Hey Brandon, I'll just add in that all people at some point in their lives feel as if they don't fit in somewhere. Like Malachite said, you might want to check out different churches, but expect that when going to any new congregation that it will take time to fit in. It's a process of getting to know people and comfortable with your new surroundings.
However, even though the sense of community is very important in religion, it's also important to remember that the point of worship is not only about having friends at church, it's about having a connection with the Creator. If you enjoy the sermons, beliefs espoused by that church, and so on, don't feel too badly if the only negative is that you don't feel as if you fit in with the other members of the congregation. At the end of the day, you want to please God, not other members of the congregation.