Susan's Place Logo
Main Menu

Giggle for Girls loses High Court appeal bid. Roxanne Tickle discrimination case

Started by Sarah B, Yesterday at 07:49:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Sarah B

Title: Giggle for Girls loses High Court appeal bid in Roxanne Tickle discrimination case
Link To: Article 🔗 [Link: news.com.au/national/courts-​law/giggle-​for-​girls-​app-​founder-​loses-​final-​appeal-​bid-​in-​landmark-​trans-​discrimination-​case/news-​story/7db773b0207192809214c498c8048e91/]
Author:
Date: Sep 10, 2026
Trigger Warning: None

Brief summary of the article
The High Court of Australia has refused Giggle for Girls and founder Sall Grover special leave to appeal a Federal Court ruling that they discriminated against transgender woman Roxanne Tickle by excluding her from the women-only app. The decision leaves in place the Federal Court's finding of direct discrimination and the increased $20,000 damages award to Ms Tickle, with the High Court also awarding costs against Giggle and Ms Grover. The case has prompted debate over the Sex Discrimination Act, gender identity protections and women-only spaces.

Main Points of the Article
"The years-long legal saga began in 2021 when Ms Grover personally removed Ms Tickle's profile from the app, after AI software designed to filter out males cleared her."

"Any appeal [...] has insufficient prospects of success to warrant a grant of special leave to appeal."

"These protections extend to all women, including transgender women."

Best Wishes Always
Sarah B
Global Moderator
@Jessica_Rose @Lori Dee @Petunia @Allie Jayne
Be who you want to be.
Sarah's Story
Feb 1989 Living my life as Sarah.
Feb 1989 Legally changed my name.
Mar 1989 Started hormones.
May 1990 Three surgery letters.
Feb 1991 Surgery.

Petunia

This really is good news, and to be fair the decision really had to go this way otherwise it would defy all logic.

But then again we live in uncertain times
And then one day you stop to find,
10 years have got behind you,
no one told you when to run,
you missed the starting gun
  •  
    The following users thanked this post: Lori Dee

Allie Jayne

Grovers team seemed confused, not really challenging the previous judgements on a legal basis, but still attempting to argue they weren't fair, so it was bound to fail. Grover has attacked Australia and the Government, and has said she will leave the country, reportedly bound for the UK. Her costs ar reportedly being paid for by the US christian conservative group, Alliance Defending Freedom, though this may not include penalties or Ms Tickles costs.

The Australian conservative groups, backed by the right wing parties, have started petitions and vowed to pressure the government to make changes to the Australian Sex Discrimination Act to define sex as sex assigned at birth, which effectively removes protection for trans people. Bills have already been tabled and defeated, but the pressure still there, so we cannot lose our vigilance at defending this Act. I have a meeting with our state Labor Equality Advisor on Monday to try to ensure our state politicians are educated as to how to respond to 'gotcha' questions which have been used in parliament and the press.

I strongly suspect the conservatives / right wingers have not actually read the Act as it already contains exemptions for situations of significant disadvantage or safety. This allows bodies to make a case to discriminate against trans people in certain circumstances, which mostly invalidates many of the anti trans groups arguments. So the contentious issue they have is that trans rights may diminish cis women's rights to single sex spaces. This is the argument we need to win to put this to bed.

Hugs,

Allie