hi all!
My ups and downs are driving me crazy, and I wonder if it hormonal, psychological, or both! I and my wife have two daughters one through her teen years, one in the throws of them. I thought maybe I would be like them, moody demanding, and irritable and to some extent I am, but it is also, I think, very different. I feel like I should be in control of how all this moves forward, after all I decided to do this! But I think control is the last thing I have in the actual progress I make.
I wonder if anyone else sees transitioning as under their control to some extent?
It dawned on me that it feels like when I don't progress fast enough its as if I think I should be able to do something to move forward, not like a teenager, but more a medical decision. But it is a natural response to the hormones so it is more like being a teenager, albeit one driven by taking hormones and levels determined by a doctor.
Reality is though it is a natural transition once we start HRT - a lot of what happens is out of our control. The loss of real control, but thinking we are making decisions is confusing me!! That even confuses me!!
I think I am rambling...just want to feel less alone! lol.
Love and Hugs to you all! Marcie :)
Oh trust me I know what you're going through... Estrogen is one heck of a hormone. But I guess so is testosterone.. I think I have a lot going on though so things are out of whack for sure
Sent from my VS501 using Tapatalk
Marcie,
We all feel unusual at first, but as soon as we become accustom to the changes, the roller coaster seems to level out.
For myself, my main experience with Estradiol is that I felt so at peace with the world. Nobody or nothing seemed to bother me. I just accepted what ever came my way without complaint. I really enjoyed my roller coaster ride. I never felt so good my entire life previous to Estradiol.
Since we are all different, we may experience different results, but what you describe is what many other trans women describe with their first experiences with Estradiol. Just be cool and take it as it comes. 8)
Quote from: Dani on April 06, 2018, 05:22:41 AM
Marcie,
We all feel unusual at first, but as soon as we become accustom to the changes, the roller coaster seems to level out.
For myself, my main experience with Estradiol is that I felt so at peace with the world. Nobody or nothing seemed to bother me. I just accepted what ever came my way without complaint. I really enjoyed my roller coaster ride. I never felt so good my entire life previous to Estradiol.
Since we are all different, we may experience different results, but what you describe is what many other trans women describe with their first experiences with Estradiol. Just be cool and take it as it comes. 8)
Thanks Dani!
I too definitely feel euphoria and a calmness, and if all else were equal maybe the roller coaster ride as you describe it would not have so many highs and lows. I love being on Estradiol, it is as if I should always have been on it! I just have so much going on, and then add in the downs and I hit bottom frequently. I think if I get some of the tough things resolved and am out completely then a lot of this may be just that an enjoyable roller coaster ride! I hope so anyway!
Love and Hugs, Marcie
Quote from: Allison S on April 05, 2018, 12:49:27 PM
Oh trust me I know what you're going through... Estrogen is one heck of a hormone. But I guess so is testosterone.. I think I have a lot going on though so things are out of whack for sure
Sent from my VS501 using Tapatalk
Thanks Allison for the support and reply. It is hard doing this - even your besties who are trans have their own lives and struggles so often I feel alone in this. I hope that will change over time and once I can be out to my entire family and the world! Have a beautiful day!
Love and Hugs, Marcie
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on April 06, 2018, 06:25:25 AM
even your besties who are trans have their own lives and struggles so often I feel alone in this
I absolutely agree with this. It's a very lonely and personal process, even if you know people who are on HRT as well, it's very different for each one and everyone does things their own way, have their own lives to live so no experience will be exactly like yours and it can feel lonely. I've certainly felt that along the way.
The good news is that I think it makes us stronger, and also it means there's no right or wrong way to do this, we can get some guidance by professionals but at the end we must follow our inner voice.
Enviado de meu Moto G (5) Plus usando Tapatalk
Quote from: Charlie Nicki on April 06, 2018, 06:55:04 AM
I absolutely agree with this. It's a very lonely and personal process, even if you know people who are on HRT as well, it's very different for each one and everyone does things their own way, have their own lives to live so no experience will be exactly like yours and it can feel lonely. I've certainly felt that along the way.
The good news is that I think it makes us stronger, and also it means there's no right or wrong way to do this, we can get some guidance by professionals but at the end we must follow our inner voice.
Enviado de meu Moto G (5) Plus usando Tapatalk
Charlie Nicki - YES! unfortunately my inner voice often is filled with fear as of now, I think if other people in my family in particular could just let me be out and let them know what is going on that would fade away a lot. Right now hiding is so painful!
I'd say it's you, but that's just me. To my mind there is no way an adult can be a teenager, with all that lack of basic experience, socialization (positive or negative, in any way), never paid a bill, great hope, huge disappointments, everything so intense.
I just don't buy into a healthily adjusted adult feeling that way like an adolescent does. Yes, hormones are everywhere, but with the serious benefit of adult socialization. The amout of non trans adults who say 'I wish I could go back there with my brain/life experience now' is striking. To do it all again with an adult brain and the wisdom of adult perception, well that'd be bloody brilliant really, wouldn't it?
They can't do it. We can (to an extent), as long as we don't kid ourselves we are actually teenagers. Because we aren't on any level. Nobody really has that luxury, trans or not. It would an absolute luxury, a fantasy of a dream adolescence that nobody ever gets to live.
That is not the generation we come from, we have no idea what it is like, and they have no idea what it was to be a teen however many decades ago. Even superficially, the hopes, the fears, the mores, the music, the television, the aspirations, even the fashions that defined male v female. Very few of them fit or even merge for any generation or the sub groups within each.
Look at the early 80's with everything from later punks to New Romantics and Sloane Rangers. How would you explain that to a teen now? It was barely understandable to those of us who were teens in the 90's and only then because it wasn't as far back as hippies or mods & rockers, and we knew people who were identifiably still in each group.
To say you're a teen equivalent now is self indulgent flattery as far as I can see. And it's not even that flattering because realiy, who would want to be one aside from the fantasy of doing it all perfectly? As I say, everyone has that glorious hindsight, trans or not.
Quote from: alex82 on April 06, 2018, 05:12:25 PM
I'd say it's you, but that's just me. To my mind there is no way an adult can be a teenager, with all that lack of basic experience, socialization (positive or negative, in any way), never paid a bill, great hope, huge disappointments, everything so intense.
I just don't buy into a healthily adjusted adult feeling that way like an adolescent does. Yes, hormones are everywhere, but with the serious benefit of adult socialization. The amout of non trans adults who say 'I wish I could go back there with my brain/life experience now' is striking. To do it all again with an adult brain and the wisdom of adult perception, well that'd be bloody brilliant really, wouldn't it?
They can't do it. We can (to an extent), as long as we don't kid ourselves we are actually teenagers. Because we aren't on any level. Nobody really has that luxury, trans or not. It would an absolute luxury, a fantasy of a dream adolescence that nobody ever gets to live.
That is not the generation we come from, we have no idea what it is like, and they have no idea what it was to be a teen however many decades ago. Even superficially, the hopes, the fears, the mores, the music, the television, the aspirations, even the fashions that defined male v female. Very few of them fit or even merge for any generation or the sub groups within each.
Look at the early 80's with everything from later punks to New Romantics and Sloane Rangers. How would you explain that to a teen now? It was barely understandable to those of us who were teens in the 90's and only then because it wasn't as far back as hippies or mods & rockers, and we knew people who were identifiably still in each group.
To say you're a teen equivalent now is self indulgent flattery as far as I can see. And it's not even that flattering because realiy, who would want to be one aside from the fantasy of doing it all perfectly? As I say, everyone has that glorious hindsight, trans or not.
I think it was meant more in terms of emotional instability. I think hrt does do that. I think regardless of age, changing from one gender to another is a very intense ride. If you focus on actual age, yeah teenagers are more vulnerable since they rely on parents/family/others. But that's not always the case and also it makes things easier than being an "adult". Like a lot easier.
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Quote from: alex82 on April 06, 2018, 05:12:25 PM
I'd say it's you, but that's just me. To my mind there is no way an adult can be a teenager, with all that lack of basic experience, socialization (positive or negative, in any way), never paid a bill, great hope, huge disappointments, everything so intense.
I just don't buy into a healthily adjusted adult feeling that way like an adolescent does. Yes, hormones are everywhere, but with the serious benefit of adult socialization. The amout of non trans adults who say 'I wish I could go back there with my brain/life experience now' is striking. To do it all again with an adult brain and the wisdom of adult perception, well that'd be bloody brilliant really, wouldn't it?
They can't do it. We can (to an extent), as long as we don't kid ourselves we are actually teenagers. Because we aren't on any level. Nobody really has that luxury, trans or not. It would an absolute luxury, a fantasy of a dream adolescence that nobody ever gets to live.
That is not the generation we come from, we have no idea what it is like, and they have no idea what it was to be a teen however many decades ago. Even superficially, the hopes, the fears, the mores, the music, the television, the aspirations, even the fashions that defined male v female. Very few of them fit or even merge for any generation or the sub groups within each.
Look at the early 80's with everything from later punks to New Romantics and Sloane Rangers. How would you explain that to a teen now? It was barely understandable to those of us who were teens in the 90's and only then because it wasn't as far back as hippies or mods & rockers, and we knew people who were identifiably still in each group.
To say you're a teen equivalent now is self indulgent flattery as far as I can see. And it's not even that flattering because realiy, who would want to be one aside from the fantasy of doing it all perfectly? As I say, everyone has that glorious hindsight, trans or not.
WOW...okay then...thanks
Quote from: Allison S on April 06, 2018, 05:43:51 PM
I think it was meant more in terms of emotional instability. I think hrt does do that. I think regardless of age, changing from one gender to another is a very intense ride. If you focus on actual age, yeah teenagers are more vulnerable since they rely on parents/family/others. But that's not always the case and also it makes things easier than being an "adult". Like a lot easier.
Sent from my SM-G930T using Tapatalk
Thanks Allison, definitely the sense...reading between the lines is a lost art to some...
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on April 06, 2018, 09:35:56 PM
WOW...okay then...thanks
You're welcome. I took it to be a genuine question, so I answered in that spirit.
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on April 05, 2018, 12:17:01 PM
hi all!
My ups and downs are driving me crazy, and I wonder if it hormonal, psychological, or both! I and my wife have two daughters one through her teen years, one in the throws of them. I thought maybe I would be like them, moody demanding, and irritable and to some extent I am, but it is also, I think, very different. I feel like I should be in control of how all this moves forward, after all I decided to do this! But I think control is the last thing I have in the actual progress I make.
I wonder if anyone else sees transitioning as under their control to some extent?
It dawned on me that it feels like when I don't progress fast enough its as if I think I should be able to do something to move forward, not like a teenager, but more a medical decision. But it is a natural response to the hormones so it is more like being a teenager, albeit one driven by taking hormones and levels determined by a doctor.
Reality is though it is a natural transition once we start HRT - a lot of what happens is out of our control. The loss of real control, but thinking we are making decisions is confusing me!! That even confuses me!!
I think I am rambling...just want to feel less alone! lol.
Love and Hugs to you all! Marcie :)
Interesting thoughts and comments, and ones I can almost mirror, especially over the past week.
If you mean mood changes, then no I personally have not experienced any. I have always been moody though, so I probably would not notice any change.
For me, mood changes and emotional ups and downs have not been a factor. I have lots of stresses in my life right now, and being on HRT only adds to that stress level. So maybe i don't "feel" the emotional effects because my life is full enough of other things.
Physical effects yes - loss of body order, skin less oily, painful breast and breast buds.
Losing control - I have intended/hoped to control my transition with the idea that I could slow down, or back out at any time. I looked in the mirror this morning and with the even tiny increases in breast size, realized that this is the body I have always imagined is me. I feel like lost control when I realized that. Yikes! I have controlled this beast my entire life.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I was borderline suicidal for the first couple months. I could go from hating life to loving it in just a few seconds and it was like this all day. After a couple months it got much better though
Well, I haven't had suicidal thoughts and never will. Survival mindset is too ingrained. Doesn't make things any easier though - get the feeling that something is going to happen which is very strong at times.
In the past, this feeling has prepared me to act or respond in response to something happening but there's nothing that even suggests that's what is happening so it's just an issue of fighting it and getting over it, hopefully.
Quote from: Cassi on April 07, 2018, 08:24:23 PM
Interesting thoughts and comments, and ones I can almost mirror, especially over the past week.
I am sorry for that - hang in there Cassi - as they say misery loves company
Quote from: kanad3 on April 08, 2018, 06:06:58 AM
I was borderline suicidal for the first couple months. I could go from hating life to loving it in just a few seconds and it was like this all day. After a couple months it got much better though
Wow - well I am almost there still at the 5 month mark, I am glad it passed for you and you made it through! Love and Highs, Marcie
Quote from: TicTac on April 08, 2018, 03:01:56 AM
If you mean mood changes, then no I personally have not experienced any. I have always been moody though, so I probably would not notice any change.
Yes, but not just mood changes - the physical feelings of transitioning also seem to ebb and flow causing ups and downs!
Quote from: anne_indy on April 08, 2018, 03:39:34 AM
For me, mood changes and emotional ups and downs have not been a factor. I have lots of stresses in my life right now, and being on HRT only adds to that stress level. So maybe i don't "feel" the emotional effects because my life is full enough of other things.
Physical effects yes - loss of body order, skin less oily, painful breast and breast buds.
Losing control - I have intended/hoped to control my transition with the idea that I could slow down, or back out at any time. I looked in the mirror this morning and with the even tiny increases in breast size, realized that this is the body I have always imagined is me. I feel like lost control when I realized that. Yikes! I have controlled this beast my entire life.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Anne - the reaction to the physical changes you are having is what convinced me it was the only thing for me too! I am having mood and physical changes so I guess if they get in sync it will either be netter or worse! :)
Love and Hugs Marcie
Quote from: alex82 on April 07, 2018, 08:04:42 PM
You're welcome. I took it to be a genuine question, so I answered in that spirit.
It is a genuine - real question, but the spirit you answered it in was lets say a bit judgemental as opposed to lets say just truthful and helpful. But that is okay it takes all kinds of people with all kinds of personalities to make up the diverse word.l. we are in...
have a blessed day.
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on April 08, 2018, 11:43:05 PM
It is a genuine - real question, but the spirit you answered it in was lets say a bit judgemental as opposed to lets say just truthful and helpful. But that is okay it takes all kinds of people with all kinds of personalities to make up the diverse word.l. we are in...
have a blessed day.
The phrasing of your question gave two options. Possibly three if a blend of the two options is considered as being separate. You asked it, and the question mark invited answers. You have sadly chosen to take my initial response as spiritually hostile (despite it actually being pretty reflective if you read it properly) and that is your choice which you had full agency over.
Ironically, it's only me who's been judged here and dealt with in a way that demonstrates zero generosity - what with your capital wows and takes all kinds comments, followed by blessings. I on the other hand (aside from the first sentence where I directly answered the question posed, and, more fool me, in good faith at that) was not personal but went on to speak generally.
There was nothing particularly judgmental in it. I gave an honest reply and drew on and critiqued more than trans experiences in what makes up the world of a teenager and how they interact and cope with life and with change, and why. There was nothing I said that could be countered by anyone conversant with the development of children and young adults, in practice or theory.
In fact I spoke to several colleagues today about your question, which I think shows a level of engagement far beyond what you wrongly took to be dismissal because it wasn't wholehearted agreement. None are trans, yet all were in agreement that if they could relive significant decisions made in youth, they would. As I said, it's not an uncommon dream. It's just not real.
I think my answer was fairly comprehensive in explaining my own position, and placing it into its proper context societally and in terms of emotional and psychological development. It fits into the wider backdrop and countered, with personal thought (without labouring the point), some critiques of trans people and our maturity. It was not impolite, and nor was it passive aggressive.
However, I also misread your initial post and for that I apologize. You say in it that you thought it might be like being a teenager but it isn't. I must've read that and then not referred back to it in my reply because I knew you'd said it to the extent I was agreeing with you. It is different, and all I said in my reply was why that might be. I hope you find peace and happiness in your life.
This is a support site. Some threads are not good fits for some people. Why not just move on if there is a conflict forming. It ain't worth the stress.
Moni
Quote from: anne_indy on April 08, 2018, 03:39:34 AM
Physical effects yes - loss of body order, skin less oily, painful breast and breast buds.
Losing control - I have intended/hoped to control my transition with the idea that I could slow down, or back out at any time. I looked in the mirror this morning and with the even tiny increases in breast size, realized that this is the body I have always imagined is me. I feel like lost control when I realized that. Yikes! I have controlled this beast my entire life.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Quote from: Marcieelizabeth on April 08, 2018, 11:39:08 PM
Anne - the reaction to the physical changes you are having is what convinced me it was the only thing for me too! I am having mood and physical changes so I guess if they get in sync it will either be netter or worse! :)
Love and Hugs Marcie
Hello again Anne & Marcie
I have noticed some mood changes from being low to being high/happy and laughing at virtually nothing a few hours later.
However I must add that I feel precisely the same as you on the physical side. The breast buds, the small breasts, the softer skin confirm to me that I am doing the right thing - to finally achieve the female body I have always sought.
Hugs & Kisses
Pamela
Quote from: pamelatransuk on April 10, 2018, 05:07:02 AM
Hello again Anne & Marcie
I have noticed some mood changes from being low to being high/happy and laughing at virtually nothing a few hours later.
However I must add that I feel precisely the same as you on the physical side. The breast buds, the small breasts, the softer skin confirm to me that I am doing the right thing - to finally achieve the female body I have always sought.
Hugs & Kisses
Pamela
The laughing parts are cool but the downer parts aren't. Changes definitely happening fo sure.