Hi Violet,
I am one year post-op. I use a set of soulsource dilators, and the second largest is green. It is 1 3/8 inches in diameter. I can get it in about four inches on the rare occasions I use it. With the smaller ones (purple and blue) I can only get about 4 1/2 inches of depth, no matter how hard I push. There is just no more room, and my surgeon told me as much. The green one doesn't really hurt excessively, but I never really saw the point of gaining width when I have no depth.
I guess all I am trying to say is I understand your disappointment. Like you, this isn't what I was hoping for. It isn't what I wanted, but there it is, take it or leave it.
I've actually decided to see if there is any surgical revision that can be done. That extra inch or so is something I really want. Rationally, I can't tell you why it makes so much difference, but I am fairly fixated on my lack of depth. I have a feeling once I talk to a couple more surgeons and they tell me I'm wasting my money, I'll probably start focusing on what I do have instead of what I don't have, but right now I'm seemingly determined to find fault with aspects of my transition that by most measures has been just short of miraculous.
There are a lot of trans girls out there that have zero inches of depth, i.e. they can't have SRS for financial or other reasons. Would I want to switch places with them? No. Hell no. So maybe I need to check myself before I wreck myself. Now I am not putting my trip on you, or suggesting your pain and frustration is not valid, but I am offering myself up as an example of being our own worst enemy.
There are plenty of things that suck about being trans, and I think many of us have been asking ourselves, "What is wrong with me?" for so long we don't know when to stop. I know I am guilty of this.
Let me simply offer my blessings to you, and hope that you find some peace and satisfaction in knowing how far you have come.
With kindness,
Terri