Fish.
It's not so much that I'd have a problem shooting fuzzy woodland creatures ... but I know I wouldn't be able to handle skinning and cleaning up the body. I'd feel guilty ... and probably grossed out and go completely vegan after that. And I can always let the fish free. But really I'd rather not do either but that's not an option. So fish!
Would you rather get a new High end state of the art computer or a new car?