Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

A Pain that I can't make go away.

Started by Glenn, August 17, 2011, 01:27:01 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Glenn

Today I felt really good. I had job hunting and got into a few interviews that left me feeling very well about myself and the changes in my life since beginning transitioning.  I was politely called miss and treated as a lady and even after the interviewer was informed that I am Transgender they treated me as a lady.  So feeling wonderful and a little empowered by the days events I decided to give visiting my sister a try and seeing if I could talk to her about her negative feelings towards my transition.

A little back ground. My sister has been opposed to me changing at all and has in the past caused some disputes in the family. But over the last 8 months she has begun to act civil around other family members and I had assumed she was beginning to except me for who I am.

So I headed over there from my interviews dressed nicely and feeling fine. I knocked on her screen door as I could see her inside on the phone.  I over heard her say. "Sorry I have to go my little brother is here" She came to the screen door with out opening it and asked what I wanted. 
I explained that I thought we should talk about how things have been between us since my transition had begun. 

She nodded and rather then invite me into her home she came out on the door step closing the door behind her.  She paused for a moment or two then told me that before I say anything she wanted to tell me her point of view.  After which she went ahead to do just that.  Her first words were I don't know you!  You're the person that killed my brother and stole 43 years of happy memories from me.  She went on for sometime leaving me speechless and as she was crying and I was shocked I cried also. She drove the point home by saying I had killed or murdered her little brother several times. When I finally interjected saying I''m still here still the same person. To which she replied, no you're not.  I can't call you Glenn anymore. I don't know a Marie, she's not my little brother. I can never forgive you for taking my brother away!

I left her there on the stairs crying as I cried in the car and drove off.  I drove for 3 hours just around town cried several times.  It seems that I have in changing my life for the better.  That I have somehow taken from my sister something I cannot replace.  At least in her view.
I am heart broken and I don't know what to do about it.

I'm not asking for sympathy or advice but this seemed the only place I could speak of this thing which has blind sided me so cruelly.
  •  

lonely girl

you have to understand your transition is not something trivial to her, especially if you were close with her.

My mom reacted exactly the same soon that I told her I wanted to be a girl... If i can collect all the tears I and my mom wept, I can fill buckets with them... It took quite some time (2-3 years) for her to finally adapt to the new me, and finally accepting and supporting me.

Give her some time, If she really loves you for the person you are, she will eventually accept you.
  •  

annette

Hi Marie Simone

Good to see you again.
I think Lonely girl has a point.....give it time.
We are in our minds the same person, so we expect that other people accept us as that person.
But is this realy true?
I don't think so, with the hormones running trough our veins.
We don't want to be treated as the person we were, we want to be seen in the right gender.
There is a difference in behaving of genders and leaving the role you were playing for so many years, is a big change to other people.
So, in a way your sister is right, you will never become her little brother with the behaving of a little brother.
Of course it was some kind of act she saw and was used to, but , she was used to it.
Now you're not playing a role anymore, but being the one you should have been in the first place, is quite a change to her.
She lost her brother, that's true, but I think she needs time to get use to her sister now.
Your transitionplans didn't come from a night oversleep, it has taken you years to get were you are now.
All those years your sister had no notice about.
So, give it time...she get use to it, just give it time.
You'll see, in time that pain will go away.

love
Annette
  •  

Cindy

Hugs Marie,

Remember you have not killed her brother, you have released her sister. She doesn't know it yet, but as you grow into the happy contented woman you are she will see. There is nothing easy in this journey, except how easy it is to make friends and be accepted here.

Love and Hugs Sis

Cindy
  •  

Glenn

The butterfly & the Caterpillar


A day came, a birth a tiny egg among many fertilized. The Magic of natures blessing passed onto a small, still yet un developed individual.  Months Pasts and he emerged drawn forth from his mother.  A Caterpillar his life begun a new, but with out direction.  His only lot in life to eat and move from leaf to leaf grazing on the green foliage. 

But he witnessed the beauty and grace of the butterfly, and longed to be as beautiful as she. Gliding effortlessly on the wind coming to gentle rest on beautiful flowers and kissing the due of the morning. She was all he wished to be.

Yet on the plant did he sit grazing himself fat rejecting his image not willing to look into a drop of due for fear of  the reflection that hurt his very soul to the deepest recesses of his heart.  For each time he would gaze into the mirror like surface of a due drop. His ugly face and fat long body would stare back at him reminding him that he was not the butterfly at all but some ugly worthless creature that had no place among the wonders and beauty that surrounded him. 

His heart sank his desire to be the butterfly so great.  His heart being that of a butterfly but his body slug like.  With out beauty, fat with only one purpose. To graze on the leafs and destroy the plants on which he feeds. 

Self loathing filled his demented heart, hatred for what god or nature had rendered in his creation! Desperately he looked around him casting from creature to creature searching for some logic.

In his sisters he saw the grace and beauty he so desired. Each time they would spread they're wings and glide about the sky with ease and grace, of which he had none. 

He would look at those younger then him, the children of his beautiful sisters.  One a butterfly the other a caterpillar but not a bland fat Caterpillar but a colour full and vivid caterpillar.  It's skin covered with fine multi colored hair black with red and yellow dots.  It's life not meaningless but with purpose. 


How he could exist was beyond his own imaginings. It seemed as though God and nature had purposely combined they're malice to create a caldron filled with the foulest of things then placed an incantation on the putrid stuff to creating him.

What a cruel joke has been played on me he would think.  My very appearance a tragedy and a torture to my mind. How could god and nature be so cruel and heartless to allow such a travesty?

In the Hights of his depression he created for himself and escape.  Forming a cocoon, creating a safe shell for him to hide his ugliness away from the world.
He crawled into it and waited for death to send the reaper to take him away.

Time passed and he lay in his cocoon dreaming of the butterfly. In his mind he became her so graceful so wondrous, beautiful. So after a long time he emerged from his cocoon, shedding the shell and opening his eyes to the light. 

To his horror and amazement he found pain on his back he twisted to see what was causing this pain and saw small wings had begun to form. He looked to his body expecting to see the fat ugly green skinned slug and was faced with a soft smooth skin the color and texture of cream.  He rant to a drop of due and in it he saw a young butterfly so pretty and he rejoiced! I am her that I wished so desperately to be!

When from over head a voice cried out.

"Ahhhrgg! What have you done?!!!!!!!! "

He looked and to his shock above him floating effortless on gossamer wings was his sister.

"You! What have you done to my brother?"

She spat in a most venomous voice. The newly formed butterfly said.

"It's me I have become what I always wished to be. I am your sister and I love you." 

Yet the hovering butterfly looked down from her vantage and said.
"You are not my brother, you are not the one whom I remember at all! You have stolen from me all that I could remember of my brother. You have murdered the brother I loved and you most certainly are not my sister!"

The sister butterfly then said.

"Go away from me what you have mutated into offends me to the core, you killed my brother!"


A new pain then opened in the heart of the newly formed and fragile butterfly. She had begun to become her dream, she had become her desire and in so doing fulfilled her life desire.  But the cost of her transformation was the lost of one of those she loves and values so much.

The end.

Quote: letter from. Ismena To Horatio.

Alass! How unequal am I to the task and how impossible is it for me to describe what is beyond all description! To think that one has another self, and another dearer part which participates of all our plans and joys, or rather feels the greater part of them, as being more concerned for interests of a beloved object then it's own, and to be confident that this is only to be for a time, a sudden start of fondness, but ever; fills the mind with ideas so ravishing and delicate as can ill represent by the force of words. -A tender friendship ( Or family relationship)

Quote: William Shakespeare from Hamlet

Alas, poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio, a fellow of infinite
jest, of most excellent fancy. He hath bore me on his back a
thousand times, and now how abhorr'd in my imagination it is!
My gorge rises at it.


  •  

Jillieann Rose

Marie,
:'( :'(
A big long hug.
I so wish I could deliever it in person and just sit with you.
But know, I cry with you sis.
  •  

FairyGirl

I experienced much the same from my siblings.  But you do move on, knowing that your own life is so much better.  It isn't your fault and you have done nothing wrong, only tried to live the best way you are able.

I can tell you this for certain, something my boyfriend told me: the butterfly, once freed from the cocoon, never dreams of the caterpillar.
Girls rule, boys drool.
If I keep a green bough in my heart, then the singing bird will come.
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: lonely girl on August 17, 2011, 02:30:13 AM
you have to understand your transition is not something trivial to her, especially if you were close with her.

My mom reacted exactly the same soon that I told her I wanted to be a girl... If i can collect all the tears I and my mom wept, I can fill buckets with them... It took quite some time (2-3 years) for her to finally adapt to the new me, and finally accepting and supporting me.

Give her some time, If she really loves you for the person you are, she will eventually accept you.



I appreciate your view and I understand that my transition is not a trivial thing for her.  Because to me it is the best thing to happen to me in my life. 
what astonishes me is that she was the person in the family closest to me. The one that told me that I had to find what would make me happy and do it.
I guess what makes me happy was not what she expected.
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: Cindy James on August 17, 2011, 02:57:42 AM
Hugs Marie,

Remember you have not killed her brother, you have released her sister. She doesn't know it yet, but as you grow into the happy contented woman you are she will see. There is nothing easy in this journey, except how easy it is to make friends and be accepted here.

Love and Hugs Sis

Cindy

This is true Cindy and it seems when things look black I can come back here to talk about them.
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: annette on August 17, 2011, 02:54:54 AM
Hi Marie Simone

Good to see you again.
I think Lonely girl has a point.....give it time.
We are in our minds the same person, so we expect that other people accept us as that person.
But is this really true?
I don't think so, with the hormones running trough our veins.
We don't want to be treated as the person we were, we want to be seen in the right gender.
There is a difference in behaving of genders and leaving the role you were playing for so many years, is a big change to other people.
So, in a way your sister is right, you will never become her little brother with the behaving of a little brother.
Of course it was some kind of act she saw and was used to, but , she was used to it.
Now you're not playing a role anymore, but being the one you should have been in the first place, is quite a change to her.
She lost her brother, that's true, but I think she needs time to get use to her sister now.
Your transitionplans didn't come from a night oversleep, it has taken you years to get were you are now.
All those years your sister had no notice about.
So, give it time...she get use to it, just give it time.
You'll see, in time that pain will go away.

love
Annette

Annette how are you? It's been a long time since we talked' Well as most things time can heal all wounds. My sister is a very slow healer. She divorced from her husband for adultery 20 years ago and she still longs for him..  But stubborn as well in that she will not except to go back.  So it may come to pass that I have lost a sibling. I intend to move away from this city when my transition is finished.  I want to start new somewhere that know one knows who I was before.  Maybe Holland what you say sis? lol
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: Valeriedances on August 17, 2011, 04:00:32 PM
It is hardest on our families, they can have such a hard time accepting. We know this, and yet it still hurts almost more than we can bare.

The best we can do is remind them that we are still here and that we miss them.


Thank you those are kind and wise words. I'm feeling a bit better having written my poem and taken the time to cry it out of my system. 
Tears can be magical in they're ability to cleans ones spirit.
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: Jillieann on August 17, 2011, 05:01:55 PM
Marie,
:'( :'(
A big long hug.
I so wish I could deliever it in person and just sit with you.
But know, I cry with you sis.


Jillieann you've come so far look at you!  Thank you for the hug, I still need to get to port huron someday
  •  

Glenn

Quote from: FairyGirl on August 17, 2011, 05:30:24 PM
I experienced much the same from my siblings.  But you do move on, knowing that your own life is so much better.  It isn't your fault and you have done nothing wrong, only tried to live the best way you are able.

I can tell you this for certain, something my boyfriend told me: the butterfly, once freed from the cocoon, never dreams of the caterpillar.


That's beautiful and thank you so much
  •  

Cindy

  •  

annette

Hi Marie
In Holland we have so many blunt people that we're glad to see when nice people are coming to Holland.
So, it's not a bad idea to teach us some friendliness and politeness, welcome dear.
With me everything is okay, still poor and healthy.
How are your parents, I remember you had their support and from your Italian brother in law.

What about the slow healing of your sister, it's a pitty and I'm sorry to hear that, but I was in the same thing with my parents and brother and at the end of the day they all came back to me.
There is always hope and if not, don't forget you must try to live your own life and not the life your sister want you to live, she can manage her own life not yours.
Keep faith but don't try to convince her, it will make her more stubborn, when she don't want to have contact with you, it's her loss, she will let the chance go by to meet a lovely new sister.

hugs and kisses sis
Annette
  •