I have only used patches, so I can't do a comparison. But I have had no problems with them. The ones I use last half a week (3.5 days). I change them Friday mornings and Monday evenings, to get the most even spacing.
I've been on HRT for nearly a year, so about 100 patch changes, and I have only had problems with one or two not sticking. If I am careful to stick them on wrinkle-free the first time, they never give me problems. They only fail to stick if you have bad wrinkles so water can get under them in the shower, or if you try to reposition it after you have stuck it on. Apparently, the adhesive only works well once.