Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Am I betraying my self?

Started by Emma Morgaine, November 13, 2012, 03:57:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Emma Morgaine

The past few years have been very intense for me. From the age of thirteen I believed myself to be a gay man, at 20 I learned that I was indeed bisexual and that took some serious adjustment for me. I felt like I had to redefine who I was, as if my masculinity had to take dominance over my femininity because I was a MAN who liked WOMEN. Here recently, and only very recently, I have discovered that I am a girl...and a boy and simultaneously, neither; more, different. Most days i am okay with this expanded awareness of who I, Ewan, am. Late at night, when the world was asleep I would let down my hair from it's ponytail and apply makeup and flowing skirts. i told myself it was strictly for "spiritual purposes" but inside I knew it wasn't. i knew it was because a part of me, that I grew to call Emma, wanted it. loved it. i would wake up some days and feel a strange sensation of "where are my breasts? Why is there a penis down there? Other days i was fine and felt very much myself. Now I can finally acknowledge this outloud to myself, that I am most definitely TRANSGENDERED. (deep breath) But this realization has come with a price. i feel like maybe I'm somehow betraying Ewan by embracing "Emma" i know that these two names are indeed one person, ME, but i find it hard some days to have them co exist. i feel like maybe i am betraying nature's gift to me (my male body) or that i am somehow abusing or neglecting the man i have always been. i feel, on some days like i am disgusting for feeling this way. crazy. not OKAY.  Am i being punished? am i just punishing myself? why was it so easy to embrace my sexuality but now so difficult to embrace my genders. Can I be both male and female? i feel that i am. I love the womanly part of myself. I love being a woman. i love dressing as a woman. does that mean i  have to stop being a man?
:icon_flamed:
  •  

Kevin Peña

I wouldn't be able to answer that, but I can say that you should do what makes you most happy. You have no obligation to anyone to live life as a man if you don't want to.
  •  

BlueSloth

Quote from: Ewan-Emma Morgaine on November 13, 2012, 03:57:55 PM
Can I be both male and female? i feel that i am.
Yup.

Quote from: Ewan-Emma Morgaine on November 13, 2012, 03:57:55 PM
I love the womanly part of myself. I love being a woman. i love dressing as a woman. does that mean i  have to stop being a man?
Nope.

Quote from: DianaP on November 13, 2012, 04:34:51 PM
do what makes you most happy. You have no obligation to anyone to live life as a man if you don't want to.
Also, you have no obligation to not live as a man.
  •  

Catherine Sarah

Hi Emma,

You asked four very interesting questions, that I will attempt to answer.
1. Are you being punished?  Answer. No.
2. Are you just punishing yourself? Answer. Most probably yes.
3.Can I be both male and female. Answer. As we have both Oestrogen and testosterone in our body/brain, yes we can be both, but not simultaneously. Depends which hormone is dominant.
4. Do you have to stop being a man. Answer. Being totally open and honest with yourself, it depends on what you want or who you want to be.

If you are vacillating between these two states is becoming too uncomfortable, might I suggest you seek out a professional gender therapist to talk your feelings over with? You may be pleasantly surprised at the the person you find within.

Be safe, well and happy.

Lotsa huggs
Catherine




If you're in Australia and are subject to Domestic Violence or Violence against Women, call 1800-RESPECT (1800-737-7328) for assistance.
  •  

Emma Morgaine

i was in therapy for 10 years in attempt by my mother to change me. you could imagine my feelings toward them, but i believe you are right about talking to one. thank you for all of the answers!
:icon_flamed:
  •  

Beverly

Quote from: Ewan-Emma Morgaine on November 15, 2012, 03:40:25 AM
i was in therapy for 10 years in attempt by my mother to change me. you could imagine my feelings toward them, but i believe you are right about talking to one. thank you for all of the answers!

There therapists and there are therapists. Going to one YOU have chosen would be very different from being sent to one someone else has chosen.


Quote from: Ewan-Emma Morgaine on November 13, 2012, 03:57:55 PM
I love being a woman. i love dressing as a woman. does that mean i  have to stop being a man?

Well, I cannot see how you could be a woman and a man at the same time. Maybe ask in the Androgyne section?
  •  

Seana

It all seems like perfectly normal soul -searching and progression to me.

A Gender Therapist is ALOT different than most "generic therapists" .
Over time your personality will probably level out to one gender or the other. It's all part of the self-acceptance and it comes clearer with life experience, self acceptance . In short you'll trend towards one gender or the other and the other will become less prominant.

It's important to note, especially since you seem to be struggling with this part, sexuality is generally seperate from gender identity. So of course it is a different level of difficult.

I'll tell you what thought helped me the most. The people who are most important in my life , . the ones that are closest or more supporting, or those that are blood relatiion, are the ones LEAST LIKELY to have an issue with my gender identity. The ones that do have issues, are the least likely to be involved in my life.

Seana
  •  

monica.soto

Hey Emma,

I think we tend to box ourselves into what a man or a woman should be, the thing is you are emma/ewan, there is no one without the other. it's just you.

There's a lot of things we think we are or think we want, but are they truly so? The who you are is a mixture of expectations put upon you by your family and loved ones, society and last of all yourself.

You talk about punishment, and because of how you phrased it, I can tell you're aware that in the end the only person who can punish you is yourself (by either accepting or submitting).

Your sexuality and gender are parts of the whole, if you feel the fluidity of being male/female it's not the case of being either or, you are who you are, and there's no way you're betraying yourself if you're being yourself.

take care
Signature not Required
  •  

Emma Morgaine

Quote from: monica.soto on November 15, 2012, 11:09:01 AM
Hey Emma,

I think we tend to box ourselves into what a man or a woman should be, the thing is you are emma/ewan, there is no one without the other. it's just you.

There's a lot of things we think we are or think we want, but are they truly so? The who you are is a mixture of expectations put upon you by your family and loved ones, society and last of all yourself.

You talk about punishment, and because of how you phrased it, I can tell you're aware that in the end the only person who can punish you is yourself (by either accepting or submitting).

Your sexuality and gender are parts of the whole, if you feel the fluidity of being male/female it's not the case of being either or, you are who you are, and there's no way you're betraying yourself if you're being yourself.

take care


Bless you! Thank you, for your words were amazing and encouraging! I keep reminding myself to just stay true to myself, but sometimes it is hard to see who I am.
:icon_flamed:
  •  

Emma Morgaine

Quote from: Seana on November 15, 2012, 08:07:27 AM
It all seems like perfectly normal soul -searching and progression to me

It's important to note, especially since you seem to be struggling with this part, sexuality is generally seperate from gender identity. So of course it is a different level of difficult.

Seana

you're very right. thank you.
:icon_flamed:
  •  

Taka

i just want to say that it's perfectly possible to be both male and female at the same time. on the biological level the best examples would be males with female chromosomes. mentally bigender is another good example.

there are days when i seriously argue with myself over stupid little things that my male and female sides can't agree on. those are very confusing days, and luckily i'm usually more of one or the other, or none, so i don't have to fight myself constantly. that would be rather tiring.

hormones may or may not change how you feel about your gender identity. some experience that the so-called birth gender just disappears, and it wasn't anywhere near as bad as they thought it would be. other people never lose that side, and in their case that side is most likely a valid part of their identity. but hormone treatment might still make it easier to live in peace with yourself as the genders you are.

don't let anyone tell you what you probably are. statistically everybody is probably cis and heterosexual. but to many trans or homosexuals, that was never even a possibility to be considered. looking at yourself, and not others, what do you think you are? any answer or suggestion is a valid one as long as it's based on your own experience.
  •  

Emma Morgaine

Quote from: Taka on November 16, 2012, 04:12:25 PM
i just want to say that it's perfectly possible to be both male and female at the same time. on the biological level the best examples would be males with female chromosomes. mentally bigender is another good example.

there are days when i seriously argue with myself over stupid little things that my male and female sides can't agree on. those are very confusing days, and luckily i'm usually more of one or the other, or none, so i don't have to fight myself constantly. that would be rather tiring.

hormones may or may not change how you feel about your gender identity. some experience that the so-called birth gender just disappears, and it wasn't anywhere near as bad as they thought it would be. other people never lose that side, and in their case that side is most likely a valid part of their identity. but hormone treatment might still make it easier to live in peace with yourself as the genders you are.

don't let anyone tell you what you probably are. statistically everybody is probably cis and heterosexual. but to many trans or homosexuals, that was never even a possibility to be considered. looking at yourself, and not others, what do you think you are? any answer or suggestion is a valid one as long as it's based on your own experience.

Awesome. :)
:icon_flamed:
  •