Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

You have to change your last name

Started by Princess_Jasmine, July 31, 2010, 10:15:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Princess_Jasmine

I have a very interesting story to tell.

I came out two years ago to a close minded middle eastern Christian six person family. No one accepted it and they tried to "cure" me through various methods, especially my father. There were times where he would make me walk in front of him in the neighborhood trying to teach me to "walk like a man". After I told them I was a girl and I wanted to live as my true female self, hell broke loose in my home. I was not allowed to go into my sisters room, my dad forced me to cut my hair short (but he's always done this to me because they've always known about my femininity), I was not allowed to hang around my female cousins if they came over, I could not move my hands when I speak, walk feminine in any way whatsoever, and I had to act like a man. Well, because I have always been extremely feminine (not to be confused with flamboyant) from the day I was born, I have never been able to do any of the above. No matter how hard my father tried or threatened me or tried to scare me into "being a man" it never worked. Everyone could tell I was such a girl and this always angered my father. In my culture, the father is pretty much the one who determines everything, so if he accepts me, then everyone else in my household would. But he did not.

One year ago when I realized nothing was changing, I started HRT in secret under a doctor's supervision. I had to know what I was getting myself into if I was really choosing this life and whether the hormones would even work or not. So I started hormones and changes came fast, and I should point out that I was 19 when I started them. My face began to femininse, my nipples protruded, and what little muscle mass I had disappeared. After about four months on hormones, I was still presenting as male (but really I just wore skinny jeans and tank tops with tight hoodies all the time) and no one could tell anymore that I wasnt a boy. I was always referred to as a female wherever I went even though I had very short hair, and by this time, my father started picking up how feminine my face was.

On New years day, my mom came to my room and told me that my dad said my chest was pointing out and that he thought I might be taking hormones. This scared me to death because I knew if he found out I was on hormones, he would do something drastic. So, I began binding my breasts. Months later, I realized my face looked completely like a girl, and yet my family could still not grasp that I was a woman. Nothing was improving and no one cared. I realized I couldnt live like this anymore, doing hormones in secret and not really living as myself, wasting time for people to accept while I could be living my life. So,I left three months ago which was extremely shocking to do in our culture. Even though we live in the United States, we stick to our traditions. Everything was horrible at home because I am the youngest in the family, and in strict middle eastern culture, you dont leave the house until you marry, especially when your older siblings are still home. I am now living full time as my true girl self and I pass extremely well and have had no issues at all with that. In a couple weeks, I will have been on hormones for a full year.

The issue now is just not being able to see or talk to my mom. She never put me down my whole life or told me I was "possessed by the devil" for being different and we had the closest bond. We have tried to talk once a week in secret on the phone to keep our relationship, but she and I always break in tears and she wants me to come back to God and be the boy that God created, but thats never going to happen because I'm a girl.

So now, this past Friday she pretty much told me that I have to change my last name because my father doesnt want someone like me to be associated to them and shame the family honor. Omg I burst into a mental breakdown of tears and it wasn't really the fact I had to change my name but it was because she was the one who told me. I feel like it really is the end where they really will never accept me no matter what. I mean, its been two years since I came out, and three months since I left home and still no budge from anyone to support me or want me to come back home as the real me. It hurts so bad because I feel so betrayed and unloved and I don't understand how anyone could really do this to their family. I learned that their really is no such thing as unconditional love and it breaks my heart that they could just leave me like this for the sake of people from our culture not seeing me so that it doesnt look bad on my family name. I don't know how to cope with this anymore. I just know that I dont regret transition AT ALL because I am not depressed anymore about life. It just hurts finally having found peace within myself but having no family to go home to. Can someone please help me make sense of this?
  •  

Hermione01

I am sorry to hear about your circumstances but it sounds like it may be a rough time ahead for a while yet. It's only been a few months since you've left, so things could change considerably over the coming months and years. Mainly with your mother and siblings who I am sure will defy your father for the love of you. I am afraid that your father may be a lost cause.

Again, I am sorry. I hope you can regain the courage you gathered when you left the family home to go on with what needs to be done. Changing your last name isn't so bad, I've done it myself. But I understand that it is the rejection of yourself that hurts and changing your last name is the final cut from your family roots.  :(
  •  

Princess_Jasmine

Thank you Hermione01. I know I need to be strong :( I applied to a really great university this summer and got accepted. I am transferring with my AA that I just finished this summer, and I will be attending as...the real me! I am just looking forward to focusing on school this fall.
  •  

lilacwoman

Quote from: Princess_Jasmine on July 31, 2010, 10:36:00 PM
Thank you Hermione01. I know I need to be strong :( I applied to a really great university this summer and got accepted. I am transferring with my AA that I just finished this summer, and I will be attending as...the real me! I am just looking forward to focusing on school this fall.
Once you get to Uni you will be accepted as the woman you are and life will get better.
Uni shoudl provide you with lots of ways to build a great social circle that will keep you busy so you don't have lots of loneliness.
Once you get there make sure you send the family all the Xmas or whatever cards and send your mother a nice letter every week or so to let her know you are happy and doing well.
The family may accept you eventually but lots of Middle eastern 'ethnics' are very transphobic so they may not.   Keep your last name as it may help the legal matters.
  •  

Sarah B

Hi Princess Jasmine

I'm sorry you had to hear from your mother that you have to change your name, however I would suspect the request did not come from your mum, but your father.

I'm afraid there is no easy answer to 'Can someone please help me make sense of this?".  However, family tradition, cultures and a patriarchal father or culture is the main reason behind the request to change your name.  Because a patriarchal family or culture is a social system where the father or eldest male is the absolute head of the household or village, having absolute authority over all the men, women and children.

Your defiance, has shown him to be weak and the only way, he can gain any measure of control or self respect over his family again is to ask indirectly through your mother to ask you to change your name.  I would assume he knows that your mum is still talking to you.

I know you love your mum unconditionally and from what you have said about your mum, that she loves you also unconditionally.  Keep this in mind at all times.

A couple of things I can suggest.  First change your name to an appropriately female ones (maybe with suggestions from your mum, I will come back to this point in a minute).  However, do not change your last name, if you do not want to.  I hope you have applied to the university you will be attending, using your female name as this will make your life extremely more easy later on.

Second, in regards to your mother, somehow I don't know how, get in contact with your mother, maybe by phone or arrange some way to see her when she is not surround by other members of the family and hence your father will not know about the meeting and tell her you love her very much, you cannot go back to the way you was and ask her what would she have called you.

It's not easy to be without a family and I do not know how it is myself, because my family found out about me and fortunately they accept me for who I am, even though they can be a pain.  You are a strong person, because you showed strength, determination, courage and defiance despite what was thrown at you.  This will be the foundation of a truly remarkable strong women.


I final thing, I agree with what Lilacwoman said.  So take care and all the best for the future.

Kind regards
Sarah B
Be who you want to be.
Sarah's Story
Feb 1989 Living my life as Sarah.
Feb 1989 Legally changed my name.
Mar 1989 Started hormones.
May 1990 Three surgery letters.
Feb 1991 Surgery.
  •  

rejennyrated

What an awful thing to be told. I do feel terribly sorry for you.

However I think that, painful as it may be to do it, changing your last name may be for the best, both in terms of making life easier for any of you family who do want to stay in touch despite your fathers attitudes and indeed your own personal safety.

There are sadly quite a few in this world who take the matter of family honor to the point that they condone attacks and killings on people who they deem to have shamed them. So really if changing your name cuts that bond and allows you to start fresh it may be for the best.

Good luck - if you need a new family name I'm sure there are many of us on here who would be honored to share our family name with you.

Ps - oh and as an interesting little aside, I have been writing a screenplay about a fictional postop transsexual member of a royal family. In doing this I had to do a lot of detailed research. Undoubtedly  the strangest fact I came across was the story of a real life middle eastern Princess who did indeed under go a sex change operation in the 1980's. So unbelievable as it may seem, your screen name is actually not as fanciful as you might suppose, such a person does truly exist. Middle eastern culture is indeed complex and has very many well hidden facets to it.
  •  

Cindy

Hi Jasmine

As others have said I'm sorry things have not turned out the best. But they have turned out pretty good ::). Ok you dad has rejected you, but you can keep in contact with your mum. You are a healthy young woman at Uni. You have a marvelous life ahead. From your post you are feminine, good looking, ambitious and educated.  Keep looking at the positives, and as liliacwomen said keep sending letters and cards to the family, particularly detailing your success in anything. Study; looking awesome in a gown at a formal; with your girlfriends chilling out. You as the woman you are. I think M & D may end up having discussions about their daughter. But it may be a long term thing.

Also, you haven't lost a family. You have gained one. Here. Post away.

Hugs

Cindy
  •  

spacial

Quote from: Princess_Jasmine on July 31, 2010, 10:15:16 PM
It hurts so bad because I feel so betrayed and unloved and I don't understand how anyone could really do this to their family. I learned that their really is no such thing as unconditional love and it breaks my heart that they could just leave me like this for the sake of people from our culture not seeing me so that it doesnt look bad on my family name. I don't know how to cope with this anymore. I just know that I dont regret transition AT ALL because I am not depressed anymore about life. It just hurts finally having found peace within myself but having no family to go home to. Can someone please help me make sense of this?

Many families do indeed put conditions on their love. Most will accept you as a criminal, even a thug. But many don't accept you being who you are.

It's a reality many of us have had to get use to. We can turn this to a positive by not infliciting the same on our children.

best wishes Jasmine
  •  

Diane Elizabeth

  Where do they get off telling you to change your last name.  If they are so embarassed then let them change their last name. 
Having you blanket in the wash is like finding your psychiatrist is gone for the weekend!         Linus "Peanuts"
  •  

Samantha_Marie

OMG sweetheart I'm so sorry...

I wish there was some magic wand I could just wave and if not change our bodies, then at least change their minds.