Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Your writing style - Feminine or Masculine?

Started by Dora, December 21, 2010, 03:06:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Fencesitter

Oh, I studied literature and I did not plunge into this subject but we had a lecture about it. As far as I remember, it has been tried a lot to figure out which writing style is male and which is female, and how to recognize it. There seem to be some tendencies, but you cannot pin it down. And especially when it comes to professional writers, it gets very unreliable.
  •  

Alex201

  •  

Lee

Ran a couple of things through:

Female Score: 266
Male Score: 902

Female Score: 849
Male Score: 1683

Female Score: 511
Male Score: 1223

Female Score: 565
Male Score: 1047

At least I'm consistent.   :laugh:
Now I'm curious who decided "a" is masculine....

However, my handwriting is frustratingly girly.  It's really loopy, slanted cursive.
Oh I'm a lucky man to count on both hands the ones I love

A blah blog
http://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/board,365.0.html
  •  

Silver

Well I decided to give this a shot. Put up an rp post I wrote.

Words: 1088
Female Score: 1260
Male Score: 1425
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!

So. . . I guess I should be satisfied?
  •  

Yakshini

I posted a short story I wrote a little over a year ago. It's about zombies.  :D :D
Anyway, I got this as a result.

Words: 4314
Female Score: 4745
Male Score: 6315

The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!
  •  

Alexmakenoise

Nonfiction:

Words: 799
Female Score: 865
Male Score: 1081
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!

Fiction:

Female Score: 493
Male Score: 590
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!

  •  

spacial

Quote from: Alex201 on December 22, 2010, 10:57:22 PM
My handwriting style I cant even read!

I hear that. I was illiterate until I bought my first typewriter.  :laugh:
  •  

Rock_chick

My thoughts on this are don't read to much into it. It's interesting but not conclusive. Also due to the way it works, you need to be putting in large chunks of text for it to analyise.
  •  

Donnie B.

I did it for a lot of stuff I did recently, as well as a few years ago, and it said male for all of them. Correctamundo in my case, then again I've always been very direct in my writing thanks to a professor helping me with my essay writing skills, and my straightforward story telling.

Eh, I wouldn't get overly disappointed if it had said "female", though, because this is a bit interesting, but not a divisive "you must not be female if you scored male on this test" kind of thing.

To point out handwriting- mine's small, angular, and always perfect. Then again, I'm known for being a bit of a perfectionist.
  •  

yin_haan

What a load of nonsense. And they wonder why feminists frequently charge that our education system is riddled with male privilege...

It seems fairly obvious from the selection of words they describe as male v. female seem on the male side to heavily weighted toward words which indicate specifics and concretes (a, the, at, said, is, these, to), whereas the female side is weighed toward conditionals, feminine personals, and relationals (she, her, hers, with, should, if, and, we). I find it funny that they consider "me", "myself", "when", and "where" to be feminine, while considering "as", "what", "more", and "it" to be masculine.

In fact, the single largest hit on almost all of my writings seems to be the word "the". I simply don't see how this could have any basis in scientific fact, when the majority of the most basic words used in the English language all fall under the masculine side. I have a hypothesis that these two researchers (both men, by the way) have a large misogynistic bias in their assumptions.

Oddly enough, the only sample of my writing that turned up female in their test is a section of a work of fiction I'm writing that incidentally consists largely of a dialog between two men.
  •  

yin_haan

And just for ->-bleeped-<-s and giggles, Bev Jo's article for The Magazine Project, "Transwomen" Are Merely Castrated Men, turns up overwhelmingly "male", as does the excerpt of Germaine Greer's book, The Whole Woman reproduced on Lynn Conway's website at http://ai.eecs.umich.edu/people/conway/TS/Rogue%20Theories/Greer/Exorcism%20of%20the%20mother.html

I think we can assume that Bev Jo and Germaine Greer are both cis women, can't we?
  •  

Mr.Rainey

From some short stories and crap I have written-

Words: 151
Female Score: 145
Male Score: 279
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!

Words: 107
Female Score: 64
Male Score: 135
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!

I think it is just a silly thing, who knows how acurate it is. The only basis for it being plausible in any way is the fact that some of the male words are descirbing words, which males are usualy more visual. Also a lot of the words that were used for the ladies were words used when talking about events, which seems logical because women tend to talk about people and details of things they do.
  •  

Atreyu

Words: 371
(NOTE: The genie works best on texts of more than 500 words.)

Female Score: 192
Male Score: 538
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: male!


it's almost scary how good this thing is, huh? :P
i agree with Mr.Rainy though. looking back at the words, that makes sense.
  •  

gail123

Words: 1811
(NOTE: The genie works best on texts of more than 500 words.)

Female Score: 2414
Male Score: 1688

I was somewhat surprised to learn the Genie identified my writing as Female, as I had always thought of my writing as the one  masculine trait I possessed.

I'm not sure how valid this is but it is entertaining.
  •  

Samantha1

I'm doing a continuing story on my blog of a girl on a romantic night.  It's in the first person,
and I'm deliberately making it as "girly" as I possibly can.  I'm a pretty good writer - I've written a
couple plays now.  So this is stacking deck about as much as you can, and I came up female
2 out of 3 times, and the one I missed on, I missed by a lot:
#1 - A Cabin North of Duluth: F:528 M: 426  - Female
#2 - Bailey's on Ice: F:505 M:1300 - Male (Ouch!)
#3-A Little Thing, Like a Kiss: F:754 M:501 - Female

I'm not worrying about it, because the third one is very girly, but
the second one is not manly, it's just not as feminine.
When I write with the objective of appearing girly,
I think I will incorporate some of these hints on word choice.
Otherwise, eh.

PS, this entry F162 M270 -Male
Oh yeah! who's the man!

  •  

inna

well, I submitted fiction I have written long ago and here is the score:
Female Score: 271
Male Score: 79
168 words

Feels good, but the significance of such test is disputable  ???

I just submitted another and here it is:

Words: 217
(NOTE: The genie works best on texts of more than 500 words.)

Female Score: 228
Male Score: 189

The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: female!

Well, my conclusion is this; if I will go full time I will stop talking and every time I will need to speak to a stranger I will write a lengthy note, then for sure they will see me as I truly am, female!
  •  

Double_Rainbow

I took a whole bunch of my posts from various forums and mashed them together under the 'blog' category.
Words: 646
Female Score: 1323
Male Score: 881
The Gender Genie thinks the author of this passage is: female!

Gender Genie thinks I am female?!  All my worries have been lifted and I feel completely at ease with myself........NOT!  These things are hardly accurate.  But c'mon peoples, deep down you were hoping it would be what you wanted it to!  I know I did!  ;D

  •  

N.Chaos

Oh wow, I can see myself wasting entirely too much time posting excerpts from my stuff into that thing haha...
I scored male on just about everything except, ironically, the goriest thing I've written thus far. That's...funny to me for some reason.
  •  

Chantal185

I find male/ female writing styles very interesting ie words that men and women seem to use differently in conversation etc. However I find this thing a little bogus. Especially considering words like the "and" "at" "and" "who" are considered masculine and words like "when" "should" "and" and  "was" are considered feminine. I think according to this system it would be very easy to write something that sounds very much like it was written by a girl and come up male or vice versa. However at the same time there are a lot of differences between how men and women form sentences. For me I do notice certain words and speach patterns that men and women seem to display differently. For instance I find that men are usually more get to the point and tend to write about the specifics of the topic for instance in a journal they will write what happened that and what they did whereas a more feminine way to write is to explain the feelings and emotions of your day, and who you did it with, what you felt, and the connections between the activities. When I write I usually write more feminine and use more feminine speach patterns etc. However when I analyzed some of my journal entries and forum postings in the gender genie I got a good mix of masculine and feminine traits which I will not complain about. However I did notice a certain pattern in that whenever I talked about my experiences with other people or what I did Christmas day it would come back feminine whereas if I was bantering on about something that drove me nuts, or something more technical like the wording on my homepage. It came back male. I don't know what to think about this, but it is interesting. I remember seeing an info-graphic before of the 50 most common words used by men and women, and it did seem to make sense.
  •  

Chantal185

ahhh... my last forum posting came back.

Female Score: 384
Male Score: 704

oh well. no biggie, It just shows how variable this all is.
  •