Well, I don't know anything about Melzer, but I'm posting this from my bed at the Brassard recovery residence, and I have high praise for him and his team. My surgery was excellent, the aftercare superb, and while I won't see the final aesthetic result for a few months, I'm sure it will be great, and I have depth to spare. In fact, a couple of people have told me that even tho they didn't have a lot of material, Dr. Brassard was able to give them adequate depth without an external graft. I'm 56, but I DEFINITELY plan to use my new bits in intimate situations.