Susan's Place Logo

News:

Based on internal web log processing I show 3,417,511 Users made 5,324,115 Visits Accounting for 199,729,420 pageviews and 8.954.49 TB of data transfer for 2017, all on a little over $2,000 per month.

Help support this website by Donating or Subscribing! (Updated)

Main Menu

Using wrong pronouns

Started by Dominick_81, May 24, 2011, 06:05:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Dominick_81

Anyone else having problems with people using wrong pronouns when they know your trans and continue to use wrong pronouns. I'm not talking about family or friends I know they will constantly get the pronouns wrong, I'm talking about like doctors that know or the nurse that gives you your shot? The nurse that gives me my shot every other week is always calling me mam (I'm not sure if I spelled that right) it kills me. I don't understand why she's calling me mam when she knows I want to be a guy? It's really upsetting. I'd like to go by my male name, but I feel uncomfortable saying anything. I hate going by my female name.

Also, I was just wondering for the guys getting their shots by the nurse or when they go to the endo for a check up, do they use your male name or your female name? And when you go to get your blood test done, do they call out your female name when your going to get your blood drawn? It would be embarrassing if you passing as male and their calling out a female name and theirs people in the room. Do you say something to the receptionist asking just to use the last name so your not embarrassed?

.
  •  

James-Alen

My boyfriend, constantly. In fact, sometimes I know I'm passing, and he'll shoot it down. It's not malicious, just oblivious. If she was calling you Ma'am while GIVING you your T shot, that is not funny. It's very rude. I know it's awkward but say something, it's very important that the nurse needs to be set straight. I don't have any docs because I'm not on T yet, but if that happened I would be pissed. I let it go most times when professionals mix up my pronouns because I haven't changed my name yet, so fair is fair.


  •  

Dominick_81

I'm sorry your bf does that. that sucks.

Sometimes after the shot, she'll say Ma'am. She's like, "there you are Ma'am"! Or like today she handed me an envelope of papers and said, "Here ya go Ma'am"! And the receptionist guy there noticed my voice getting deeper and he's like, "say that again". And I said, " my voice is getting deeper" and he's like "yeah",(the receptionist guy knows I'm trans) and that's when the nurse said, " here you go Ma'am!  And she just heard me say to him that my voice is getting deeper.

I dunno... maybe she doesn't know what to say. But I think it's obvious that I want to go by male pronouns.
  •  

Nygeel

My employer and strangers in general are my main problem. My new doctor is part of an LGBT clinic. The office took a long time to get my name right (they forgot to enter in my preferred name a bunch of times). I'm pretty sure they'll get my name right the next time I go in.
  •  

Da Monkey

Wow, really?

When I first went to my endo and gave them my ID (with my birth name on it) the receptionist was like "okay so what really is your name?" and called me Jay and he ever since.

But I recently moved and got a new family doctor and I heard her talking outside the door and realized she was referring to me as she. I was really shocked because she seemed to get it otherwise.
The story is the same, I've just personalized the name.
  •  

Mr.Rainey

When people I don't know or don't care about use female pronouns for me I ignore them and pretend that I think they are talking to someone else. When it is someone I know and am out to I look at them directly and say "I am a HE".
  •  

Da Monkey

James-Allen: Yeah I don't know how you put up with that. If that was my boyfriend, well he wouldn't be.
The story is the same, I've just personalized the name.
  •  

Inkwe Mupkins

My name isnt legally changed but i pass 200% of the time...my endo asked me what i wanna be called and he put my prefered name in the system. He always uses male pronouns even when talkng about me with others...

However my family doc goes out of her way to use female pronouns...pisses me off but i dont say anything...i stoped going for my shot i now do it myself
Islam means peace.
  •  

Sharky

Correct them, make it clear what you expect from them.
  •  

EliNewGuy

So, just out of curiosity, how would y'all interpret it if someone you thought was a friend was pissed off at you and made a point to start off a text to you by putting your "girl name" in caps and in quotes, even though you've been going by your "boy name" with him for nearly a year?
  •  

tvc15

The doctors and nurses at my clinic asked which pronouns I preferred, and they stick to them. I even noticed that they do it when I'm not around, as I overheard a dialogue between a nurse and the doctor before they came into the room I was in.

The thing that bothers me the most though, is when people meet me as I am now and assume I'm male, until they find out I'm trans and then use female pronouns. I don't really think there's any excuse for that when I've introduced myself to them as a male. I can understand it for someone who knew me before, and had to get used to new pronouns. But I was talking to my therapist the other day and she referred to me as "she." She apologized, but it was still rough. Cause, you know, that's my gender therapist. Same for my dad's girlfriend. I even got on her case about it, and she gave me this long speech about how sorry she was, and that she understood, but she never bothered to get any better.

Also as for Eli's question: I would be pissed off. That's a really dirty move for a friend to pull.


  •  

Dominick_81

Quote from: Nygeel on May 24, 2011, 06:54:18 PM
My employer and strangers in general are my main problem. My new doctor is part of an LGBT clinic. The office took a long time to get my name right (they forgot to enter in my preferred name a bunch of times). I'm pretty sure they'll get my name right the next time I go in.

I hope they get it right for you. It really sucks when they don't get it right.

Quote from: Sharky on May 24, 2011, 09:16:37 PM
Correct them, make it clear what you expect from them.

I feel weird correcting them, kinda shy about it. They see me as female for some reason. I hope I can get the courage to tell them to call me by my preferred name.

Quote from: phoenixflorida on May 24, 2011, 10:41:40 PM
The doctors and nurses at my clinic asked which pronouns I preferred, and they stick to them. I even noticed that they do it when I'm not around, as I overheard a dialogue between a nurse and the doctor before they came into the room I was in.

The thing that bothers me the most though, is when people meet me as I am now and assume I'm male, until they find out I'm trans and then use female pronouns. I don't really think there's any excuse for that when I've introduced myself to them as a male. I can understand it for someone who knew me before, and had to get used to new pronouns. But I was talking to my therapist the other day and she referred to me as "she." She apologized, but it was still rough. Cause, you know, that's my gender therapist. Same for my dad's girlfriend. I even got on her case about it, and she gave me this long speech about how sorry she was, and that she understood, but she never bothered to get any better.

Also as for Eli's question: I would be pissed off. That's a really dirty move for a friend to pull.

That sucks that people would use female pronouns once they found out you were trans after you introduced yourself as male. That's not right. I'm sorry about that.

  •  

MaxAloysius

My first endo called me she all the time, as well as using my birth name, he didn't ask me for a preffered name at all. The same with my first psychiatrist, and that woman was a specialist! My GP still calls me she, but as soon as I legally changed my name and had them fix it on the files, she calls me by that. I think her calling me by my birth name was what she considered 'professional'.

I went to another endo who specialised in trans matters in a city further away and he was great, he used male pronouns right from the start. And my third psych used male pronouns as well, and called me he all through her letter for T.

I think noting what a professional calls you can tell a lot about their experience, and how they're going to treat you in the long run. If they don't know enough about the person they're working with to even realise that calling them by the wrong name or pronoun is harmful, then should they really be working with trans people at all?
  •  

Dominick_81

Quote from: MaxAloysius on May 24, 2011, 11:23:18 PM
My first endo called me she all the time, as well as using my birth name, he didn't ask me for a preffered name at all. The same with my first psychiatrist, and that woman was a specialist! My GP still calls me she, but as soon as I legally changed my name and had them fix it on the files, she calls me by that. I think her calling me by my birth name was what she considered 'professional'.

That totally sucks.

QuoteI went to another endo who specialised in trans matters in a city further away and he was great, he used male pronouns right from the start. And my third psych used male pronouns as well, and called me he all through her letter for T.

I'm glad they got it right.

QuoteI think noting what a professional calls you can tell a lot about their experience, and how they're going to treat you in the long run. If they don't know enough about the person they're working with to even realise that calling them by the wrong name or pronoun is harmful, then should they really be working with trans people at all?

Probably not. I think their not sure what pronouns to use. But they should ask you in the beginning what you would prefer to be called.

  •  

Arch

Quote from: EliNewGuy on May 24, 2011, 09:29:28 PM
So, just out of curiosity, how would y'all interpret it if someone you thought was a friend was pissed off at you and made a point to start off a text to you by putting your "girl name" in caps and in quotes, even though you've been going by your "boy name" with him for nearly a year?

I think I would be minus a friend. None of my friends has been so immature or disrespectful to do something like this. If I had any friends who were that kind of person, well, I probably wouldn't have been friends with them in the first place.
"The hammer is my penis." --Captain Hammer

"When all you have is a hammer . . ." --Anonymous carpenter
  •  

Arch

Quote from: phoenixflorida on May 24, 2011, 10:41:40 PM
But I was talking to my therapist the other day and she referred to me as "she."

Large boulders. Tiny straw. Suction.

This borders on inexcusable...maybe it is inexcusable but possibly forgivable. Once.

I guess therapists are human, too, but a "slip" like this would not inspire me with confidence.
"The hammer is my penis." --Captain Hammer

"When all you have is a hammer . . ." --Anonymous carpenter
  •  

Cindy

Sorry again for interrupting,

A couple of things, correct medical people, straight away, not after but during. If you are having T injection and the nurse refers to you in any feminine way. STATE, it is sir (whatever you wish to be referred as). Medical people will always refer to people with the track of least resistance. They are also generally gender neutral. This is going to sound rude forgive me, it is not meant in an insulting way. If you look 'feminine' they will call you by female pronouns, if you look masculine they will call you by male pronouns. Unless they know you. I'm often referred to with male pronouns when I go to my medics, no matter how I'm dressed; how any nurse could say Hi sir that is a really cute skirt I do not know, they only do it once  >:-). Most of the medics who deal with me now call me Cindy. Which is fine. I have no problems sitting in the waiting area and the receptionist whatever calls out, Cindy you are on room 5.

I suspect and apologise again, because of FtM upbringing you may have a non-aggressive relationship to people. None aggressive males tend to be walked over, it is the nature of masculinity. So you have to break that learned instinct and be more aggressive in social circumstances.  YOU tell them straight away. YOU have to break the mould. YOU stand up for yourself. When on T it should get easier as you will become more aggressive, but you need to practice it, sensibly. It's often told to the girls at Susie's to watch how other woman their age act and relate. It is very important that you guys do as well. Young guys have a social structure that you want to fit in to. But be careful, there is aggression and violence, and most GG guys will have massively higher upper body strength until you can work out etc. So proving yourself through violence will be counter productive.

I now feel like your Grandma

Sorry, I wasn't trying to preach, but I love my boys

Cindy

Cindy
  •  

MaxAloysius

Hahaha, nice advice Cindy :P I happen to agree, I'm really forthright, and I'll say what I think, and I find more often than not rather than being offended for being called up on something they did wrong, people will apologise and most try to change the behaviour. But if you do nothing, people will think they can get away with it, and they will just walk all over you because it's easier for them.

I find in the long run, it's better to have a quick awkward conversation with someone about how they're getting it bloody wrong and if they don't stop something irreplacable is going to be damaged! than worrying constantly about them outing you or treating you in an emotionally painful way.
  •  

bojangles

Listen to your Grandma.  :angel:

Cindy hit the nail on the head. Well said.

There's plenty of mild mannered CGs in the world...but they're already pegged as male.
For us, not standing up for ourselves is a good way to continue being perceived as female.

Also, watch your body language. My posture was terrible before chest surgery & whenever I would feel awkward or uneasy with people, I would kinda shrink up even more and look down or away. This does not look male.
With all the awkward situations we go through in transition, we gotta learn to hold our heads up and walk right into it like we belong there. Men do not need permission to be men.
  •  

N.Chaos

Quote from: EliNewGuy on May 24, 2011, 09:29:28 PM
So, just out of curiosity, how would y'all interpret it if someone you thought was a friend was pissed off at you and made a point to start off a text to you by putting your "girl name" in caps and in quotes, even though you've been going by your "boy name" with him for nearly a year?

I'd rip them a new one. I had a friend call me and leave a voicemail which ended up being like "Answer the damn phone, woman" and I wigged out on him hardcore. I'm done taking it from people, regardless of who they are.

My issue is actually backwards, I haven't had anyone call me a girl in public for a while now, my family/friends are just having issues with it. I can forgive my mom because, well, she's my mom. She knows the situation, and she's trying to get used to it and that's all I can ask from her. It's my friends, though, who've seen what it does to me. That's where it pisses me off.
  •