We've all heard the old question.....

[Devlyn]

Ginger or Mary Ann? I won't limit your choices. Which castaway(s) would you want to stay shipwrecked with? I would have been showing Mr Howell some leg! Hugs, Devlyn

[cindianna_jones]

When I was younger, I would have picked Ginger. She was so glamarous. Now.... I'd go with Marry Ann. She was bubbly, fun, and down right cute. I suppose it boils down to who would make the better friend.

[hiddenflame]

Cindi you said basically what I would.  Mary Ann was so much closer to living in the real world almost like a girl next door type.

[Jamie D]

Being the non-conformist I am, I'm going to throw you a curve.

I vote for "Bunny."

[Beth Andrea]

Mary Ann.

I've never really cared for the "Marilyn Monroe" dolls. Real girls are HOT.

[Stephe]

Ginger or Mary Ann? I won't limit your choices. Which castaway(s) would you want to stay shipwrecked with? I would have been showing Mr Howell some leg! Hugs, Devlyn

Gilligan? 😛

[justmeinoz]

Can I share a hut with Mary-Ann and Ginger? 

Gilligan Stephe?  Do you have an ear fetish?? 

[Stephe]

Gilligan Stephe?  Do you have an ear fetish?? 

Well lets see, I got to choose between the fat skipper, the old man and the obnoxious professor... Compared to them Gilligan looks pretty good 😛 True tho the professor could make a blender out of a coconut..

Sorry, just not into women much these days...

[Michelle G]

Even though I am an avid fan of hot redheads I still would pick Maryanne! Until recently when I realized that Dawn Wells is the exact same age as my mother  😮

[Cindy]

The professor, I always thought he was a hottie.

[Rubberneck]

Mary Ann of course.

[Tammy Hope]

my answer never reflected who I wanted, but who i wanted to BE - and that was, slam dunk, Mary Ann

there's was none of the guys i would have been interested in but i'd have definitely cuddled up to the Professor given the options.

[V M]

Another vote for the professor  🙂

[Jamie D]

The professor, I always thought he was a hottie.

Well, if the issue is survival, yeah, the Professor is a great choice.  I mean, who else could make a radio out of coconuts?

[kelly_aus]

Well, if the issue is survival, yeah, the Professor is a great choice.  I mean, who else could make a radio out of coconuts?

Was there anything he couldn't make out of coconuts?

[justmeinoz]

Thinking about it I'd have gone straight for the Professor too!  Intelligence is Hot!  Besides he could make a bra out of a coconut as well.

[Amazon D]

Even though i never dated men i don't think of gilligan as a man  or male.. gilligan always seemed to break the gender boundarys and so gilligan would be my pick because he seems non sexual / asexual which is what i am..

[Jamie D]

Who was "Bunny," you ask?

"Bunny" was the "pre-Mary Ann" in the seldom seen pilot for the show.

See THIS 🔗 [Link: gilligansisle.com/pilot.html/] website for more historical information about the original pilot.


Bunny was one of two secretaries (along with Ginger).  The Professor was just a high school teacher.
It was a six-hour tour.
And the theme song was a Latin tune.