Susan's Place Logo

News:

According to Google Analytics 25,259,719 users made visits accounting for 140,758,117 Pageviews since December 2006

Main Menu

Expectations of a man

Started by Magnolia88, June 29, 2013, 12:26:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Joanna Dark

Quote from: Heather on June 29, 2013, 05:14:18 PM
Thank you I've kinda gotten to a weird point in my transition were I can still pass as a guy but when present myself in girl mode I'm almost passing or at least I have been told that. Your pretty lucky if I was your size I doubt I would be able to pass as a man anymore either. All the photos you've posted I can't see a guy in any of them and I can't even tell your height either. So combine your feminine face and your smaller frame I doubt you'll ever be able to pass as a man ever again congrats! Wow I just went way off the subject of this thread. :laugh:

Aww thanks so much!
  •  

Tristan

Quote from: Heather on June 29, 2013, 01:14:44 PM
Wow am I like the only one who can fit in with men or women. I've never really had a problem hanging out with men granted the further I go in hrt the more mysterious their behavior is to me. Which also makes them more alluring to me. I don't have a problem conversating with women either. But as far as the topic is concerned expectations don't really bother me since I've never done what was expected of me.  ;)
your not the only one. i try to help with heavy things. im not the best at it and tend to drop stuff but i still try. oh. and i can cut grass and do some car stuff too. not afraid to get a little grease under my nails. but only a little grease
  •  

Jamie D

#22
Quote from: Magnolia88 on June 29, 2013, 12:26:21 AM
One thing I have hard time with is how people expect me to "be a man" since that's what they see on the outside but inside it's the complete opposite. I hate when people talk to me as "one of the guys" or group me with other men. Then there's whole aspect of what is expected of men. For example, I being the only other "male" in the house had to help lift two extremely heavy couches and I have thin arms and very little upper body strength. I struggled with feeling like I shouldn't be asked to do heavy lifting since on the inside, I am female and women shouldn't have to do such things, but also having guilt that I in a male body was complaining about lifting a heavy object when most men would do it willingly. it's very frustrating to live up to what people want me to be as man when I'm not a man. Was I in the wrong or has anyone else ever felt this way?

Don't let artificial gender roles cloud your thinking.  It is true that there is some degree of sexual dimorphism in the human species, and it generally relates to size and strength, but females just as capable as males.

So tell the lazy girls in the house to help out.

  •  

Heather

Quote from: Tristan on June 29, 2013, 06:37:02 PM
your not the only one. i try to help with heavy things. im not the best at it and tend to drop stuff but i still try. oh. and i can cut grass and do some car stuff too. not afraid to get a little grease under my nails. but only a little grease
I tend to drop things more now than I did before. And I can change the oil in my car but that was because my dad got fed up with me having him do it for me so he taught me. And since my job does require some heavy lifting I kinda have to but I think the guys at work can tell I've lost some strength so they help me lift the real heavy things now. :)
  •  

Joanna Dark

Quote from: Sarah84 on June 29, 2013, 05:27:46 PM
And I wasn't  good in any sports. My high school was a hell because of those incompatibilities.

Yeah I wasn't any good either. I was always, always picked last and I basically stopped going. The only real interests I had in high school was literature, music and smoking pot. But it wasn't all bad I hung out with a group of girls and guys and everyone was cool with everyone. But I'm pretty sure people could see stuff was up even then as one time at lunch everyone was talking about what we'd be when we grew up and my two friends (who were girls) both replied at the same time: housewife. lol don't i wish.
  •  

Heather

I was like the complete opposite I didn't play sports because they didn't want me I just choose not to. The coaches literally called my mom and begged her to make me play football. So yeah sports were not a problem with me accept basketball which I suck at!  :laugh:
  •  

Bookworm

I live in an area where there are pretty clear male and female roles. That is not to say that there are not people who bend those. It is more my conservative family as well as my church family. I know that there are not a lot of real female or male roles, but it is still hard for me. I think I blend alright with the male roles, but that does not mean that it is easy. I have grown up with all of this confusion. I had more female friends, that male friends. On the same not I did not have a lot of friends. I could not role with the girls well because of all of my own insecurities and then I never felt all that right with the guys either.
  •  

Lilyyy

don't worry. i feel this way too. i feel like i am a woman but everyone is rough with me and treats me like a boy. I hate myself already and they make it worse. I weigh 50kg and im so delicate. can't they just treat me like a girl already?
<3
  •  

Tristan

heather you missed out on some sports? that sucks. and the guys should be helping you out more now because i hate to admit it but we just are not as strong as they are. Lilyyy i know what you mean. i hate it when i still see some people on my moms side of the family and they are rough with me. that stuff hurts! and not in the good way... >:-)
  •  

Heather

Quote from: Tristan on June 30, 2013, 08:08:17 AM
heather you missed out on some sports? that sucks. and the guys should be helping you out more now because i hate to admit it but we just are not as strong as they are. Lilyyy i know what you mean. i hate it when i still see some people on my moms side of the family and they are rough with me. that stuff hurts! and not in the good way... >:-)
I missed out on football I did play baseball and soccer when I was younger. But I did play football enough with friends to know having people run into me at full speed might not be something I wanted. :laugh: And besides I didn't hangout with the jocks in school in fact they used to try to pick on me. So the thought of having to spend after school time with them was not to appealing to me. But I don't feel like I missed out I got to do other stuff with my friends. And I also got to take advantage of the extra freedom that boys enjoy. My sister was not allowed to do half the stuff I did. In fact after I came out my mom told me she would put the same rules on me. Thinking that would stop me from wanting to be a girl. But I don't think I missed out at all and for some reason now I can look back on my teenage years and see it wasn't as bad as I thought it was.  :)
  •  

Tristan

heather thats to funny. my dad always reminds me he stopped my sleep overs when i was 7 because he thought something was up. and as far as the rules on girls thing. yeah that totally sucks. i still remember those kinda rules. i couldnt do nothing. haha
i guess thats why i was quick to join cheer/soccer and volleyball. im sorry jocks use to pick on you in school. guys can be mean sometimes and the girls can be just as bad if not worse from always starting stuff
  •  

Heather

Quote from: Tristan on June 30, 2013, 10:15:26 AM
guys can be mean sometimes and the girls can be just as bad if not worse from always starting stuff
Yeah I witnessed how mean girls could be when I dated this one girl who wasn't popular but  she was beautiful. So I would have teenage girls coming up to me asking me why I would go out with her. Asking me how I could go out with someone so unpopular. So the girls are just as bad as the boys they just go about it a different way.
  •  

Tristan

yup heather your right. high school was like the gossip game. i was so glad for University. once i became kappa kappa gamma at least i had sisters to protect me so i could just have fun :)
  •  

Mermaid

Quote from: Cassandra Hyacinth on June 29, 2013, 04:51:11 PM
Gender roles in general disgust me to be honest. It's nothing but a means by which women are suppressed for the benefit of men.

Uhm... I don't think that's very true. Men are victims of our mysoginistic society, probably more so than women nowadays... do you think it's in anyone's best interest to feel pressured to control their own emotions, to be expected to be financially succesful and play the role of provider, to be assertive, confident and capable of attracting the opposite gender... I kind of don't think so. Lack of masculinity in a man results in him being shunned, masculine dominant traits in a woman are seen as empowering (I'm refering to assertive self-sufficient qualities, not square jaws, that's what I mean by "masculine woman"). These really aren't the 60s where we need to fight for "women's rights", we need to fight for absolute equality and not make it a war about gender-related privileges.
  •  

Lilyyy

wow, Mermaid. i actually COMPLETELY agree with you. i am transsexual but when i was younger (like 12-13) i always was curious and upset at gender roles. iwanted to have much more feminine gender roles but now that i'm transsexual it will mean that i have an excuse finally. i do want to be a woman for many reasons and this is one of them :)
<3
  •  

Alainaluvsu

It's easier to live as a man, period.

If a man looks raggedy he can get away with it without being chastised by both genders. Let a girl walk in a room wearing something that makes her look fat. Oh, and if a woman can't get a man in todays society, she can at least make it - but she can almost expect to have a mediocre career that IS somewhat based on looks, where men will not take her seriously and women will target her to take her down if she is better at what she does than everybody else. Of course after that is the physical issue, where it still is less safe for a female to walk around by herself, especially at night.

As a man, I could go in and interview and almost expect to walk away with a job. As a woman, I'm hoping it's a guy that thinks I'm attractive. If it's a woman, then she'll likely find a man, if it's a married man, then he'll more than likely pick the lady that his wife isn't going to be threatened by if I'm working with him on a day to day basis, if the interviewer thinks I'm unattractive, they'll probably throw my resume away just because women are suppose to uphold a standard of attractiveness.

And it's not that much easier as an attractive female. If women think you're attractive (especially those 40-50 year old women), they'll feel threatened by you. They'll look at you without a smile and be very evasive of you. Not to mention they'll plot against you. I had a "friend" tell a couple guys that I may be HIV positive (I'm not) just because she saw me as competition. I've also had a "friend" tell a guy I am trans because she liked the guy and the guy liked me. Women are ruthless.

If you're attractive in a mans world, yeah you can smile and make them do whatever. But the next cuter girl that comes in (especially if she's promiscuous), they'll flock to her and totally forget about you, and  you wont get your talking "privileges" back. Any time you talk you'll be dismissed as the not so pretty girl who is just jealous because you're not the cutest thing around.

Being a woman sucks. I wish I was a guy, because I'd rock it if I could.
To dream of the person you would like to be is to waste the person you are.



  •  

Joanna Dark

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PM
Being a woman sucks. I wish I was a guy, because I'd rock it if I could.

You forgot that you're expected to smile all the time and if you aren't smiling people can just outright tell you to. And men just get so close to you and feel they can just go ahead and start violating your personal space. Oh, and the dismissive attitude that you are wrong. They are right.

And I've only been doing this for like six months. But I had about zero male privilege to begin with so it is way better then that.
  •  

Heather

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PM
It's easier to live as a man, period.

If a man looks raggedy he can get away with it without being chastised by both genders. Let a girl walk in a room wearing something that makes her look fat. Oh, and if a woman can't get a man in todays society, she can at least make it - but she can almost expect to have a mediocre career that IS somewhat based on looks, where men will not take her seriously and women will target her to take her down if she is better at what she does than everybody else. Of course after that is the physical issue, where it still is less safe for a female to walk around by herself, especially at night.

As a man, I could go in and interview and almost expect to walk away with a job. As a woman, I'm hoping it's a guy that thinks I'm attractive. If it's a woman, then she'll likely find a man, if it's a married man, then he'll more than likely pick the lady that his wife isn't going to be threatened by if I'm working with him on a day to day basis, if the interviewer thinks I'm unattractive, they'll probably throw my resume away just because women are suppose to uphold a standard of attractiveness.

And it's not that much easier as an attractive female. If women think you're attractive (especially those 40-50 year old women), they'll feel threatened by you. They'll look at you without a smile and be very evasive of you. Not to mention they'll plot against you. I had a "friend" tell a couple guys that I may be HIV positive (I'm not) just because she saw me as competition. I've also had a "friend" tell a guy I am trans because she liked the guy and the guy liked me. Women are ruthless.

If you're attractive in a mans world, yeah you can smile and make them do whatever. But the next cuter girl that comes in (especially if she's promiscuous), they'll flock to her and totally forget about you, and  you wont get your talking "privileges" back. Any time you talk you'll be dismissed as the not so pretty girl who is just jealous because you're not the cutest thing around.

Being a woman sucks. I wish I was a guy, because I'd rock it if I could.
Yeah all this is why I seriously debate if I should ever fully transition.
  •  

Mermaid

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PM
It's easier to live as a man, period.

The way you start your post almost makes it seem like an impossible debate... it's discouraging to discuss anything with anyone who starts by stating that their opinion is a fact. =/

It is not, I'll give it an attempt at explaining why...

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMIf a man looks raggedy he can get away with it without being chastised by both genders.

This is the worst arguement possible. "Men get to look like crap and nobody will say anything"... Is this really an advantage? Who seriously wants to look "raggedy"? Is that supposed to comfort anyone born in the male sex? Perhaps some appreciate it but I'm sure most men out there want to look their best and feel as desirable as their female counterparts. Being able to get away with looking bad isn't a social advantage, it's to balance things out for having a restricted wardrobe with limited clothing expression in comparison to the other sex, for being uncapable of wearing make-up without facing public ridicule, along with a lot of other factors. It simply wouldn't be fair for the same expectations regarding appearence to be equal for men and women... A woman has a pimple? She covers it up with make-up... a man has a pimple? He sucks it up or risks listening to snarky remarks for wearing make-up. I'm sure most people like to feel attractive and cover their flaws... men aren't given as much option regarding this as women are, therefore men have to be cut some slack.

Me, as a person, regardless of what gender I identify with, want to look good. Is it not fulfilling for most people to feel they are good-looking? It is a human need, not a gendered one.

I always wanted to express my own individuality and to seem pleasant to the eye; women have a lot more tools at their disposal for accomplishing this. I got shunned for waxing my legs as a teen, but the fact is that I was simply trying to be comfortable with myself. Of course that on the other side you have women that will get laughed at if their legs are hairy... my opinion? A man should be able to be as pretty as a woman if he desired to, a man should be able to get rid of every single hair on his body if that's what he aspires to, a woman should be entitled to have a forest under her arm-pits if that's what she wanted. It's basically freedom of expression. Just don't tell men "being able to look raggedy" is something to be thankful for, when most of us know how fun it is to get all dolled up. I will stress again that feeling attractive is a human need, not a gendered one, so men should groom themselves all they want if it makes them feel good and fulfilled. Men have a lot less to look forward to when it comes to pampering themselves and feeling good about themselves... Some men are okay with this, some are not; people are people, not genders. The way I see it, things come down to whether you feel good expressing femininity, masculinity or a blend of both.

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMLet a girl walk in a room wearing something that makes her look fat. Oh, and if a woman can't get a man in todays society, she can at least make it - but she can almost expect to have a mediocre career that IS somewhat based on looks, where men will not take her seriously and women will target her to take her down if she is better at what she does than everybody else.

I think that's a huge exaggeration... there are problems, but I don't think any gender is antagonized that dramatically. Have you ever wondered why women are taken "less seriously" in their workplace? It's to do with the false assumption that they're more emotional beings, whereas men are more likely to suck it up, "be men" and "man their way through it". Men inspire more confidence in workplaces, which is absurd if you ask me... Like I said, people are people, there's a lot of women who're better leaders and more competent than men at any given task and vice-versa. The thing is men are emotional creatures too and if society acknowledged that fact as much as it does with women, there'd be less gender-stereotyping and stupid assumptions being made. Now, it must be stressed that only certain profiles are capable of holding positions of leadership, because they generally involve more masculine traits, such as dominance, power, assertiveness and such. Women can and possess these traits, it's just sort of expected that men are more likely to possess them because society lives on the pathetic assumption that masculinity = men and femininity = women.

I would respect fellow co-workers regardless of their gender and try to make no assumptions of their personality, however, it's a bit of an automated process to question their seriousness if they were say, for example, parading themselves around the office in revealing clothing, which women are much more likely to get away with. I hate generalizations but, to my eyes, it's a little undeniable that women are way more free to exert their sensuality to get ahead and gain attention, whereas men tend to have to downplay themselves and rely solely on their skills. Again, I'm not saying this is commonplace or not, I'm a student and never worked in my life, but the impression I have of society as a whole is that women have the option to exploit their sensuality to get ahead way more than men do, and as such, a whole gender loses a certain amount of credibility. I think it's a defensive mechanism to respond to the way society works...


Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMAs a man, I could go in and interview and almost expect to walk away with a job. As a woman, I'm hoping it's a guy that thinks I'm attractive. If it's a woman, then she'll likely find a man, if it's a married man, then he'll more than likely pick the lady that his wife isn't going to be threatened by if I'm working with him on a day to day basis, if the interviewer thinks I'm unattractive, they'll probably throw my resume away just because women are suppose to uphold a standard of attractiveness.

To me that sounds almost dellusional and insulting to most men and women... I don't think people are hired based on what they look like, nor that whoever is hiring people for a specific job is necessarily interested in who they're hiring, that sounds almost disgusting... there's a point in life where people settle down to raise a family and don't really care what their coworkers look like as long as they're competent? I don't think high school mentalities really stick around with most individuals? People have their own relationships and won't be forever seeking to surround themselves with good-looking people, come on...

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMAnd it's not that much easier as an attractive female. If women think you're attractive (especially those 40-50 year old women), they'll feel threatened by you. They'll look at you without a smile and be very evasive of you. Not to mention they'll plot against you. I had a "friend" tell a couple guys that I may be HIV positive (I'm not) just because she saw me as competition. I've also had a "friend" tell a guy I am trans because she liked the guy and the guy liked me. Women are ruthless.

I think it's more that people are ruthless, rather than women being ruthless... There's good and bad people in both genders, it's not strictly a problem with women. Men are just as competitive in my experience, just the modus operandi of each sex is different because of their roles in society.

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMIf you're attractive in a mans world, yeah you can smile and make them do whatever. But the next cuter girl that comes in (especially if she's promiscuous), they'll flock to her and totally forget about you, and  you wont get your talking "privileges" back. Any time you talk you'll be dismissed as the not so pretty girl who is just jealous because you're not the cutest thing around.

You're basically implying all men are whores -.- That's not been my experience... so many guys just want to settle down with one person and aren't on an everlasting chase for the perfect woman... *sigh* But whatever. I'm not saying it doesn't happen, but will a guy who's in love really keep looking for other girls just because they might be more attractive than the person he loves? I don't know, maybe it happened to you or your experiences have been frustrating, but everyone has feelings, regardless if they're men or women, and that's what drives them... perhaps if someone moves away from you and onto someone else it's because there was no chemistry in the first place...

Quote from: Alainaluvsu on June 30, 2013, 11:09:22 PMBeing a woman sucks. I wish I was a guy, because I'd rock it if I could.

How about detransition? If not, I don't really think you "wish you were a guy". People (specially cis) say they wish they were the opposite sex far too frequently and far too unaware of the global picture... the grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.

There are gay guys, there are masculine guys, there are feminine guys, there are guys who want to be strong, there are guys who want to be next to someone strong. Some have it easier than others in our society, a "guy" is an abstract concept, because they're essentially people and being human is what's hard, not being a gender.

I'm not sure if my views are a bit radical, I hope not... but I do not see myself as a "woman" or a "man", I am not a box, I see myself as a person with feminine tendencies that must live as a woman to be able to fit the molds of society and coexist at peace with everyone else without receiving weird looks. I think it's a mistake to see people as women or men, because everyone is unique and nobody should make assumptions about what satisfies anyone or grants them fulfillment. I don't know how one can feel they are a "gender", I just feel me.

I'm more comfortable as a woman, which in turn should make me one, but that's not what I'm trying to be; I feel it's too dull and empty to only aspire to becoming a gender. I think we all are a lot more than that =)
  •  

Catalina

Quote from: Magnolia88 on June 29, 2013, 12:26:21 AM
One thing I have hard time with is how people expect me to "be a man" since that's what they see on the outside but inside it's the complete opposite. I hate when people talk to me as "one of the guys" or group me with other men. Then there's whole aspect of what is expected of men. For example, I being the only other "male" in the house had to help lift two extremely heavy couches and I have thin arms and very little upper body strength. I struggled with feeling like I shouldn't be asked to do heavy lifting since on the inside, I am female and women shouldn't have to do such things, but also having guilt that I in a male body was complaining about lifting a heavy object when most men would do it willingly. it's very frustrating to live up to what people want me to be as man when I'm not a man. Was I in the wrong or has anyone else ever felt this way?

I think women can lift as well as men. But there are some physiological differences that make it more difficult for women to lift heavier objects. I will lift and carry when I need to, but only according to my capacity. Men just can naturally carry more than I can!

When I was younger, I also hated being stereotyped because of my appearance. Now it is almost expected (willingly or unwillingly) that men carry first before me. I hated carrying things in the past, not because it was a chore, but it was somehow a sexual trait that wasn't obvious in my own very being!
"Live fully, love wastefully, and be all that you can be."
-- Bishop Spong
  •