Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Transsexual vs Transgender, Which Term is More Important to You?

Started by Jayden, The Bagel Paragon, July 11, 2017, 09:14:15 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Miss Clara

Labels are sometimes necessary depending on the circumstances and the context in which the subject of one's sex/gender arise.  For example, I recently found a new primary care physician to look after my health needs.  In my introduction, I informed her that I was a post-op transsexual woman.  That description was meaningful to her.  Describing myself as 'transgender' would have been ambiguous, requiring further explanation.  If I had simply identified as a 'woman', I would have been withholding pertinent information important to future medical advice and treatment with potential consequences to my health and well-being.

I will refer to myself as transgender when the details of my situation are not really germane to the conversation.  The way I see it, sex and gender are two separate characteristics of a person.  One's sex is a physical characteristic, while gender is a social/behavioral characteristic.  I am transgender because I once identified as a boy/man, but now as a woman.  That is, I went from identifying and presenting as a man to identifying and presenting as a woman, first part-time, and, eventually, full-time.  My sex remained male during that time.  I might have further identified as a drag artist, cross-dresser, transgenderist, or described myself as gender fluid, non-binary, or gender queer.  No matter the label, physically I was still male.

But despite having changed my gender identity from male to female (as others perceived me), I was still physically male which was very discomforting to me.   I had strong male body dysphoria.  The expression 'trapped in a male body' felt very real to me.  I needed to go beyond changing my social gender identity to transforming my bodily sex from male to female.   That need/objective distinguished me from transgender people who have no need or desire to medically alter their bodies.  I began the long process of transforming my physical sex from male to female. 

Like Charley, I identity simply as a woman.  A female woman.  No other qualifier is necessary under ordinary circumstances.  But if my past must be divulged, transsexual is a more precise descriptor than transgender.

  •  

Ryuichi13

It seems that people are basically saying that "transgender" is mental, while "transsexual" is physical.  I suppose that may be true. 

However, I refer to myself to others as transgender.  It has become an easier word for the general (cis)public to understand, therefore one I tend to use. 

In my mind, the term "transsexual" has negative connotations (a la Jerry Springer and movies that lampoon transsexuals), therefore I would rather say "transgender in the process of transitioning" for that reason.  Unless someone is one of my doctors, whomever I'm speaking to does not need to know if I've had any surgeries, they only need to know I'm transitioning. 

Before I began travelling down this road, I heard soneone say, "sex is who you go to bed WITH, and gender is who you go to bed AS."  To me, this was the simplest, easiest way I've come across to describe my situation to a cis person.  I still tend to say it to any new cis person I speak to on the subject...IF I even decide to tell them.

I have lived as a man for quite some time now, and despite the accident at birth that made this body female, I have always been metally male, and now that I'm transitioning, I will continue to live outwardly as a male for the rest of my life. 

So, to answer your question, I am a man.

Ryuichi

Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk


  •  

Miss Clara

The terms 'sex' and 'sexual identity' have become synonymous with 'sexual orientation' in the minds of many people.  That's unfortunate.  Sexual identity (being male or female) says nothing about sexual orientation (sexual attraction), nor does is say anything about gender identity.

As I see it, sexual orientation is who I go to bed with.  Gender identity is who I go to bed as.  Sexual identity is who I am in bed (male or female). 

Isn't it interesting how we want to distinguish gender from sex in some situations (e.g, dating), but conflate them in others (e.g., bathrooms). 

  •  

Jailyn

If I may say so we are a very bright bunch, lol!!! I love all the points everyone has made. This has given me more thoughts and stuff to think on for sure. Sum this all up we are very complicated beings and nothing will change that. Keep the thoughts coming I love this discussion.
  •