Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

Rep. Frank, Stop Blaming The Community

Started by Shana A, February 09, 2010, 08:24:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Shana A

Rep. Frank, Stop Blaming The Community
Filed by: Dr. Jillian T. Weiss
February 7, 2010 5:30 PM

http://www.bilerico.com/2010/02/rep_frank_defensive_and_apoplectic_on_enda.php

Thursday, Representative Barney Frank gave an interview to Michelangelo Signorile on SiriusXM. Frank was alternately defensive and apoplectic. He spent the entire time blaming the LGBT community for lack of movement in Congress. He was full of rage and contemptuous of the community. It was a shameful performance.

The incredibly unflappable Signorile asked about the failure of Congress to move on ENDA and DADT, and the President's failure to lead. Frank's angry response was that the LGBT community has failed to lobby Congress. He characterized our community as "lazy" and "whining". He said "that is why we will lose" on ENDA and DADT. It was obvious he was more interested in defending himself and his cronies than in providing any leadership.
"Be yourself; everyone else is already taken." Oscar Wilde


  •  

Stephanie2664

I have personally thought this guy was an idiot, and more of the problem in Congress with nothing productive to contribute.

Have a great day.   :)
Stephanie

***  Fade to Black  ***


  •  

lizbeth

not to ruffle feathers, but he does sorta have a point.

this fight for civil rights pales in comparison to past civil rights movements. I think the largest motivating factor to mobilize them (women in the 30's and blacks in the 60's) was suffrage. not every homosexual person wants to get married and not every homosexual wants to serve openly so it's not the strongest rallying cry to channel a movement - at least not quickly.

most of the movement is still online and until it takes to the streets in an order of magnitude greater than it has already (outside of California's prop 8 marches, I suppose) it isn't going to influence congress in the slightest. their bread is buttered by the large corporations and the religious right much more so than the LGBT and supporters.

my 2 cents

  •  

SarahFaceDoom

I love Barney Frank.  All he's doing is trying to call people to action on causes that are very near and dear to his heart.  I'm sure to him sometimes it gets pretty lonely in congress fighting all of our fights without much thanks for it.

I don't get the catty read on it either.
  •  

BunnyBee

Totally agree with the recent posts.  He isn't blaming the community, he is frustrated that his community hasn't had his back, so to speak.  I appreciate the honest expression of his feelings.  It's kind of refreshing to see from a congressman.

Regarding transpeeps, I sometimes wonder if we have enough of a fighting spirit to ever really try to claim our rights- with many content to blend into the woodwork, many others too ashamed to speak up or out, and many more so psychologically and emotionally damaged by the trauma of being themselves in this world that they do well just to wake up and take on the day.  Society has done a real number on us and I just fear that it will ultimately make us "keep our place."

I have seen a lot of positive changes though recently in attitude.  I will keep hope that such trends will have inertia.
  •  

Alyssa M.

Here's the thing about Barney Frank: His "community" isn't queer folk. It's the 4th Congressional District of Massachusetts, and it always has been. And his community by and large loves him. He does a damn fine job representing their mainstream liberal values in Congress. I don't think he understands the gay rights movement as it exists now, but that's not his job. What he misses is that most activism in the movement happens at home, in families and communities, by people coming out and speaking out and making conservative friends and relatives get over their bigotry. And I think it's working fairly well, if slowly. Still, he's certainly free to criticize.
All changes, even the most longed for, have their melancholy; for what we leave behind us is a part of ourselves; we must die to one life before we can enter another.

   - Anatole France
  •  

spacial

The problem for the TG community seems, in part at least, to stem from our failure to find a common ground to state our case.

On opposition, we face labels of sexual degeneracy. But I suggest, a greater source of opposition will come from men who fear being confronted by a TG women and not know.

The effect upon young men of dating a man, even one who might appear very feminine and even be physically feminine is known to most people. Most young men spend much of their time attempting to deny they are homosexual, that they are actually normal. This seems to be one of the more basic male emotional responses. There is certainly a lot of historical evidence for it.

My personal feeling is we need to concentrate our claim for acceptance on individualism. That each individual in society has a basic right to live free from dogma.

The claims of medical or biological justification are, at best, unproven. But more importantly, they further denigrate our image by suggesting we are somehow ill and not in control of our actions.

I appreciate the needs of Americans, who need to find a medical justification to obtain medical insurance coverage. But sadly, this is tending to make the situation worse for the community as a whole.
  •  

tekla

His "community" isn't queer folk. It's the 4th Congressional District of Massachusetts, and it always has been. And his community by and large loves him. He does a damn fine job representing their mainstream liberal values in Congress.

Ahh, someone studied Civics.  Spot-on!
FIGHT APATHY!, or don't...
  •