Recently, I found a new eyeliner by Wet N Wild called Breakup Proof. I prefer the gel. It is the only one I have found that doesn't flake off and get in my eyes.
I have to agree with Chrissy, lipstick comes in at a close second. I use Maybelline Colorstay in pink. I don't like the feel of lip gloss or other products that leave my lips sticky or greasy. The Colorstay lipstick stains the skin, so I put it on first. When I am done getting ready I can wipe most of it off and my lips are left with just enough color.