Is ours a Christian nation?

[cindianna_jones]

I've been troubled of late by those who insist that ours is a Christian nation. It is a matter of historical record which shows that our founding fathers were not alligned with "the Christian church"  when putting together our government.

Tonight I was doing some reading on this subject and came across the following article.  It is a real treat to read something with "just the facts" and little of the writer's opinion.

http://www.yosemitedems.net/FFathers.html

Check it out if you're looking for quotable quotes on this subject.

Cindi

[Susan]

Start with My letter to the IRS Commissioner from back in 2004, then move on to Joan Bokaer's excellent Theocracy Watch web site, and last but most certainly not the least is an article published by the Nation magazine on Our godless constitution. If you need more let me know.

The people who think this is a Christian nation are what's known as Christian reconstructionists.

Joan Bokaer speaking on "Are We Becoming a Theocracy?"

http://video.google.com/googleplayer.swf?docId=-6082626617349511699

Life and Liberty for All Who Believe

http://video.google.com/googleplayer.swf?docId=4716092367662227177

Joan Bokaer speaking on "The Rise of Dominionism"

http://video.google.com/googleplayer.swf?docId=-5388450360562655999

Can you tell this is a subject I have some very strong opinions on? These people are not Christians, they are "christians" or so called christians...

[cindianna_jones]

I'm thinking of becoming overtly politically active again. I need to do something in my community.

Hmmmmm.

Cindi

[Susan]

Need any tips just ask me or Togetherwecan.....

[cindianna_jones]

To the bat cave?

Something like that!

Cindi

[ChefAnnagirl]

I wish someone would simply explain to all of us - how or why a man -  a "prophet" -  -  someone supposedly "like" Jesus himself - obviously well-noted for advocating, and most certainly possessing all of the deepest qualities of unconditional love, acceptance, sacrifice, generosity, and forgiveness - to the utmost extent possible of any human being ever - right ? -

I would wish to suppose that this then would be the ideal(?) example that (all) of his followers ideally would, and therefore logically should, wish to follow with all of their hearts and minds - right ? 

i mean, provided that anyone that believes in this man, i should think actually respects such positive messages as he was undoubtedly sent to deliver ?

How could such a person ever have sanctioned any sort of thing as the vitriolic hatred and total lack of acceptance or discrimination and prejudice of every kind that has occurred between peoples of any kind for centuries on top of centuries - and even to go so far as to establish a justification for the minimization of, and the general abuse and disrespect of say, women (and children) in general for example ?

How can this (could this have) ever been justified by this person, or any other such so called "standard", or living embodiment of God's all encompassing love, no matter what race or culture or set of wise men or prophets (take your pick - Buddha, Mohammed, Jesus, others, etc...) that you like -  ?

Would he ? - well - would he ? cmon - They'd all just stand by and cheer on someone that is beating (or stoning) any other person just for being different than himself ? - Yeah - he or she would be a "good" Chrisitan - Sure he would - he'd look right at you and say "i hate your guts, you little sinning pervert - and for that, i'm gonna stomp your ass into the pavement"...... "oh, and youre not forgiven either" - almost forgot to mention that part before i decided to speak for good ol' Jesus himself and kill, rape, maim, or discriminate against or disrespect you as i deem necessary to prove my superiority and rightful "Chrisitan" dominion... You know - WWJD an all that stuff - right ? ....

Someone out there please tell me how "he" would just stand by and idly watch, or even better yet, encourage the beating of ANY person, much less any form of TG one.... Awwwww - cmon - i know there has just got to be someone out there willing to step up to the plate  - speak up - How does that work, exactly ?

- how dare they distort the truths of love and acceptance he tried to give to all of us, and then have the sheer audacity to call themselves "Christians", and their "religion" "Christianity"... the love of all of the prophets has been so twisted for gain, for power over others, and for corrupt agenda that has nothing to do with truly loving thy fellow man in truth...

I think that this and other religions and cults in general, have given many people the ability to amass such political power, influence, and the sick justification for somehow presupposing the necessary correctness of establishing complete dominion over other peoples, simply because they do not share the same beliefs, or are different in any way - 

This has got to be one of the greatest disgraces of the whole human race - To me, this seems to be almost the very core of all evil, warfare, and bloodshed in so many ways.

How unfortunate that such things of beauty and incredible miraculous cosmic perfection could have ever been so distorted into such bloody instruments of hatred, ill will, prejudice, and willful misunderstanding between so many people, still to this day.

Just felt like venting a little....

Sincerely,


Annagirl

[rhonda13000]

I've been troubled of late by those who insist that ours is a Christian nation. It is a matter of historical record which shows that our founding fathers were not alligned with "the Christian church"  when putting together our government.

Tonight I was doing some reading on this subject and came across the following article.  It is a real treat to read something with "just the facts" and little of the writer's opinion.

http://www.yosemitedems.net/FFathers.html

Check it out if you're looking for quotable quotes on this subject.

Cindi

No, it is not.

And I have posited before that in my admittedly very limited perspective, I do believe that we are living now in the incipient [perhaps beyond incipient] stages of the [self] destruction of this nation in a pattern which has been oft repeated throughout history [i.e., Roman Empire].

I too rhetorically shake my head, when I hear this country described as such.

[cindianna_jones]

Annagirl. That's it isn't it? You've pinpointed the key issue.  What would Christ do? (Assuming he was the guy we've been taught he was).  Wasn't it Jesus who "coined" the phrase "Give unto Ceasar that which is Ceasar's?"  

I've only looked at the first video that Susan posted here.  I'm going to have to look at the other two later today.  But I'm astonished at how much is really behind this.  And here I thought that it was just a bunch of wackos throwing their weight around. I don't generally give much weight to conspiracies, so I'm not going to call it that.... but this is a very well organized effort isn't it?

Cindi

[rhonda13000]

"The people who think this is a Christian nation are what's known as Christian reconstructionists."

Not exclusively.

There is a large contingent of the naive and ignorant.
"I've been troubled of late by those who insist that ours is a Christian nation."

I watched the first video; I like her.

It necessarily begs the question: "What constitutes Christianity?"

[Attis]

Europe was created by history. America was created by philosophy. -- Margaret Thatcher.

Too bad the neo-cons don't know this.

-- Brede

[Hazumu]

Bravo!!

Could this be re-engineered into a 'Who said THAT?!?' e-mail, and leave it to the reader to GOOGLE the author?  It's MUCH more powerful when you think it's written by some kinda' amur'ka-hatin' RAD-i-kul, and you find out it's a Founding Father.

And for those who revel in ritual without understanding what it is you're saying, a mondergreen version of a common ritual:

"I pledge a lesion to the flag, of the United State of America, and to the republic for Richard Stans, one naked individual, with liver tea and just this for all."

Karen

[Ms Bev]

How unfortunate that such things of beauty and incredible miraculous cosmic perfection could have ever been ever been distorted into such bloody instruments of hatred, ill will, prejudice, and willful misunderstanding between so many people still to this day.

Just felt like venting a little....

Sincerely,


Annagirl

Anna...........what would Jesus do?  I think after He cried, he would take over.  The trouble with the church, is that it's full of people.  The trouble with Christians, is that they're people following people.

Bev, Christian

[cindianna_jones]

Who was it said that our "constitution can withstand the term of any president"?  I think that we've come dangerously close to disproving that famous remark!

Cindi

[rhonda13000]

How unfortunate that such things of beauty and incredible miraculous cosmic perfection could have ever been ever been distorted into such bloody instruments of hatred, ill will, prejudice, and willful misunderstanding between so many people still to this day.

Just felt like venting a little....

Sincerely,


Annagirl

Anna...........what would Jesus do?  I think after He cried, he would take over.  The trouble with the church, is that it's full of people.  The trouble with Christians, is that they're people following people.

Bev, Christian

Mankind perverts, abuses or distorts pretty much everything that it get 'its hands' on or is involved with, be it theology or the complete absence of theology.

I look at the state of the religious world as it is, has been and I just shake my head.

I read literary tripe like the 'Humanist Manifesto' and I scoff at the presumptuousness, naivete and self-deification of it.

The commonality between these two? Mankind thinks that it can do things in life fully independently on the sole basis of its intuition or internal guidance.

Please.

Jeremiah 10:23, et al.

[cindianna_jones]

I believe that it is when we move from hoping that God is on our side to where we KNOW that God IS on our side that we create these huge boondoggles. 

Cindi

[Chaunte]

I believe that it is when we move from hoping that God is on our side to where we KNOW that God IS on our side that we create these huge boondoggles. 

Cindi

Cindi,

The onlything I would disagree with is the word "boondoggle."  It needs to be replaced with something much more dangerous & alarming.  Something like "extremist."

Is the United States a Christian nation?  No.  I believe that we are becoming a nation of religious extremists.  If you take away the IED's and suicide bombers and just at the rhetoric, is there really much of a difference between the Neocons/"Religious Right" and the Islamic clerics of Iran & Iraq?

I don't really think so.

And that is very fightening...

Chaunte

[BeverlyAnn]

The onlything I would disagree with is the word "boondoggle."  It needs to be replaced with something much more dangerous & alarming.  Something like "extremist."

Is the United States a Christian nation?  No.  I believe that we are becoming a nation of religious extremists.  If you take away the IED's and suicide bombers and just at the rhetoric, is there really much of a difference between the Neocons/"Religious Right" and the Islamic clerics of Iran & Iraq?

I don't really think so.

And that is very fightening...

Actually when you think of the far religious right, we have had IED's.  They just planted them at abortion clinics and gay bars.  What actually worries me is the possibility that this country could turn into a true theocracy.  Fortunately, there is no right wing preacher around who is charismatic enough to sway the extremist vote.  (Read Robert Heinlein's novella If This Goes On.)

Beverly

[Hazumu]

Right now I'm reading "The Blank Slate", by Steven Pinker.  In it, he comes up with some fundamental frames that have lead to the thinking that has made the modern-day militant Christians we're discussing in this topic.  I've linked to a Wikipedia page with a bit more on the book.  Basically, after attempting to show how 'The Blank Slate', 'The Noble Savage' and 'The Ghost in the Machine' lead to the belief that all human beings are innately capable of any choice they want, (including for/against homosexuality or transsexuality, the angle that has me interested...), and this mind-set leads to overgeneralization and persecution of those who deviate (they could choose NOT to, y'know,) he sets about showing how the Ghost IS the Machine, as it were, that our spirits/souls arise out of the bio-chemo-electrical-mechanical machine that is our bodies and indeed is US!

But far from leading to nihilism and the loss of all morality, Mr Pinker shows (or is beginning to show, which is where I am in the book, how the human mind, made up of subsystems containing black-box modules which are all cross wired to each other, gives rise to morality, altruism, and other behaviours cherished by the 'free will' Christians (and, of course, others who desperately wish to believe in a ghost- or a pronoun-in-the-machine.)

Along the way he brings research that illuminates his points, such as psychopaths showed all the traits of psychopathy at a very early age (lack of remorse, unreliability, cruelty to animals/ other children, untruthfulness,) and the eerie similarities in the personalities, talents and skills of identical twins, who essentially share the exact same genes.

I present this as further food for thought on this topic...

Karen

[Chaunte]

The onlything I would disagree with is the word "boondoggle."  It needs to be replaced with something much more dangerous & alarming.  Something like "extremist."

Is the United States a Christian nation?  No.  I believe that we are becoming a nation of religious extremists.  If you take away the IED's and suicide bombers and just at the rhetoric, is there really much of a difference between the Neocons/"Religious Right" and the Islamic clerics of Iran & Iraq?

I don't really think so.

And that is very fightening...

Actually when you think of the far religious right, we have had IED's.  They just planted them at abortion clinics and gay bars.  What actually worries me is the possibility that this country could turn into a true theocracy.  Fortunately, there is no right wing preacher around who is charismatic enough to sway the extremist vote.  (Read Robert Heinlein's novella If This Goes On.)

Beverly

Hi, Bev!

I stand corrected about the IED's. Thank you.  And I have read If This Goes On.  I am seeing far to many paralels between fiction & reality.

Chaunte

Remember - just because you are paranoid doesn't mean that the world isn't out to get you! 

[BeverlyAnn]

And I have read If This Goes On.  I am seeing far to many paralels between fiction & reality.

Ironic isn't it how a story written in 1940 and expanded to novella length in 1953 can be so relevant to what the right wing is up to these days?

Beverly