Quote from: Thrall on October 28, 2011, 10:18:52 AM
insideontheoutside, anti - AD propaganda? really? i don't think it's time and place to do so.
do you have any medical education?
I think it's the exact time and place to do so. It's funny that people think talk like that is "propaganda". My "education" is in pharmaceutical marketing (which I'll let you in on a little secret ... that IS propaganda ... so much so that I refused to work with any more of them because I still have some moral, ethical fiber left in my body) and also personal experience. I was on them - and so have at least two dozen people I personally know, one of whom is no longer with us because she committed suicide earlier this year after going on a new anti-depressant (after being on 3 different ones in the course of 3 years).
When it comes to anti-depressants, I have yet to see 100% proof from any source that anti-depressants do anything (except cause side effects). When placebos in studies have similar effects, why wouldn't you question the effectiveness? Oh right, they don't exactly put those on public display do they? Those studies ... or who's in their control groups ... or how many actual adverse reactions were experienced ... etc.
Of course simply knowing about the inner workings of the pharmaceutical industry and all the personal experience I have on the topic isn't enough for someone who believes in the medication and what their doctor says (never mind that the drug companies have their pushers ...ooops I mean sales force ... offering "gifts" to doctors for filling more prescriptions ... that's all part of the marketing though.)
What anti-depressants may (note the use of the word "may" - that's important in the legal department - because you can't actually claim or verify that it will help with anything - only that it "may" treat something) be, is enough of a crutch for someone to get back on their feet - but I'll tell you right now that statistically, people will not get off the meds, and when they stop working or they find themselves unable to cope with regular life again, it starts a very vicious cycle - one that the pharmaceutical industry makes a considerable amount of money on (even with all the lawsuits and the marketing budgets). Even if you do go on an anti-depressant (or anti-anxiety med for that matter) you should be trying alternatives and additional coping mechanisms so that you do not rely on a pill.
Believe what you want. I've said what I wanted to say on it - and the only reason why I do speak up about it is I have a genuine concern for people - unlike the pharmaceutical industry - who have gone through depression or anxiety like I have. I'm saying there are alternatives out there. I've used them. And unlike the drugs, the alternatives did help make me a lot healthier. I no longer experience depression or anxiety like I had. I overcame anxiety and depression that was so bad I would not leave my house for 3 months straight. Depression isn't just a chemical imbalance in the brain, nor is anxiety or panic disorder. Feelings of depression and anxiety are a normal experience of life - it's when those experiences become on-going and every day occurrences that they actually become symptoms of a larger problem. The drugs do not, "right a chemical imbalance" - that's the marketing, folks. Some can mask the symptom of depression (Xanax can, for instance, for a little while) but I'm telling you, it's not something you should be thankful to get on. Do not use it as a fix all. Explore the alternatives.