Are there FTM gays?
1. Are there ftm who love ONLY OTHER ftm's?
2. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio/cis straight men?
3. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio Gay Men?
As a straight mtf, when I embarked in my journey I always thought all mtf were like me but then I was amazed to know that lesbians mtf exist. Some who like only cis/bio women and others who like only mtf, tv etc...and some others love both.
So I wondered if in the ftm world, if it's the same cos I NEVER heard that so far and want to extend my knowledge about this.
Yes.
Yes, there are.
If you browse the FTM section of this site, there's plenty of them even on this site. :3
There definitely are plenty gay trans guys out there, but I'm not one of them so I'll leave your other questions for someone else to answer.
No
Being gay is un-manly.
FTMs should definitely avoid that.
Like seriously what even.
There seems to be way more gay FTMs than straight.
Quote from: Sharky on January 04, 2012, 09:34:04 PM
There seems to be way more gay FTMs than straight.
I think it depends on where you're looking. I know considerably more straight trans men than gay ones.
You mean people have sex :o :o
Oh boy...
There are gay trans men. There are bisexual trans men. There are straight trans men. There are polysexual trans men. There are asexual trans men. There are trans men who are tops. There are trans men who are bottoms. There are trans men that enjoy both. There are demisexual trans men. There are trans men who are feminine. There are trans men who are masculine. There are trans men who are androgynous. There are trans men who are comfortable without hormones. There are trans men who need hormones. There are trans men who feel their quality of life is improved/could be improved with hormones. There are trans men who don't want bottom surgery. There are trans men who do want bottom surgery. There are trans men who want top surgery. There are trans men who don't want top surgery.
If you can think of it, it probably does exist.
Quote from: Brendon on January 04, 2012, 09:40:09 PM
I think it depends on where you're looking. I know considerably more straight trans men than gay ones.
I also think it varies by location/ect. I'm part of a local trans* group, and most of the guys (we don't really use the term FTM, transguy/boy or trans-masculine is more common) in the group are pansexual, bisexual, or gay. Out of the 15 who's orientations I know, only 5 identify as straight.
Quote from: Brendon on January 04, 2012, 09:40:09 PM
I think it depends on where you're looking. I know considerably more straight trans men than gay ones.
This. Online nearly every FTM is gay it seems. IRL all my FTM friends are straight.
Quote from: Brendon on January 04, 2012, 09:40:09 PM
I think it depends on where you're looking. I know considerably more straight trans men than gay ones.
Yeah I actually tried to keep my sexual orientation quiet for awhile because I'd met so many straight transmen but no openly gay ones. I felt like I was weird and didn't belong.
I do think there are proportionally more gay ftm's than there are gay cismen, and I bet we could speculate all night about the whys and wherefores.
Quote from: Happy Girl on January 04, 2012, 09:06:18 PM
Are there FTM gays?
1. Are there ftm who love ONLY OTHER ftm's?
2. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio/cis straight men?
3. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio Gay Men?
As a straight mtf, when I embarked in my journey I always thought all mtf were like me but then I was amazed to know that lesbians mtf exist. Some who like only cis/bio women and others who like only mtf, tv etc...and some others love both.
So I wondered if in the ftm world, if it's the same cos I NEVER heard that so far and want to extend my knowledge about this.
To answer more directly, if you take out the "ONLY" then I fall into all three of the categories you mentioned. I'm probably 95% gay, judging by my behavior and past lovers, but I'm not averse to dating or sleeping with women. They'd have to live up to way higher standards to get my attention though, so I don't seek them.
1. yes 2. yes 3 yes
Only thing I will say is there probably aren't many that are only into "cis/Bio straight men"
This is one of the most common questions people ask me when they find out I'm trans. First they're curious as to my own sexual orientation. (Straight.) Then they want to know whether trans people can be gay. I just tell them that trans people are just like cis people. (Although then I have to explain the term cis.) Trans people are just like cis people - some cis people are straight. Some cis people are gay. Some are bi, pansexual, and everything under the umbrella. The same goes for trans people.
We're not some weird sect of LGBT culture that is predestined to be one way or another. We're just people.
Quote from: Happy Girl on January 04, 2012, 09:06:18 PM
Are there FTM gays?
1. Are there ftm who love ONLY OTHER ftm's?
2. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio/cis straight men?
3. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio Gay Men?
As a straight mtf, when I embarked in my journey I always thought all mtf were like me but then I was amazed to know that lesbians mtf exist. Some who like only cis/bio women and others who like only mtf, tv etc...and some others love both.
So I wondered if in the ftm world, if it's the same cos I NEVER heard that so far and want to extend my knowledge about this.
yes to all of it since sexualety is fluent it comes in many diffrent shapes..
for myself I would consider myself bisexual mostly into guys..
I love ftms, I love bio gay mens, and straight bio men, but its kinda sad because no straight guy will date another guy unless he thinks you ass a girl or unless he actualy is bisexual or gay deep inside.
We were talking about a particular article on a trans man on my show last night (who identifies as gay and was formerly a "lipstick lesbian") and so the subject came up of FtM orientations. I made a point to emphasize that I didn't know of any reliable statistics but that I'd heard it seems like almost an even split, as in 1/3 str8, 1/3 gay, 1/3 bi. Of course, that's simplified because it leaves out concepts like pansexual, asexual, and others. In fact, I'm pretty sure I'd heard it on this board somewhere as this is where I get a lot of my information about trans-related issues.
Anyone else recall that being discussed here? It was probably in this section.
That's also why it seems silly to me when people argue to completely separate trans issues from LGB issues. One, there tends to be tremendous overlap, e.g. trans people who also identify as having some degree of non-traditional orientation. And two, I think the source of prejudice and oppression is largely the same, i.e. tyrannical culture around behavior, roles, and expression as it relates to gender and gender disparities.
I think thatlike with gender identity sexual orientation tends to get blurred and fall into gray areas much more easily within the trans community. I know for me at least it has and seems pretty true for the trans people ive met in person.
While the majority of my sexual partners have been cis males, I don't neccisarily consider myself to be gay. Ive also been with cis females, mtf's and genderqueers. Totally confused my roommates one night when I went out to the bar saying I was going to try to hook jp with a girl and ended up bringing home a gay guy. They all thought I was a lesbian.
I think once you start questioning your own identity and reach a point where you start doing something about it, how your partner identifies starts to matter less. I just like people. I guess that makes my polyp but I don't really like that word.
Quote from: dalebert on January 05, 2012, 06:37:57 PM
We were talking about a particular article on a trans man on my show last night (who identifies as gay and was formerly a "lipstick lesbian") and so the subject came up of FtM orientations. I made a point to emphasize that I didn't know of any reliable statistics but that I'd heard it seems like almost an even split, as in 1/3 str8, 1/3 gay, 1/3 bi. Of course, that's simplified because it leaves out concepts like pansexual, asexual, and others. In fact, I'm pretty sure I'd heard it on this board somewhere as this is where I get a lot of my information about trans-related issues.
Anyone else recall that being discussed here? It was probably in this section.
That's also why it seems silly to me when people argue to completely separate trans issues from LGB issues. One, there tends to be tremendous overlap, e.g. trans people who also identify as having some degree of non-traditional orientation. And two, I think the source of prejudice and oppression is largely the same, i.e. tyrannical culture around behavior, roles, and expression as it relates to gender and gender disparities.
The best stats on sexual orientation among trans folk I've seen is in this recent study in the States: http://www.thetaskforce.org/downloads/reports/reports/ntds_full.pdf (http://www.thetaskforce.org/downloads/reports/reports/ntds_full.pdf) .
Now it's not perfect, but it's the closest I've seen to an effort at a broader, statistically-relevant sample.
For trans guys (roughly 1800 respondents) the breakdown they give is as follows (page 29 in the report):
25% Heterosexual
13% Gay
13% Bisexual
46% Queer
2% Asexual
2% Other
Interestingly, the trans girls (roughly 3000 respondents) had a pretty different breakdown (page 29):
23% Heterosexual
29% Gay/Lesbian
31% Bisexual
7% Queer
7% Asexual
2% Other
I think the 1/3 1/3 1/3 split you are thinking of is more for trans girls. Trans guys tend to have a good majority in the queer/pan/bi range in not only this poll, but in most of the polls I've seen.
And ya, it always baffles me a bit when people try separate out the T. I mean I suppose I get it from the perspective of the straight guys and girls, but the majority of us are queer to some degree.
I dont belive there more or less gay/bi/queer transpeople than cisgenders..
I just belive transgender people tend to be more openminded about it because its harder to be trans than to have another sexualety.
if your can handle being out as trans then you can probebly also handle being out as gay/bi/queer whatever.. ::)
Quote from: Natkat on January 05, 2012, 08:50:48 PM
I dont belive there more or less gay/bi/queer transpeople than cisgenders..
I just belive transgender people tend to be more openminded about it because its harder to be trans than to have another sexualety.
if your can handle being out as trans then you can probebly also handle being out as gay/bi/queer whatever.. ::)
I think there is quite a lot of truth in that. There have been societies in human history which were a bit less uptight about sexuality and where bisexuality was the norm. However, I do have a feeling that our rates might also be somewhat above the standard due to our odd hormone mixtures. For example, we know that cis women who were exposed to extra T during fetal development have a higher than average rate of being lesbian. Which would explain some of the awesome level of queerishness among trans girls. ;D
Sarah -
They only surveyed 1,800 people.
I don't think this could possibly be an accurate representation.
Also, the explanation for queer being so high in the transguys category might have something to do with guys that are stealth feeling discomfort in answering this type of survey; queer people are usually also non-binary to some extent, so they are less likely to feel uncomfortable with being identified as trans. Even though they surveyed people in fifty states and a couple of other countries, there may have also been a concentration of respondents from queer friendly areas. Is there a part of this PDF where they cite the location of each respondent? Because that may be important in understanding why the survey turned out the way it did...
answer to the question....they exist..
Quote from: Happy Girl on January 04, 2012, 09:06:18 PM
Are there FTM gays?
1. Are there ftm who love ONLY OTHER ftm's?
2. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio/cis straight men?
3. Are there ftm who love ONLY bio Gay Men?
As a straight mtf, when I embarked in my journey I always thought all mtf were like me but then I was amazed to know that lesbians mtf exist. Some who like only cis/bio women and others who like only mtf, tv etc...and some others love both.
So I wondered if in the ftm world, if it's the same cos I NEVER heard that so far and want to extend my knowledge about this.
Yep! There are ftms with all sorts of preferences :).
I'm FTM.
I'm gay.
I exist...I think.
So, yes.
I have two MTF friends and both are lesbian.
Quote from: JasonRX on January 05, 2012, 09:43:53 PM
Sarah -
They only surveyed 1,800 people.
I don't think this could possibly be an accurate representation.
Also, the explanation for queer being so high in the transguys category might have something to do with guys that are stealth feeling discomfort in answering this type of survey; queer people are usually also non-binary to some extent, so they are less likely to feel uncomfortable with being identified as trans. Even though they surveyed people in fifty states and a couple of other countries, there may have also been a concentration of respondents from queer friendly areas. Is there a part of this PDF where they cite the location of each respondent? Because that may be important in understanding why the survey turned out the way it did...
Um... 1800 does make that the largest survey of trans guys like... ever - and that's a pretty decent size sample in general for that kind of survey. But, no it's not a perfect representation. It's just the closest we've seen to date. The explanation of their methodology begins on page 12 of the PDF.
Of the 4 I personally know in real life, 2 are gay, 2 are straight. All different facets do exist.
I identify strongly as a gay man myself and while I've tried my hardest through life to like girls, there's not that same magnetic pull I feel towards men.
So, I exist! :D