want, I still don't want to hurt him again with changing my name. So I'm just trying to really know before I mention anything to my family.
Almost every parent says to wait a few years. They hope that you will change your mind even if they do not admit that is the reason.

  •  

kings joker

Quote from: Alexthecat on January 22, 2017, 05:35:15 PM
Almost every parent says to wait a few years. They hope that you will change your mind even if they do not admit that is the reason.
That's interesting you say that. It really hurts me to have him say that. I'm not sure if it hurts because he thinks I should wait as if I'm going to change my mind or if it hurts because he doesn't fully understand how painful it is existing in a body that doesn't feel right.
  •  

Alexthecat

Quote from: kings joker on January 22, 2017, 05:42:44 PM
That's interesting you say that. It really hurts me to have him say that. I'm not sure if it hurts because he thinks I should wait as if I'm going to change my mind or if it hurts because he doesn't fully understand how painful it is existing in a body that doesn't feel right.
I would say that it is both. Tell him that it hurts you when he says it. For a parent to repeat things that they know you do not like would just be cruel; show his true colours at least.

  •  

FTMax

There was no way I could have lived as a man with my old name. I also never liked it, so two strikes. Like Kylo, I liked starting fresh. I kept my initials the same but otherwise there's no similarity between my old name and my new one. Well, both middle names are a bit outlandish, but that's it.

Agree with Stone Magnum - settle on a name and change both your name and gender marker at the same time, or you'll get charged twice when updating documents the second time around.

Also agree with Alex. My parents wanted me to go slowly, even though they were supportive and understood that I had been waiting almost 8 years to have the resources to be able to transition. I do think it's usually because they hope we'll change our minds. I've made it through an entire medical transition in just over 2 years. It has been tough for them to keep up with because I've basically been on to the next thing every six months or so, but they did eventually fall in line and start getting things right consistently.
T: 12/5/2014 | Top: 4/21/2015 | Hysto: 2/6/2016 | Meta: 3/21/2017

I don't come here anymore, so if you need to get in touch send an email: maxdoeswork AT protonmail.com
  •  

kings joker

I guess I'm just having trouble because I don't dislike my nickname. I'm actually the one who decided to be called it at such an early age but I couldn't imagine changing my name legally to my nickname when I might as well change it to something more masc.
  •  

Alexthecat

Quote from: kings joker on January 22, 2017, 09:34:16 PM
I guess I'm just having trouble because I don't dislike my nickname. I'm actually the one who decided to be called it at such an early age but I couldn't imagine changing my name legally to my nickname when I might as well change it to something more masc.
You can get your name changed legally to something completely different from your current legal name and your nickname and then still be called your nickname. There's not a magical rule that says just because your legal name is not related to your nickname that your nickname no longer can be used.

  •  

kings joker

That's a good point. I could use my nickname when I'm with family, so not to completely erase it, and use my legal name amongst friends and co-workers. Best of both worlds?
  •