It's amazing how disclosing a bit and being honest with myself changes things. And I'm definitely confused as heck, trying to figure out who I am.
But now I'm leaning more MTF. I spent a lot of time talking to my wife, with her asking some pointed (and valid questions) and some serious contemplation on my side - where is my destination? How do I want to be.
I really appreciate the help on this topic - it's really helped me and helped with confidence to figure out who I am, and I appreciate being believed (even if I was still trying to tell myself that there was a path other than the one I know I need to go down). I'll be changing my name on the forums and moving over to other sections - thanks in part to the support here. I wish everyone here happiness and joy!