Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

An Open Letter to NPR

Started by Shana A, January 29, 2011, 09:09:26 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Shana A

An Open Letter to NPR
Posted by eastsidekate at Friday, January 28, 2011

http://shakespearessister.blogspot.com/2011/01/open-letter-to-npr.html

Dear NPR news,

Thank you for Richard Gonzales' coverage of the Berkeley city council's proposal to fund health care for transgender municipal employees during this Thursday's All Things Considered.

Because it's so routine and careless for media organizations to bungle coverage of issues pertaining to trans and gender non-conforming people, I tend to respond to inaccurate or transphobic reporting with some combination of silence and weary sarcasm. However, NPR News has a well-earned reputation as a responsible journalistic organization, so I actually trust that you'll take my remarks into consideration.

Transsexual is an adjective, not a noun (e.g., transsexual person, transsexual woman, transsexual man).
"Be yourself; everyone else is already taken." Oscar Wilde


  •  

Nobuko

I'll be honest, don't really care much for the whole 'Transsexual is an adjective, not a noun' statement. Then again, any type of linguistic prescriptivism typically rubs me the wrong way.

I guess I can see part of the reasoning, as I'm guessing anyone who says a statement like that is likening transsexualism as a transient identity or a disease. And when someone has a disease you don't refer to them as 'an autistic' or 'a disable'. Some people hear 'This person is a transsexual' and think it's functionally equivalent as 'This person is a cripple'. And then there's all these accusations of insensitivity and unwitting 'transphobism'.

Many people use 'transsexual' as a noun in much the same way as people use country names as nouns to refer to people. And although the term 'American' has its fair share of positive and negative associations, I've never heard of someone trying to change people's attitudes about Americans by telling them they shouldn't use 'American' as a noun.

If anything, I see the excessive pedantism when it comes to language as counterproductive, because it's irritating to people who don't intuitively grasp what they're doing wrong. The subtle nuances of difference between 'I am a transsexual' vs 'I am transsexual' or 'I am a transsexual person' are lost on almost everyone, and it'd be a lot more productive to change people's attitudes over changing the way they happen to speak.
  •