SO My hair is getting almost to my shoulder and still no filling in enough where I had male pattern balding. I know wigs are an option one I do not like. and surgery to relocate my hairline, and moving hair around. Has anyone had a great result with those, or with Rogaine or Propecia (Finesteride)?
Love and Hugs Marcie
I had a similar thread a while back. There were some ladies there with excellent results. Here's the link, but I'm sure they will pipe in also.
https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,228370.msg2025883.html#msg2025883
Bari Jo
It is my understanding that finesteride will slow down or actually stop male pattern hair loss. It has definitely helped mine. I don't believe that it alone will facilitate regrowth.
I started going thin on top in my very early 20's. It has been really hard on me. I'm now almost 37 years old, and am completely bald on the top. So finally last year, I decided to just start keeping my entire head completely shaved. Which of course does wonders for my dysphoria :'( but atleast it is better than having the old man look of totally bald on top and only hair around the sides. I have tried Rogaine in the past, with absolutely zero noticeable results. I think mine is just too far gone. It would take a LOT of RE-growth and most things only stop the loss, not help regrow. And I don't think I have enough hair to work with even if I were to go the route of surgeries. So I am currently in the market for a good wig that I actually like. So far all of the wigs I have tried, make me feel like I look really weird. But I think I just need to get used to it.
Quote from: Bari Jo on November 01, 2017, 09:26:11 AM
I had a similar thread a while back. There were some ladies there with excellent results. Here's the link, but I'm sure they will pipe in also.
https://www.susans.org/forums/index.php/topic,228370.msg2025883.html#msg2025883
Bari Jo
THANK YOU! I had also heard that there can be some initial shedding of hair that scares me? I did not see that yet in the other thread...do you know?
love and hugs, Marcie!
Initial shedding is very common with most hair treatments or surgeries.
I've mentioned what I've been doing in a few threads now (I think in the one Bari Jo linked in particular), but no harm going over it again.
I've seen solid results so far from minoxidill + finasteride + ketoconazole. I have only been on them a few months, but I have a lot of wispy hairs that are darkening everyday. I use the generic and cheapest versions of everything, such as buying the costco brand Minox off of Amazon for 20 bucks for 6 months. Finasteride I get Proscar and quarter it (a few bucks a month versus 100 bucks a month for Propecia, and its the same exact thing, Proscar is actually the original they spun off into propecia after recognizing the hair effects). Ketoconazole shampoos have been clinically shown to help with stopping dht bonding to follicles, though in theory if you are on HRT this is not needed. However, it also helps to sooth the scalp from the irritation/dryness that repeated minox use can cause. (And it's cheap, so you know, why not? ;D The non prescription 1% brand is Nizoral, but there is a 2% prescription solution too that is supposed to be more effective.)
My results: I began with seemingly barren crown (MPB) and thin hair on top due to genetics (not MPB) as well as severe damage from scalp psoriasis, all hair lost or damaged mostly within the 2-7 year window that is often cited as the upper limit on "reviving" follicles. My front hair line was fine, so can't speak to effect on it. 2 Months of minox led to a ton of near invisible wispy growth, particularly on the crown and on top. Seeing this, I ran out and got the other two. Now, about two months later my hair is notably thicker on top with a lot of stray hairs on crown and even more of the translucent hairs (just touching my head it doesn't feel bald at all, you just can't really see it). Nowhere near full coverage by any means, and doubt it ever will be, but still a major improvement in just 2 months while you aren't even really supposed to be seeing effects for at least 4-6, and not full effects for a year to two. I add the caveat that much of this hair may been the follicles that were impacted by psoriasis and not actually regrowing of hair lost to MPB, which would explain the uncommon speed of some of the results.
My goal is not full coverage, that's a pipe dream unless hair loss is extremely minor when starting, but to make transplants more feasible/effective (and cheaper).
I have used both finasteride and Rogaine (actually generic 2% Minoxidil) for years. They did stop my hair loss thankfully but I don't really think I have had much regrowth of lost hair. Luckily I started with mostly full hair, just thinned on top a bit. After a few months of Rogaine you can reduce to only 3 or 4 times a week (my doctor told me this), not twice a day as recommended on the label. I can't use the 5% because of itching and irritation, so I get the women's version (Walgreens) which is always 2% (same price, same ingredients).
does finesteride require a prescription?
Quote from: Roll on November 01, 2017, 10:46:11 AM
Initial shedding is very common with most hair treatments or surgeries.
I've mentioned what I've been doing in a few threads now (I think in the one Bari Jo linked in particular), but no harm going over it again.
I've seen solid results so far from minoxidill + finasteride + ketoconazole. I have only been on them a few months, but I have a lot of wispy hairs that are darkening everyday. I use the generic and cheapest versions of everything, such as buying the costco brand Minox off of Amazon for 20 bucks for 6 months. Finasteride I get Proscar and quarter it (a few bucks a month versus 100 bucks a month for Propecia, and its the same exact thing, Proscar is actually the original they spun off into propecia after recognizing the hair effects). Ketoconazole shampoos have been clinically shown to help with stopping dht bonding to follicles, though in theory if you are on HRT this is not needed. However, it also helps to sooth the scalp from the irritation/dryness that repeated minox use can cause. (And it's cheap, so you know, why not? ;D The non prescription 1% brand is Nizoral, but there is a 2% prescription solution too that is supposed to be more effective.)
My results: I began with seemingly barren crown (MPB) and thin hair on top due to genetics (not MPB) as well as severe damage from scalp psoriasis, all hair lost or damaged mostly within the 2-7 year window that is often cited as the upper limit on "reviving" follicles. My front hair line was fine, so can't speak to effect on it. 2 Months of minox led to a ton of near invisible wispy growth, particularly on the crown and on top. Seeing this, I ran out and got the other two. Now, about two months later my hair is notably thicker on top with a lot of stray hairs on crown and even more of the translucent hairs (just touching my head it doesn't feel bald at all, you just can't really see it). Nowhere near full coverage by any means, and doubt it ever will be, but still a major improvement in just 2 months while you aren't even really supposed to be seeing effects for at least 4-6, and not full effects for a year to two. I add the caveat that much of this hair may been the follicles that were impacted by psoriasis and not actually regrowing of hair lost to MPB, which would explain the uncommon speed of some of the results.
My goal is not full coverage, that's a pipe dream unless hair loss is extremely minor when starting, but to make transplants more feasible/effective (and cheaper).
Thank You SO MUCH for sharing. I am thin on top to just over the top - heading toward MPB but I have wispy hair and some left all over. As I have been growing it long and on HRT - only 6weeks -I have been seeing more hair. The propecia I am taking is I am sure the lowest dose so I do not know if that can or will be increased. I have not added Rogaine - is that really an addition?
I also so far have not had noticeable shedding although only on this for short while! How inevitable is shedding?
Thanks Love and Hugs Marcie
washing your scalp with a strong brew of coffee or green tea or both will reverse hair loss....the folks at rogaine don't want you to know about that lol.
also a plum blossom hammer, an acupuncture tool works miracles, but it's not for the faint of heart
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on November 17, 2017, 08:09:54 AM
Thank You SO MUCH for sharing. I am thin on top to just over the top - heading toward MPB but I have wispy hair and some left all over. As I have been growing it long and on HRT - only 6weeks -I have been seeing more hair. The propecia I am taking is I am sure the lowest dose so I do not know if that can or will be increased. I have not added Rogaine - is that really an addition?
I also so far have not had noticeable shedding although only on this for short while! How inevitable is shedding?
Thanks Love and Hugs Marcie
Rogaine/minox works in a different manner than Propecia/finast, so for maximum effect I'd say it's definitely worth adding if you don't mind the cost (which isn't bad at all for the cheap watery stuff, but the foam is about double the cost and may be required to actually get down into your scalp with longer hair at all). It's very hard to judge the effects without it acting in a void however, so you may not be able to see any change.
There is only one dosage of Propecia specifically(though Proscar, meant for swollen prostates, is five times the same exact medicine), but I don't know if that is because of the side effects or it just doesn't do anything past a certain point. We are in a unique position to not care, or even welcome, the side effects though. ;D
With the meds you probably have seen the shedding you are going to have. That is more of an issue with the surgeries or anything that causes a major shock to the system (I saw reference to it regarding platelet rich plasma treatments for instance). I think it may also depend on exactly what is "wrong" with your hair, as if the actual hair is damaged it will probably shed where as if you just are creating growth in a bald patch obviously there is nothing to shed to begin with.
Ive had a receding hairline for a few years now. Its pretty noticeable when i pull my hair back [emoji17] what would be helpful to regrow the hair there?
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Quote from: dist123 on November 17, 2017, 08:50:07 AM
Ive had a receding hairline for a few years now. Its pretty noticeable when i pull my hair back [emoji17] what would be helpful to regrow the hair there?
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
same as above. apply strong green tea or strong coffee topically to the effected area, and get a plum blossom hammer and use it
Quote from: extraaction on November 17, 2017, 08:51:54 AM
same as above. apply strong green tea or strong coffee topically to the effected area, and get a plum blossom hammer and use it
How? Does it have to be brewed?
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Quote from: dist123 on November 17, 2017, 10:54:21 AM
How? Does it have to be brewed?
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
yes ma'am
paying a small fortune to have every hair below my eyebrows removed at the root... one electrode at a time. would give pay a fortune more to have a few hairs added to the top of my head.
This is the ultimate irony - paying huge sums of money to move around hairs on the top of my head and zap hairs on my face. I have a second hair transplant (unshaven FUT) in a few weeks to give a more rounded and female hairline and then a few weeks after that, a bulk 16 hour electrolysis session (split over 2 days). Hopefully I won't need all those hours to get a full clearance. Endgame for electrolysis should be in sight.
All in all, a very expensive process.
aren't Finasteride and Propecia both androgen blockers? Like Spironolactone? If you're on an HRT regime (spiro) what good would it be in taking additional androgen blockers? Spiro already blocks the production of DHT.
Quote from: Becca Kay on November 19, 2017, 11:01:02 AM
aren't Finasteride and Propecia both androgen blockers? Like Spironolactone? If you're on an HRT regime (spiro) what good would it be in taking additional androgen blockers? Spiro already blocks the production of DHT.
Propecia is finasteride just to be clear on that.
I asked about this during my HRT consult and I've seen it come up a few times here and there, but for whatever reason Spiro doesn't seem to cause regrowth whereas finast and dutasteride do, or at least hasn't been shown to clinically maybe. Their mechanism seems to be different, which makes sense since they are different chemicals I guess. I was told to stay on the finasteride for now, but that once it has reached maximum effect (1-2 years) and dht is suppressed, it won't be necessary.
It's a sad fact that one those little follicles have been starved of their blood supply by DHT for too long, there dead for good. Finasteride will slowly cleanse the follicles and will improve the blood supply, but if you're too late, they're not gonna grow back. Too often I hear finasteride talked about as a miracle drug, alas it's not, it will not regrow hair, just promote growth of dying (but still viable) follicles.
Quote from: MrsMac on December 05, 2017, 05:23:11 PM
It's a sad fact that one those little follicles have been starved of their blood supply by DHT for too long, there dead for good. Finasteride will slowly cleanse the follicles and will improve the blood supply, but if you're too late, they're not gonna grow back. Too often I hear finasteride talked about as a miracle drug, alas it's not, it will not regrow hair, just promote growth of dying (but still viable) follicles.
The window is supposedly 2-7 years for a follicle, but it's one of those you can't know until you try things.
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on November 01, 2017, 07:55:21 AM
SO My hair is getting almost to my shoulder and still no filling in enough where I had male pattern balding. I know wigs are an option one I do not like. and surgery to relocate my hairline, and moving hair around. Has anyone had a great result with those, or with Rogaine or Propecia (Finesteride)?
Love and Hugs Marcie
It is my understanding that Rogaine ( minoxidal) only works on balding on the crown of the head and doesn't work on hairline hair follicles. I believe finasteride works for all head hair but mainly prevents hair loss, not hair regrowth from what has already been lost. I had a slight receded hairline before hrt and after 17 months I have some fuzzy baby hairs coming in. No real regrowth, but no more hair loss either.
This is embarrassing for me to post but at 3 months hrt I noticed my receding hair line has been filling in a bit. It's no where near a female hairline yet or where I want it to be but there's hope!
I can't say for everyone but hang in there and give it a try. There's nothing to lose! If it worked for me it could work for you too(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20171231/e8becbb6624800f3f19b44990cbf706a.jpg)
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
I wanted to add to this thread: Remember that every tiny bit of hair growth matters a lot, and there is no reason not to use all medicines out there even if you don't think it will give you full coverage. There is a threshold for transplant success in amount of balding and available transplant hair, and not being over that threshold is all that matters. (And every single hair you don't have to fill in with a transplant is literally money off the final bill as well.)
(Particularly since it's not like anyone on HRT should care about the side effects of Finasteride that often drives cis-guys away from it. ;D )
Quote from: Roll on December 31, 2017, 09:23:16 AM
(Particularly since it's not like anyone on HRT should care about the side effects of Finasteride that often drives cis-guys away from it. ;D )
Respectfully, I disagree. The loss of libido for some transwomen should definitely be a concern. There are some who are married or in committed sexual relationships that can/will suffer from low libido.
Very, very small dosages of Finasteride are said to be effective for combating hair loss while not exhibiting the undesirable sexual side effects.
Quote from: LexiDreamer on January 02, 2018, 08:42:33 AM
Respectfully, I disagree. The loss of libido for some transwomen should definitely be a concern. There are some who are married or in committed sexual relationships that can/will suffer from low libido.
Very, very small dosages of Finasteride are said to be effective for combating hair loss while not exhibiting the undesirable sexual side effects.
Oh, certainly I wasn't saying in general that libido was not a concern. This was assuming the Propecia level dosage since the thread was about hair loss. The full proscar dosage is a different matter entirely. But anyone on HRT is already by default way, way beyond what the Propecia level dosages can possibly ever do is what I meant.
Quote from: Roll on January 02, 2018, 10:45:14 AM
Oh, certainly I wasn't saying in general that libido was not a concern. This was assuming the Propecia level dosage since the thread was about hair loss. The full proscar dosage is a different matter entirely. But anyone on HRT is already by default way, way beyond what the Propecia level dosages can possibly ever do is what I meant.
My apologies.
I thought your were talking about the side effects that steer cis-males away from finasteride, as loss of libido and function are two of the biggest.
I'm interested to try this coffee thing out. I'm a little thin in the front on top, and a little in the back on top and it bums me out. I'm hoping that HRT will stop the thinning at least, but I'm also hoping for maybe a little regrowth. We shall see, but trying coffee can't hurt. :D
-Rain
I did not start losing hair on the top of my head until I turned 40. (I am 50 now). I have been taking Estradol and Spiro for 3 months now. I was not expecting my hair growth on my head to improve, but the volume of hair where it had been very thin has now doubled. I had been looking into hair transplants, but now I will wait a few more months to see if the hair continues to fill in. I want to say while 80% of the hormones effects I experienced seem similar to those I have read about with other girls my progress has been different and I am sure because it is helping me grow hair that is not a guarantee that it will help anyone else.