Hi, I'm Clara, sorry for the long post but if you don't want to read it then just respond by saying "hi" but any advice on my experience/situation is greatly appreciated :D
So to sum up, I have two questions - "Does being Trans mean that you've always identified as being a member of the opposite sex?" and "Do you think it's possible for someone who's cisgendered to convince themselves otherwise?"
FURTHER DETAILS
It feels like I'm only just beginning to find my feet, because I've spent most of my life trying to avoid figuring out who I really am. I still don't know whether I would label myself as "transgender" because for most of my life I assumed I was "cis", with some strange thoughts and fantasies, but now I'm not so sure.
For most of my pre-teen life, I felt as though I wasn't aware of my gender or that it was a factor in my life but I did notice I was different from other boys my age. My behaviour and interests were wide and varied but the points that stand out from a trans perspective: was that I often preferred the company of girls to boys, playing imaginary games like "house", playing with dolls (but only until I started school, though I had plenty of teddy bears), playing with make-up on rare occasion, and having interests in gymnastics, drama, cheerleading (at one point), jump ropes and hula hoops. I was always very quiet and reserved, often choosing to spend time reading books or playing video games, but I never really felt that I was uncomfortable being a boy. I did have a lot of trouble making sense of my own identity though (and still do), but drama was a great resolve for that, because it gave me an identity in whatever character I was playing. I thought of myself as male and imagined that I would grow up in that manner, though I do remember having an attraction to "transformation" stories. As in being physically turned into someone or something else, and in some cases a girl. I would imagine what it would feel like to be in a girl's body, though I didn't think of that as strange at the time. I was always surrounded by women, due to being the first born and having several aunts, my grandmother and a stay at home mother, and very little input from my dad or other males in my life, so I never knew any different.
I was bullied a lot and I had to attend several schools as a result. I became steadily more reserved and isolated, so I slipped into my own imagination, or more specifically Harry Potter books because I would never stop reading them. It was the start of my escapism, to use any form of entertainment or imagination to keep myself busy and often opted to spend time alone.
I started going through a rebellion stage when I was thirteen and I discovered punk-rock. I started wearing eyeliner, black clothes and spiking my hair into liberty spikes. I became disruptive and despondent for a while, whereas my interests were slightly obscure in that I was obsessed with the supernatural and paranormal. I believed in conspiracy theories, UFOs, ghosts, premonitions and psychic abilities, just about anything to make life more interesting. I also had an interest in hypnosis, because I was still drawn to the idea of "transformation," so I started listening to hypnosis recordings, some of which were based around "feminisation" because I was curious and intrigued of what it would be like to be a woman. Some recordings touched upon adult themes, but it was never really about that for me, I just really liked to escape from myself and the feelings of not having a sense of identity.
Slowly I noticed changes in my thoughts and perceptions, fuelled by the suggestions from the hypnosis tapes (or at least without the guilt of being consciously responsible for my thoughts). I realised that I wasn't attracted to women, but that I admired them in a different way. My thoughts would often switch from the idea of being with a woman, to actually being a woman. There were many times when my sexual fantasies would revolve around me being the woman I was attracted to (this was without hypnosis), and any fantasies were I remained male, would often be accompanied by a sense of guilt or shame. For several years my behaviour and fantasies grew stronger and more prominent, moving into the occasional moments of cross-dressing, complete with a wig and makeup and once again fantasising about being a woman.
I struggled a lot with depression during my teen years and would often put it down to external circumstances and anger at current situations, though I still felt a continuing loss of self identity. I felt guilty and ashamed of this "darker" side to my personality and would use this behaviour to offset some of the stress I faced daily. I suffered greatly from anxiety attacks, just from the idea of people "finding out", I lost my confidence and withdrew from people because I felt as though I shouldn't be behaving this way. My "fantasies" had progressed to thoughts about HRT and SRS, and the loss of my "male" identity.
Beyond those thoughts and in my everyday life, I often tried to maintain a "normal" life and would often try to overcome my poor self-esteem by masking my feelings and "pretending" to be goal-orientated and business minded. I had no social life and I threw myself into work, not wanting to spend anytime alone with my "thoughts". Though I would continually self-sabotage, (and still do), as a means to protect myself from people finding out.
I've been going in cycles for years, so I knew that I would have to address these issues at some point and since moving out to go to University, I noticed the pattern of self withdrawal had returned. I wanted to stop, but felt I couldn't so I begun to question why, because it feels as though I don't fit the cliche of being a "woman in a man's body," because I've seen myself as predominantly male all of my life, but now I'm not so sure. I've already reached out to counselling and a local transgender support group, who've helped me immensely. When I'm around them, they refer to me as "her" and "she", as well as using a female name that I decided upon a while back, but the strange thing is that it just feels right and I feel that I don't have to hide some big "secret". I don't know if I could identify as "transgender" as I still have doubts on whether I caused this or want to believe it in some way, because of my use of hypnosis and my interest in escapism and transformation. It's almost as though I can only see my life from this perspective, in hindsight, but I don't know whether I could say that I've always been "female". It's a comforting thought because it means that I don't have to live with the guilt of being "male" and having these thoughts - though I don't think that's a good enough reason to accept my trans identity.
I've since identified myself as Gender-queer because I don't feel as though I can accept my male identity any more, nor do I feel ready to embrace myself as female. I still find I have the desire to be/identify as a woman but I don't know if that's enough to justify being transgender - as in, having always known that I was "female".
So to sum up, I have two questions - "Does being Trans mean that you've always identified as being a member of the opposite sex?" and "Do you think it's possible for someone who's cisgendered to convince themselves otherwise?"
If you have any questions, advice or perspectives of your own, then please let me know and I'll respond as soon as I can.
Thanks for reading XD
Hi Clara, welcome to Susan's Place! I'm up near Boston. Your experiences are similar to many here. Thanks for letting us know a little about yourself. Grab some snacks and I'll see you around the site!
Hugs, Devlyn
Hiya Clara, welcome.
I myself have done a few of the things that you mentioned as well, somewhat quoting you on these, such as: having an attraction to "transformation" stories, as in being physically turned into someone or something else, and in some cases a girl, crossdressing, thoughts switched from the idea of being with a woman, to actually being a woman, I don't fit the cliche of being a "woman in a man's body," because I've seen myself as predominantly male all of my life.
I had many doubts, fears, worries when I started, still do have some, but just taking things slowly, one step at a time, helps.
To answer your first question, being trans is a very broad term, there is a pretty wide spectrum of possibilities. Personally, I don't think it means that you have had to identify as being a member of the opposite sex forever, I sure didn't at least. If you think that you are trans, you are trans, no one can tell you that you are or not but you. There also is no "trans enough". According to the definition used here, transgender is an inclusive umbrella term which covers anyone who transcends their birth gender for any reason. This includes but is not limited to Androgynes, Crossdressers, Drag kings, Drag queens, Intersexuals, Transsexuals, and Transvestites.
2nd question: I guess it could be possible to convince yourself that you may be trans if you are depressed or suffering from some kind of mental illness, I don't know tho, just a guess, or sort of like just wishing you were someone, anyone else else, if life sucks at the moment or something too. I don't think most cis people spend time thinking/wishing they were the opposite sex tho, brief thought here or there perhaps, but if it has been a persistent thought I think that is a one of a few pretty good indicator of trans status.
Hope this helps.
Hi Clara :icon_wave:
Welcome to Susan's :) Glad to have you here, join on in the fun
Here's some quick links to help you along
Please be sure to review
- Site Terms of Service and rules to live by (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,2.0.html)
- Standard Terms and Definitions (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,54369.0.html)
- Post Ranks ( including when you can upload an avatar) (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,114.0.html.)
- Reputation rules (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,18960.0.html)
- Photo, avatars, and signature images policy (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,59974.msg383866.html#msg383866)
Hugs
V M
Clara
Welcome to Susan's family.(https://www.susans.org/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sherv.net%2Fcm%2Femoticons%2Fbugs%2Fbutterfly-smiley-emoticon.gif&hash=55ebfb136b45eac8ba9632f37111f98067fc3aa6) (http://www.sherv.net/)
There are many here that can offer information to help.
So many topics to explore and posts to write.
Pull up a chair and give a look over the following links for site info...(https://www.susans.org/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sherv.net%2Fcm%2Femoticons%2Fobject%2Fchair-3-smiley-emoticon-emoji.png&hash=f6de189a088518c5de131e0c9ce29661e7a52a55) (http://www.sherv.net/)
- Site Terms of Service and rules to live by (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,2.0.html)
- Standard Terms and Definitions (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,54369.0.html)
- Post Ranks ( including when you can upload an avatar) (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,114.0.html.)
- Reputation rules (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,18960.0.html)
- Photo, avatars, and signature images policy (https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,59974.msg383866.html#msg383866)
Stay safe and healthy passage on your path, popcorn?
(https://www.susans.org/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Foi62.tinypic.com%2F33a6ouf.jpg&hash=70038a414397cf8547aa00ee9064953fc318e096)
Izzy
Forum News: new for our members under 18 a new safe place just for you. Youth talk.
Thank you for the welcome and feedback!
Sorry for taking a while to reply, I've been still trying to make sense of how I'm feeling atm, all I know is that these thoughts and feelings are not going to disappear overnight. I've been battling a lot with depression of late, so it's been difficult to find some sort of solace in figuring out my next move. Things in my life seem so stagnant and there isn't a moment that I don't think that I ought to transition, but I don't think I could face the reality of that decision right now. I still have my doubts, even though internally I identify as "female" I rarely express myself in that way because I feel uncomfortable with my "male" body expressing any form femininity. I don't necessarily like dressing in female clothing because all I see is a "man" whenever I look in the mirror, which gives me horrible dysphoria. I recently had help from a few friends who've helped me find a place that's somewhat gender-neutral. It seems to help a little for now but the trouble is I still feel as though this isn't enough at times.
Morally I'm struggling to make sense of my reasons for wanting to be seen as "female," because I feel as though I should be and have no reason to be unhappy for being perceived as being male. I feel as though my sense of self continually fluctuates to make things worse, sometimes I find a balance and feel temporarily okay with everything, but I always slip back to being resentful, withdrawn and self-indulged in these feelings of longing/desire to be female.
I stated above that I have an admiration of women and femininity in general, which gives me further pangs of guilt or dysphoria because I feel that femininity is in many ways a birth right, and that I'm being somewhat pathetic for squabbling over something I'll never truly have. I could come close to being perceived as a woman (with some effort), but it's something that I will never truly experience what it's like to be a woman. In some ways I feel that even trying to be female is a disservice to what cis-women and femininity mean to me :( because I feel that I not only don't deserve it, but that I could never really understand or grasp what it means to be considered a woman.
I also worry that no one is likely to see me as a woman but a "transsexual" if I were to transition because not only do I have my doubts of "passing" but also of people's ability to adapt their view point realistically and authentically for seeing me as the woman I feel I am. I almost feel as though I'd be on some level more self-conscious than I am already in trying to determine people's attitude towards me without feeling that they're judging me in some way.
So I've found myself in a bit of a dead space atm. I'm struggling to continue being perceived as a male in my everyday life and worry a lot about building relationships that feel fake or ineffectual, whilst simultaneously worrying what people's reaction would be if they knew how I really felt inside. Whilst being unable to make the commitment to transition because I can't be sure that I would get the result that I want, which is to all purpose "unrealistic" and truly "impossible" because there is no magic button that I can press to be 100% female, which really undermines my own sense of identity as feeling or claiming to be female :P
So right now I don't know what to do. I've made an appointment to speak to my GP and hopefully I'll be referred to a Gender Therapist because it feels that I've exhausted my own questions and methods to cope with my emotions. If anyone has had similar thoughts or advice, I would appreciate it :D
I'd also like to point out I do admire TG/TS people as well and just as equally, as they have had to overcome adversity and prejudice to claim their identity and continually subvert the birthright argument. It is unfair that society attaches labels and expectations to both genders that are suffocating, restrictive and alienating to those who don't fit the label attached to their perceived biological sex (which is why I use quotation marks in regards to these labels). For those who have the bravery or at least the will for whatever reason to shatter these expectations and live fulfilling and authentic lives are truly inspirational. I judge myself harshly on the expectations society places on me, which is often a source for my depression, so at some point I may overcome my own questionable self righteous martyrism.
I to feel that way, I feel so worn out mentally and physically. I have been going to a Doc for my PTSD, and there are days I want to scream out "I Want To Be A Girl!" but out of fear I sit back and when I get asked "You doing ok" I answer "Ya I'm ok." I put to much on myself, I do my best to please the world, my biggest fear is that I will fail my family and boyfriend for wanting to be a women, that I should just suck it up and be what I am now am, a man. And the longer I wait the worst it gets.....So Hi I'm Cervantes and its nice to meet you.