Susan's Place Logo

News:

Visit our Discord server  and Wiki

Main Menu

Just man up and be yourself

Started by Alyx., January 12, 2012, 06:37:51 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alyx.

My sister said this to me, she wants me to stay a boy.
Wait, I thought that was the entire point of transition, I stop going through my life being a sad panda about not being a girl and do something about it. But in her opinion that means I stop moping about not being someone I'm not (A girl) and accept myself as nature made me.

This got me to thinking, which requires more bravery to do? At which point would I stop pretending and act like myself? What even is myself anyway? Am I myself when I don't have to take hormones and fake a voice, or am I myself when I do what makes me happy?

Does fleeing my male life really make me a coward?  ???
If you do not agree to my demands... TOO LATE
  •  

spacial

I think living according to the wishes of others is a cop-out. You may as well not bother living at all.

Seems to me what your sister is actually saying, I don't want to be bothered by your problems, I have a load of my own.

And,

I have build a relationship with you as a brother. We have developed the space between us as brother and sister. Our boundaries are male and female. I can't get my head around dealing with you as a sister.

But it's your life. Live changes and moves on. You need to do what you think best. Your situation seems analogous to a family which have always had one set of values, but one, (you) decides they want to adopt a different one.

The others will simply need to get use to it or lose you.

Their choice.
  •  

Zarania

Quote from: Heartwood (Alex) on January 12, 2012, 06:37:51 AM
My sister said this to me, she wants me to stay a boy.
Wait, I thought that was the entire point of transition, I stop going through my life being a sad panda about not being a girl and do something about it. But in her opinion that means I stop moping about not being someone I'm not (A girl) and accept myself as nature made me.

This got me to thinking, which requires more bravery to do? At which point would I stop pretending and act like myself? What even is myself anyway? Am I myself when I don't have to take hormones and fake a voice, or am I myself when I do what makes me happy?

Does fleeing my male life really make me a coward?  ???

doing what you WANNA do is actually making you a HERO and not a COWARD.

  •  

Ava C

Quote from: Beverley on January 12, 2012, 08:33:33 AM

It does not matter whether fleeing your male life makes you a hero or a coward - it is YOUR decision to make. You only get one life, your sister has her own life. You must do what is right for yourself. She can advise or offer opinions but you must do what is right for you.

Transitioning is not easy, I do not think a coward would do it. Besides a wise (wo)man flees a disaster area and does not wait about for it to get worse.

I am busy fleeing myself :D

Beverley

Exactly! You stole those words from my mouth.  :)
living halfway between reality and fantasy at all times.
  •  

A

Does fleeing your male life make you a coward? Similar question, does "fleeing" an eventual carreer your parents wanted you to do but which you hate make you a coward? Of course not.

Anyhow, if you're questioning about that comment from your sister, perhaps you should bring it up with a therapist.
A's Transition Journal
Last update: June 11th, 2012
No more updates
  •  

Julie Wilson

Most people tend to be afraid of change and risk-taking.

Not transitioning requires neither.

Staying in a bad situation because it is familiar tends to be a cowardly solution.
  •  

Rosa

Do what you think will make you happy.  Only you know who you really are, and it often takes time and exploration to figure this out.  If you do decide to transition, you don't have to think of it as fleeing manhood, you could see it as embracing your womanhood.
  •  

JoanneB

I tried "manning up" very early, again after graduating university, yet again after after separation/divorce from my wife, yet again after a fiancee called things off ......

Don't get me wrong, I've done pretty good. I really have very little regret over my decisions. By almost any measure (besides physical appearance), as a guy, I done good. In a perfect world if I could just wake up as I often prayed since the age of 4, as a girl, I'd do it in a flash.

For me it was always a question of balance. At 6' tall, big boned, very balding in my teens  >:( and a host of other negatives like weighing 250 lbs way way back, my answer was always No Way can I transition. Today, some 30+ years after my first experiment at part time, the answer is more like a definite maybe yes I can. Of course, life has complicated any immediate decision.

If my wife said, asked, and for the most part even subliminally asks me to stop the insanity, I know I can. Essentially, due to work and other life pressures, even my occasional releases were put on hiatus for a good 10 years. Quality time with her was more important. She has known about me since the first date, mostly supportive, but understandably would like things not to drastically change.

I guess it's the pragmatist in me that affords me the flexibility to endure guy mode. It sucks, but not to the point of offing myself. Long ago I thought locking Joanne away was the easy way out. during the ensuing years I've since learned that it take an incredible amount of bravery, perhaps more than transitioning, to keep up the pretense of being a guy.

The net energy drain may be the same, no matter what decision is made. The simple fact is one path is an essentially joyless life, the other......
.          (Pile Driver)  
                    |
                    |
                    ^
(ROCK) ---> ME <--- (HARD PLACE)
  •  

justmeinoz

Unless your sister is going to be by your side for the rest of your life to help you hold yourself together,  her opinion is just that . Her opinion.

She is not the one who has had to face a life of sitting on the edge of a cliff with a gun to their head, so to speak.  If she can't even handle the idea of you being slightly physically different, how would she cope if you were to suffer cancer or some other life threatening illness or a major disability?  Frankly I wouldn't pay to much attention to her complaints Alex. 

As someone here said," it takes real balls to become a woman!"

Karen.


"Don't ask me, it was on fire when I lay down on it"
  •