Susan's Place Logo

News:

Please be sure to review The Site terms of service, and rules to live by

Main Menu

General Anesthesia or Regional Spinal Anesthesia?

Started by Laura Emily, October 12, 2012, 12:14:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Laura Emily

I've been thinking of doing Regional, because I have watched a video of the surgery being performed many times and it's never bothered me. I've also found it really fascinating to watch, and I hear that the side effects are much more tolerable than with traditional general anesthesia. I'm just wondering if anyone has undergone spinal? Was it a good/bad experience for you? Would you do it again, if you had to?
Those who live life to please others, rather than live the life they please, live only to exist.  - LEV
  •  

Brooke777

I have had many procedures on my back. I much prefer spinal over general for the fact that I don't like the effects of waking up from the general. Neither hurt, and it was kind of neat to watch my procedure on the monitor with the spinal block.
  •  

veritatemfurto

I personally don't trust general anesthesia, having watched several relatives be put under and NEVER wake up.
~;{@ Mel @};~

My GRS on 04-14-2015


Of all the things there are to do on this planet, there's only one thing that I must do- Live!
  •  

Laura Emily

Thanks for the replies! RSA is sounding more and more appealing!! :)
Those who live life to please others, rather than live the life they please, live only to exist.  - LEV
  •  

veritatemfurto

YW... now if they could do regional anesthesia for GRS, that would take the cake for masochistic trippiness, though I doubt  a choice in that matter.
~;{@ Mel @};~

My GRS on 04-14-2015


Of all the things there are to do on this planet, there's only one thing that I must do- Live!
  •  

Laura Emily

It is for GRS. The letter I received from dr brassards office in Montreal mentioned it.
Those who live life to please others, rather than live the life they please, live only to exist.  - LEV
  •  

eli77

Brassard does an epidural combined with twilight sedation. You aren't awake for the surgery, though occasionally people wake up during for a few minutes and go back to sleep. You can request general anesthetic if you want, but I wouldn't really recommend it. It can make for a harder recovery.

I did the epidural/twilight sedation. No problems other than the expected nausea.
  •  

henrytwob

The twighlight sedation is probably what we call conscious sedation, it  is usual a combo of two drugs versed  and fentynal, although there are many others they may chose from. During this time you maintain control of your own reflexes. For example, you breath on your own and are not intubated. Technically, you will be able to hear what is going on, you just will not remember it.

They use this type of sedation for many procedures, such as endoscopies. They may also use it for certain surgeries. I had to a some serous surgery on my foot last year. I originally thought I would go with the conscious sedation. However, when I was there, I realized I didn't really want to be hear the saw ( or see the saw) that would be cutting a large part of my first metacarpal off, so at the last minute I changed my mind.  As a nurse, who never wanted to be an O.R. nurse, I decided i didn't want to be "present" for the procedure.

The surgery you are talking about is fairly major.  If your concern is safety or immediately post op, I can tell you that I have professionally seen very few complications as a result of anesthesia. There are always possible complications, but often that has more to do with the surgery rather than the sedation method. 

I just figured I'd add this to give you a balanced view point.

Good luck on your surgery, I'm sure whichever method you decide on, the results will be worth it.
  •  

Laura Emily

I'd just really be interested in being awake for the surgery so I could watch them work. Thanks for all the replies. I guess I still have sometime to decide.
Those who live life to please others, rather than live the life they please, live only to exist.  - LEV
  •  

blueconstancy

My wife had Brassard's spinal/epidural plus sedation rather than general anesthesia; she does not recall the procedure (!), but I was there when they wheeled her back, and she was already alert and lucid. In fact, the only real issue was the painkillers they used in combination and afterward - those caused nausea and made her "high" for a bit.

The nurses all said that general was harder to wake up and also to recover from, and had more annoying side effects, but was still usually safe.
  •