Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

The Cogiati (combined gender identity and transsexuality inventory) test

Started by tinkerbell, June 13, 2006, 07:31:07 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Jillieann Rose

Yes do try taking it again. When I took it before, that was about 5 months ago, I was only a 2.
Oh how I have changed.
:)
Jillieann
  •  

Elizabeth

High everyone,

Despite the stereotypes and generalizations, I rarely hear people say that they disagree with the results.  What I hear most often is that the results are pretty right on, with how the person sees themsleves. I first took the test two years ago and scored a 270, a year later 275, yesterday 310. I attribute the change in score to a change in my attitude.  This first two times I took it, I beleived that because of high blood pressure I could never take hormones or transistion.

One heart attack later and a lot of discusssion with my cardiologist and an article by a cardiologist that is 18 years post op, made me realize that I am not locked out.  That changed my answers to several questions, hence the higher score.

As unscientific as it may be, it seems most of us agree with the final assessment. I think the question about how we see ourselves may be the only question that is valid. I still hold that the mental health community does not tell us we are transsexual, we tell them. Bottom line, if you beleive you are a transsexual, you are.  If you beleive you might be one, than you might be on, if you beleive you are not one, you are not one.  All anyone knows is what we tell them. There is a reason stereotypes become stereotypes.

Love always,
Elizabeth
  •  

Kimberly

375

Uh, so that seems to be Number 4 again. *chortle* Yea, pretty probable.
By the by in times past it seems I came up 280.

Yay? ;)
  •  

umop ap!sdn

Hey neat we get to do this quiz here ;D (seriously - it is interesting to see the distribution of results).

I've taken this test so many times and got so many different results - I mean some of the questions I really wasn't sure what my answer would be (those all would be stereotyped questions, not identity type questions ;) ) and typically would get a level 4 as a result... but I took it again for this thread just for grins to see what I'd get and I've just barely edged my way into a 5 (total score 410).

Math is not one of my strong points; this evening I had to add 29 to 16 and my mind just froze up. I can easily tell if someone *likes* me; people have always lauded my spelling/vocabulary; couldn't tell you which way is south without looking at the constellations (or setting Sun, of course, but even that would take me a minute while I place it in a familiar setting); I always flunk those 3D shape rotation questions; sound and music are my world, and if something I said bothered somebody, I'd lose sleep over it. :-\ But on the other hand I'm a science geek and 'scuse me but strangers getting in my personal space is a bit much. :P

I wish I had known a year and a half ago what I know now about the COGIATI and other tests like it, that are based on stereotyping. I used to honestly believe that a person's brain was somewhere along a one dimensional spectrum and that if I could convince a psychologist that I was *female enough*, they'd give me the go ahead for HRT and SRS. It was a while until I could afford to see someone, and when I did I finally caught on that this all doesn't mean diddly, but during that while it was all still a big concern to me.  ::)

Someone posted something elsewhere on the internet that I think is really true. The gist of it is that stereotypes apply to groups but not to individuals.
  •  

Melissa

I also got 410, classic transsexual (you think?).  I got classified as probable transsexual before, but I was still in denial.  My problem is that I am good at math, which lowers the score and I have good reflexes, which lowers the score and I don't mind being close to people, which also lowers the score.  These are all stupid stereotypes and I do not think these to be typical of the female population.  However, the last portion of the test really does ask some good questions. Some that I would suggest to people still trying to find out more about themselves.

Melissa
  •  

Melissa

Thanks tinkerbell, that's where I did take the test including the first time.

Melissa
  •  

DawnL

I scored 290 which is a bit funny since I've fully transitioned and no longer consider myself a transsexual.  After all, I DON'T want to be a man  ;)  I excel in English and do poorly at math but can read a map, find my way around strange places effortlessly, and routinely score highly on spatial orientation quizzes--all "male" traits.  Feminists have railed against such stereotypes for years with good reason, they're stupid and may be meaningless.  When women and men are socialized in more similar ways, taught in similar ways, many of these supposed gender differences may disappear.  The BBC website has a brain-gender test that is somewhat better that can be found here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/hottopics/intelligence/brain_sex_quiz.shtml

Enjoy!

Dawn
  •  

Hazumu

One thing I've noticed that's changed since starting HRT is it's harder to pinpoint the source of a sound.  And I think I've figured out why that is.

Having worked in and around sound recording/processing/reproduction, I've sharpened my own audio processing skills, and was able to pretty well localize the source of a sound by ignoring early reflections and reverberation.

Lately, though, I find myself paying much more attention to the reverberation, as if it's a textured tapestry.  It's as if sound is no longer a seperable event, but now an enveloping event, and inseperable from my total experiencing of my local environment.  I have to concentrate extra hard to pull off the old trick of localization.  Not that I'm complaining about it, of course!  ;)

Karen
  •  


michelles

I took the test a year ago and then again a week ago, while I don't remember the exact score I no I fell into the number 3 range both times.  No test can tell a person who they are, but it can help them start looking for answers in a different way and I think that is what the test did for me.
  •  

Chynna

170

I'm probably a Transsexual!!!!!!! :D
Damn now I have doubts!! LMAO

Although question4 & 54 where biased because I don't like physical contact due to abuse issue's
  •  

Kaitlyn

I decided to retake this, since the last time I took it was some years ago. I got a 340, which is higher than last time, but it's the same result of '4'. The math/language thing still bothers me though. When I think back to when I started grade school, I don't really recall there being much difference to how I felt about math vs language, they're were just both things I had to study, and I was good at both, but in the end took math more seriously I guess. But what I do recall is that it seemed like my parents were more concerned about my progressing well in math. Not doing 'as well' in language courses wasn't a major concern and was seen as excusable, since math was 'more important' to my future and career. Nature vs nuture maybe?
  •  

umop ap!sdn

I wish the BBC link would give a number, but in any case the meter went pretty far over to the right for me. More so than last time I took it, which was before starting on my meds.

I recall seeing a study published in a scientific journal (lost the cite, sorry) that involved something akin to those "find the matching pairs" puzzles where you have to uncover hidden objects which requires remembering where each one is in the grid. They found that postmenopausal women taking estrogen showed a modest improvement in their ability to solve the puzzles over those not taking estrogen. They mentioned something about receptors in the brain.

As misleading as it would be to take the results of these tests literally, it is all the more so if some of the questions pertain to hormone related effects. It'd be like asking someone if they are already experiencing the effects of something they're not even taking yet.
  •  

Jillieann Rose

Right on Tinkerbell.
I am what I am or is it we are what we think.
Anyway I agree.
:)
Jillieann
  •  

JenniferElizabeth

I took it about 4 years ago and was truthfull, and got the classic transsexual. But, as I was taking it, I could see that it had no way to takers from lying and getting a perfect score if they wanted to. if you read carefully, it is very stereotypical, worded just the way you hear known TS to describe being TS.
Was nothing new. All you have to do is read and answer with the most female sounding answer, or TS one. Waste of time and for what? It wont get you anywhere. For that you Have to see an exp therapist, endo, ect. Sorry just my thoughts.I know there are 2 other tests like it out there.
  •  

Melissa

  •  

Rana

I just realised, I was talking about somthing else, was the Gender Test at Sparklife.
They have other interesting tests as well, but I cannot vouch for their accuracy ie, The Jerk Test - said thats probably what I was,  as if :(   AND the American Test - had the hide to say I was an American?  as if

However they are fun. This is the web addy (Moderators is it OK to post this??  if not please delete it : http://community.sparknotes.com/sparktests/index.epl
  •  

HelenW

FKA: Emelye

Pronouns: she/her

My rarely updated blog: http://emelyes-kitchen.blogspot.com

Southwestern New York trans support: http://www.southerntiertrans.org/
  •  

tinkerbell

okay for our new members, a blast from the past :P

You know, this test is reaaaaaaaaaally inaccurate....my last result was 200, and now it is 85....oh no!  am I transitioning backwards or what?  blah!


tinkerbell :icon_chick:
  •  

BrandiOK

I scored a 450 which makes me a Cat 5 raving transsexual LOL.

I feel like I should notify the hurricane center or something :P
  •