Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

What do you think of my coming out letter?

Started by HelenW, December 27, 2006, 05:14:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

HelenW

Here's a draft of the letter I'm writing with whose contents, with minor variations, I'll be using to come out to people.  Please give me an honest opinion of what you like and what you'd change.  THNX!

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

My purpose here is to tell you something rather dramatic (but not bad!) so I decided to write it in letter form so I don't miss anything important.  After you're done reading we can talk, if you wish, and I'll answer any question you might have.

Over the past year and a half I have been dealing with an epiphany that has shaken me to my very core.  It put me into a severe depression that I'm only recently begun to get out of.  Two weeks before my 50th birthday I recognized that I was suffering from a medical condition known as "gender identity disorder" (GID), specifically, that I'm male to female transsexual and that I had been fighting and repressing this knowledge for most of my life.  I was devastated by this.  My self-identity was completely destroyed along with my self confidence.  I asked myself, if I am so good at fooling myself am I fooling myself now?  Is this a delusion?  A warped "midlife crisis?"  I realized that I could not handle this alone.  I was sinking deeper and deeper into despair so I decided to find someone to help me with it.  I found and started seeing a psychologist who works through the Buffalo Children's Hospital specializing in sex and gender problems, Dr. Thomas Mazur.

I started to see Dr. Mazur last December with the request that he work to provide me with either a confirmation of my self-diagnosis or another reason why I might feel the way I was feeling.  I underwent some tests and wrote an autobiography.  As I continued therapy I got more and more depressed.  I got so low that I began to actively plan my suicide.  I felt that I just HAD to get rid of the pain.  I felt that I had no other options left.  I can't ever get that low again.  Last August Dr. Mazur delivered the news that he could find no other reason for my feelings, no differential diagnosis in "doctorspeak," and that I was correct in my thinking.

You may have heard of transsexualism but probably only through popular culture and talk show sensationalism.  These sources have generated a very false and damaging stereotype of who and what a transsexual, or for that matter what any transgendered person, really is.  In reality, GID is about who a person feels themselves to be inside, their inner identity.  Most people have no disconnect between what they feel themselves to be and what their external image tells them they are so it never becomes an issue.  It's a given.  People that have GID, however, feel as if they are one gender on the inside even though their anatomical sex is opposite of that.  It is NOT related to sexual orientation.  Being transsexual is not about being gay.  It is also not about sexual gratification, not about being a fetish.  It's not about who or what turns me on.  It's about who or what I am.

There is no cure for GID.  Doctors, scientists and other interested individuals have tried to find the cause, and effect a cure, for this condition for the past 100 years.  Nothing they tried had any permanent affect.  Certain religious organizations have claimed cures but the data they provide is questionable, if it is even made available, and is thus unbelievable.  My personal idea about their so called successes is that they may be able to help people repress this, I was able to do that for many, many years without anyone's help, but they never really cure them and make these feelings go away.  The causes of GID are also not really known.  The best evidence to date indicates that this condition is a birth defect, caused by a misapplication or mistiming of male and/or female sex hormones during pregnancy or just after birth.

While there is no cure there is, thankfully, an effective treatment for GID.  Some may consider the treatment to be very radical and others may not, feeling that if it helps people ease their suffering, it's worth it.  Basically the treatment is to have the patient change their life to living from one sex, or more accurately, gender, to the one they identify with.  In popular parlance, to have a "sexchange," even though it's really much more than that.  These changes cover a myriad of details - sometimes, but not always, culminating with surgery designed to alter the genitalia and other sexual characteristics to the self identified gender.  The methods of change also include taking cross-sex hormones, electrolysis and continuing psychotherapy.  The person is encouraged to more and more present themselves as the person they feel themselves to be.  The process is quite lengthy and is commonly referred to as a "gender transition."  Some choose not to use this cure, for various personal reasons.  Some people do it on a part-time basis and are satisfied with that.  Others eventually go to living full time as the gender they feel themselves to be.  The process for this treatment is laid out in a protocol named the "The Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association's Standards of Care for Gender Identity Disorders"

As for myself, I have, with Dr. Mazur's approval, gone to an endocrinologist: a doctor that specializes in the endocrine system, the parts of the body that produce and use hormones.  The endocrinologist prescribed drugs that suppress testosterone (the primary male hormone) and others that replace it with estrogen (the main female hormone) .  These drugs will, over the next few years, produce what essentially will be a second puberty, only this time it will be in the direction that feels right to me.  I have made no decisions yet about living full time as a woman or about getting facial or genital surgery.  My current strategy is to take things one step at a time and stop when I feel that I can live with myself.  I expect my body to begin looking more and more feminine.  I can also reasonably expect my personality to change slightly, in positive ways, but that I will always retain the same basic character I've always had before.  I have chosen a new name, Helen Christine, and plan to keep my last name in any and all circumstances.

My spouse has been understandably devastated by the news of this diagnosis.  She has found it in her heart to support me in what I've had to do to regain my emotional equilibrium.  That she continues to do so astounds me and makes my love and gratitude even more inexpressible than it ever was.  I've told my mom about this and have also come out to my two sons, all of whom have been supportive.  Two people where I work know about me and have accepted me unquestionably.  While I'm slowly expanding the circle of people that I've told about this I'm still essentially living in the closet as far as my employer, the financial industry and the government are concerned.  If anyone asks abut what's going on with me, please ask them to ask me directly.  That way I can give them a copy of this letter and explain it to them personally.

I've added a number of information sources, both in book form and on the world wide web, that explain the details behind the condition I've been found to have.  Of course, I'm open to any question that's asked in the spirit of expanding your understanding of my self and this arcane subject and, while I would rather not be the butt of any cruel jokes, I believe that recognition of the humor that can arise from this process can be very therapeutic for all concerned.  I hope you can find it in your heart to accept this news as it should be: as news of an unalterable medical condition in a friend whose life will be completely turned around by its treatment.

Thank you, hugs & smiles,
Helen
FKA: Emelye

Pronouns: she/her

My rarely updated blog: http://emelyes-kitchen.blogspot.com

Southwestern New York trans support: http://www.southerntiertrans.org/
  •  

Jillieann Rose

My honest opinion Helen is that you have did a very good job of writing this letter.
It is a very good and honesty disclosure of what has been happening in your life.
And I'm sure it will be a great help as you share with other.
:) :)
Jillieann and JR


  •  

Steph

Hello Helen.

A very good letter, very similar to the one I used myself several years ago.  Not too simple and not too complex.

Steph
  •  

jamie lee

Helen this is a very good , if not great letter ! I just wish I had this talent if putting my thoughts on paper. I find this very, very hard to do and it probly why I don't post much.

Jamie.
  •  

cindianna_jones

Good?  Naw, it's great.  In fact, it's touching.  You have written a wonderful letter Helen.  I'm sure that it will be read and understood by those who know you.

Cindi
  •  

GQPAT

Wow...it's awesome....my only lil' critique (and this might only apply to me) is that if this is for one of your parents/siblings it may seem a tad formal/academic! However, again, this may just be me and the way my family works...don't worry hun I still think it gets the point across in a VERY succinct fashion!!  Good luck you!

Cheers: Pat
  •  

Julie Marie

Helen, the letter is wonderful and very informative.  However when I place myself in the shoes of someone who knows little or nothing about this I find some problems.

In coming out to people I know I have seen a pattern that is pretty consistent.  They can only handle so much before they shut down.  Then I tell myself "Keep It Simple Stupid!"  In my desire to thoroughly explain myself I tell them everything and most can't handle it.  In a real sense each one of us has the equivalent of a PhD in transgender studies.  When a doctor goes into minute detail about something with a lay person the lay person soon gets lost and turns off.  I think that may happen with you letter.

But I would certainly keep all you have written to be available for those who need/want to know more.

Now, if you've read some of my posts, you'll know I refuse to accept I have a disorder or any other type of mental problem.  My problem is physical.  And even the professionals in the field treat my physical self.  My mental self is only treated to help me deal with things like prejudice, intolerance, hatred, etc.  While it's important to explain to mainstreamers you have been professionally diagnosed as transsexual, personally, I would shy away from any hint of mental disorder.  You never know how someone will take that.

You mentioned suicide.  I wouldn't.  People will see that as you being unstable and it could result in a boss or other workers making your life miserable at work so you'll quit.  That way they don't have to deal with your problems.  You could soften it and say you lost the desire to live, or something to that effect.  Suicide conjurs up too many negative images.

Please don't see this as beating up on your letter.  I think it's lovely but that may be because I understand it completely.  I live it.  I'm trying to see it as someone who has no clue would see it.  If I may continue...

You brought up being transsexual very early in the letter.  A person could very easily just stop reading at that point because of their prejudice and everything else you wrote will go unread.  If you write something lengthy, you need to keep the reader wondering where this is going.  If instead you focused on things everyone could relate to - sadness, questioning where your life is going, something eating away at you inside - they will read your words with a "I know what it's like" feeling and your letter will touch their heart rather than their brain.  Once you're inside their heart you can let them know exactly what's causing this emotional trauma.

I would avoid anything that would support their thinking there's something wrong with you.  You mentioned your spouse was "utterly devastated".  Joe Blow could see that as support for his negative feelings, "Hey!  Even the guy's wife thinks he's nuts!"  We live in a pretty ignorant society and we have to remember that.  You said your family supports you, that's all anyone needs to know.  Keeping the letter positive reduces the chance of supporting anyone's prejudices.

All in all I love the letter, for someone who knows the life.  It covers so much very well.  I think it's something that you can keep, as you said, as something to give to anyone who wants to know what's going on with you.

What needs to be kept in the forefront of your mind is this is something that will be put in writing and can be passed around to anyone and everyone.  You will have no control over its distribution.  The person looking for a weakness, so they can criticize it, will find it.  You need to keep the weaknesses to a minimum.  The letter should convey a strong person who has been to hell and is on her way back.  She needs a hero's welcome as she returns.

I hope you understand this is constructive criticism.  My intention is only to point out the possible pitfalls so you can avoid as much hurt as possible.  People won't change their attitude in one letter but maybe it can open some doors for them.  Hopefully they will take advantage of that.

Good luck Helen.  I wish you only the best.

Julie
When you judge others, you do not define them, you define yourself.
  •  

Kate

It's VERY well-written. Although I'm quite a ways from coming out myself, I've been toying with these letters too. I don't know if there is a "right" way to do this. But having said that, one thing I've noticed in my own letters is a need to apologize and justify what I'm doing, as if it's wrong somehow.

QuoteI got so low that I began to actively plan my suicide.  I felt that I just HAD to get rid of the pain.  I felt that I had no other options left.  I can't ever get that low again.

As others have said, I realize we want people to know the depths of our crisis, but I fear they read this as us being emotionally unstable. They may read "suicide" and think the GID is just *part* of an overall instability problem, not a cause of it. Instead of seeming like transitioning is a reasonable, well though-out decision, it now comes across as an act of emotional desperation (I know it largely IS, but I'm not sure we should emphasize that point).

QuoteWhile there is no cure there is, thankfully, an effective treatment for GID.

To me, this implies that GID is inherently wrong somehow, and SHOULD be cured... there's an implied, "While there is no cure YET" in there.

Transitioning IS the cure, IMHO.

I like mentioning doctors, and how others have accepted this. That's a great way to let people know it's not freaky to everyone. People tend to think, "well, if it's OK with so and so, I guess it's not so bad..."

And letting everyone know what's going to happen is GREAT. I think that's what people really want to know: "How will this affect ME?" I suspect this is the most important focus of a coming out letter.

So again, just some random thoughts. I've been struggling with this as well, juggling between a one-liner saying, "I'm a woman now. Deal with it...." and a multi-page essay on theories of transsexualism with footnotes, bibliography, etc., lol...

Kate
  •  

Kimberly

I like it, although a little bit longer than I normally use, informational overload and all.  My strategy is different, but generally speaking it is a roll of the dice regardless so go with what feels right, I suggest.  Also for what it is worth and just in case they fell though the cracks, see also: https://www.susans.org/wiki/Sample_Letters
  •  

HelenW

Thank you all for your kind responses.  Many good points were made and I'll take them all under serious consideration.

again, Thank You ! ! !
helen christine
FKA: Emelye

Pronouns: she/her

My rarely updated blog: http://emelyes-kitchen.blogspot.com

Southwestern New York trans support: http://www.southerntiertrans.org/
  •  

Brianna

"Nothing they tried had any permanent affect."

Effect, spacekat.

It's a good letter. I think it's a little vanila in terms of explaining the strength of your feelings, but that's just my opinion.
  •